Discussions in Dispute Resolution

Introduction Table of Contributors Acknowledgments Part 1. Negotiation Article 1.1. Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law: The Case of Divorce (1979)--Robert H. Mnookin and Lewis Kornhauser Comments: Elizabeth C. Tippett--Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law: The Case for ADR as a Field of Study Rebecca Hollander-Blumoff--Taking Human Behavior Seriously Rishi Batra--Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law: A Classic Article with a Contemporary Challenge Robert H. Mnookin--Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law Re-assessed Article 1.2. Machiavelli and the Bar: Ethical Limitations on Lying in Negotiation (1980)--James J. White Comments: Michael Moffitt--Machiavelli and the Bar and Ethical Ratcheting Peter R. Reilly--Machiavelli and the Bar: J.J. White as Negotiation Ethics Architect Lauren A. Newell--Machiavelli and the Bar: Prescient in Part James J. White--Confronting Lying in Negotiation Article 1.3. Toward Another View of Legal Negotiation: The Structure of Problem Solving (1984)--Carrie Menkel-Meadow Comments: Russell Korobkin--We Are All Problem Solvers Now Erin R. Archerd--It's Not the Lawyers We Need to Convince: Commentary on Legal Negotiation by Carrie Menkel-Meadow Andrea Kupfer Schneider--Counseling About More than the Law Carrie Menkel-Meadow--The Origins of Problem Solving Negotiation and Its Use in the Present Article 1.4. The Limits of Integrative Bargaining (1996)--Gerald B. Wetlaufer Comments: Jennifer Reynolds--Oversimplifying, Overselling, Overreaching Noam Ebner--Integrative Negotiation: Paying the Price of Popularity Robert C. Bordone--Strengthening Integrative Bargaining: How The Limits of Integrative Bargaining Sharpened the Work of Negotiation Scholars Gerald B. Wetlaufer--Reflections on The Limits of Integrative Bargaining Part 2. Mediation Article 2.1. Mediation: Its Forms and Functions (1971)--Lon L. Fuller Comments: Art Hinshaw--Lon L. Fuller: Private Ordering and Mediation Nancy A. Welsh--The Untethering of Mediation from Relationships James J. Alfini--Lon Fuller's Influence on the Debate Over Mediator Orientations Becky L. Jacobs--Lon Fuller: A Progenitor of the Pedagogy of Skills? Article 2.2. The Theory and Practice of Mediation: A Reply to Professor Susskind (1981)--Joseph B. Stulberg Comments: Lela Porter Love--A Star to Steer Her By Brian A. Pappas--Just Settlement? Rethinking the Mediator's Goals Bobbi McAdoo and Sharon Press--Neutrality in 2020: A Reply to 1981 Stulberg Joseph B. Stulberg--Revisiting Mediator Neutrality Article 2.3. The Mediation Alternative: Process Dangers for Women (1991)--Trina Grillo Comments: Carol Pauli--Trina Grillo: Productive Rage Karen Tokarz--Grillo's Rigorous Path to Intentional, Mindful Mediation Douglas N. Frenkel--The Grillo Effect at Thirty Kelly Browe Olson--Post-Grillo: New Family Mediation Protections and Revised Dangers Article 2.4. Understanding Mediators' Orientations, Strategies, and Techniques: A Grid for the Perplexed (1996)--Leonard L. Riskin Comments: Michael T. Colatrella, Jr.