Citizenship as Foundation of Rights

Rezensionen / Stimmen

'I followed the stages of this book when it was in process and when it was completed for publication. At each time I saw it's importance. I was pleased to recognize that in the Foreword to the book. Now it is in hand. And current American politics make it an even more significant book for an understanding of the United States as a political and social system. The nature of Citizenship - its centrality in elections and in politics and society more generally - make it a crucial feature of American Democracy and the challenge it faces.' Sid Verba, Carl H. Pforzheimer University Professor, Harvard University 'On November 8, 2016, the American electorate chooses between very different views of immigration policy, national security, the First, Second, Fourth and Fourteen Amendments, and other issues related to American citizenship and the rights and obligations flowing from that situation. Dr. Sobel makes timely and significant contributions to our understanding of the foundations and historical development of these issues. Citizenship as Foundation of Rights is an essential resource for an informed electorate, and it provides a meaningful framework for post-election analysis.' Edward Baskauskas, Golden Gate University School of Law, San Francisco 'A powerful argument for the concept of citizenship and the rights associated with it.' Thomas E. Patterson, Bradlee Professor of Government and the Press, Harvard University, Massachusetts 'A very good, incisive, well-written study. It is well worth spending the time to read, a fine book. The research is tops, information of high value for anyone inquisitive about citizenship matters. I could acclaim it to everyone.' Edward L. Deam, Professor Emeritus, University of Illinois, Chicago 'The book ... gives a concise and yet comprehensive overview of the basic rights that American citizenship provides, the basic concepts that have been incorporated into law in structuring American citizenship over time, and particularly today. So anyone looking for a clear and concise understanding of how American citizenship has been, or is currently legally constructed will find this book of great value. Another of the valuable things that [this relatively brief and therefore accessible] book does is, in mapping out rights of citizenship, [is] focusing primarily ... on right to vote, right to travel, and right to work. There's more in the book, but even bringing these three together is a valuable ... contribution since they're not all discussed as fundamental pillars of citizenship in many works. In particular, the right to travel is one that tends to have been treated as more marginal than it should have been, given its centrality in civil rights struggles in this country in particular periods, as Richard brings out.' Rogers Smith, 'Author Meets Critics', Midwest Political Science Association 'Sobel['s] argument for empowering citizenship [is] that American citizenship is constituted in fundamentally empowering political and related rights. These rights, like ... employment, travel and vote, are exercisable per force of citizenship ... Sobel's key focus is citizenship vs. the state ... that there is a tenuous struggle for power between citizens that want to exercise their agency and the state which seeks to control and regulate state power ... He is concerned with the acquisition of political rights with the presupposition of possessing American citizenship in order to resist authoritative practices by the state ... Sobel ... offers a reading of citizenship through an American context. His work will be of great interest to scholars focusing on American politics and citizenship. [He] provides a concise and cogent argument for empowering citizenship ... realized by three key rights: ... employment, travel and work.' James Nguyen, Citizenship Studies '[An] identification regime is inconsistent with ... underpinnings of U.S. citizenship [as] requiring ... proof of citizenship inverts the American democratic enterprise. This argument is ... insightful ... advances our understanding of American citizenship ... [and] reinvigorates the citizenship inquiry ...' D. Carolina Nidfiez, Tulsa Law Review