--"True Enough" Alyson Carrel--Dismantling the "Facilitative" "Evaluative" Dichotomy: Reflecting on Riskin's Grid and Predicting the Future Donna Erez-Navot--The Riskin Grid: A Mixed Legacy Kimberlee Kovach--Growth from the Grid? Part 3. Arbitration Article 3.1. The New Federal Arbitration Law (1926)--Julius Henry Cohen and Kenneth Dayton Comments: Carli N. Conklin--A Robust History of Arbitration in Early America: Commentary on The New Federal Arbitration Law Imre S. Szalai--The Federal Arbitration Act in Its Infancy: Cohen and Dayton's The New Federal Arbitration Law Kristen Blankley--The New Federal Arbitration Law: A Call to Ethical Practice Not Yet Realized Amy J. Schmitz--Emphasizing Efficiency in the Digital Age Article 3.2. Commercial Arbitration (1961)--Soia Mentschikoff Comments: Sarah R. Cole--Everything Old Is New Again W. Mark C. Weidemaier--The Legacy of Soia Mentschikoff's Commercial Arbitration David Horton--Inside the Black Box: A Short Comment on Soia Mentschikoff's Commercial Arbitration Stephen J. Ware--Lasting Lessons from Mentschikoff's Commercial Arbitration Article 3.3. Panacea or Corporate Tool?: Debunking the Supreme Court's Preference for Binding Arbitration (1996)--Jean R. Sternlight Comments: Jill I. Gross--Rethinking the Debunking: On Arbitration Myths, Preferences, and Legal Theory Hiro N. Aragaki--The Critical Theory Legacy of Jean Sternlight's Panacea or Corporate Tool? Michael Z. Green--Framing the Debate to Show How Big Guys Insist That Little Guys Arbitrate as a Corporate Tool Jean R. Sternlight--Panacea or Corporate Tool?: The Sequel Article 3.4. Employment Arbitration: The Repeat Player Effect (1997)--Lisa B. Bingham [Lisa Blomgren Amsler] Comments: Alexander J.S. Colvin--The River's Source: Empirical Research and Lisa Blomgren Amsler's Employment Arbitration: The Repeat Player Effect Martin H. Malin--Arbitration's Catalyst for Empirical Studies Richard Bales--The Historical Context of Lisa Blomgren Amsler's Empirical Work on Employment Arbitration Lisa Blomgren Amsler--Why the Haves Come Out Farther and Farther Ahead: The Repeat Player Effect, Control Over Dispute System Design, and Justice Part 4. Dispute Resolution Public Policy Article 4.1. Why the "Haves" Come out Ahead: Speculations on the Limits of Legal Change (1974)--Marc Galanter Comments: John Lande--For Pragmatic Romanticism in Law and Dispute Resolution: Reflections on Galanter's Remarkably Realistic Analysis of Why the Have-Nots Come Out Behind Dwight Golann--A Prescient Warning of the Vulnerabilities in ADR Cynthia Alkon--Galanter's Analysis of the "Limits of Legal Change" as Applied to Criminal Cases and Reform Marc Galanter--Reflections on Why the "Haves" Come Out Ahead Article 4.2. Varieties of Dispute Processing (1976)--Frank E. A. Sander Comments: Donna Shestowsky--How Useful Is Court ADR If Litigants (Still) Don't Know About It? Lydia Nussbaum--Dispute Processing Beyond the Courts-New Complexity, Old Problems Deborah Thompson Eisenberg--Frank Sander: Father of Court-Based Dispute Resolution Yael Efron--Varieties of Dispute Processing: The Implications on Legal Education Article 4.3. Against Settlement (1984)--Owen M. Fiss Comments: Amy J. Cohen--ADR and Public Values Again Ellen Waldman--What Against Settlement Got Right Adam S. Zimmerman--From Mass Adjudication to Settlement and Back Marjorie Corman Aaron--The Haunting Specter of Fiss's Against Settlement Article 4.4. Pursuing Settlement in an Adversary Culture: A Tale of Innovation Co-Opted or "The Law of ADR" (1991)--Carrie Menkel-Meadow Comments: Ellen E. Deason--Dimensions of Quality of Justice Elayne E. Greenberg--ADR's Place at the Justice Table James Coben--Foundational Because Prescient (and Unfortunately, Cassandra-like Prescience) Carrie Menkel-Meadow--Institutionalizing ADR: Clashing Values