Ireland's Magdalen Laundries and the Nation's Architecture of Containment

Rezensionen / Stimmen

"A study of workhouses operated by Roman Catholic nuns and housing unmarried mothers and other girls and women perceived to be a threat to the morality of Irish society; focuses on 10 in operation between 1922 and 1996." -The Chronicle of Higher Education

"Ireland's Magdalen Laundries is a historical, political and cultural account of how asylums run for wayward girls turned into prisons in which human rights were violated and bodies and souls abused. Smith's book is ... passionate, insightful, factual, and unnerving. Students of Irish history, sociologists, critics of Church/State relations and perhaps the simply curious may find Ireland's Magdelen Laundries a compelling analysis of a public scandal." -St. Anthony Messenger

"[Smith] clearly describes the relationship between the laundries and the policies of Ireland after its independence in 1922, and pays special attention to the recent plays, movies, documentaries, and monuments that brought these Magdalen laundries into the public arena. This is a provocative work that will force people to come to terms with the abuses long hidden in Ireland's past." -Church History

"This book is a well-balanced and interdisciplinary exploration of historical events and creative expression, especially interesting for research into the retrieval of suppressed history and the elements that dismantle repressive social frameworks. The book is an excellent critical discussion of various forms of historical representation and creative intervention. Smith's exploration of women's responses to the historical elision of reality merits consideration by academics and researchers in a number of fields across the humanities and social sciences. The text would make an excellent addition to university libraries." -Gender, Place, and Culture

"[Smith] provides readers with the first attempt at a comprehensive history of the institutions in Ireland. His scholarship aims to continue the work of others in chipping away at the national amnesia regarding the place of the Magdalens, to bring them to the centre of public discourse from the concealment of their margins. The study reaches beyond the ivory tower into the larger society, becoming not just useful for other researchers but also a rare example of academic activism at its best." -Irish Studies Review

"This richly argued and impeccably researched study focuses on ten Magdalen laundries that operated in Ireland between 1922 and 1996. . . . As an admirably interdisciplinary work that treats the history of the laundries alongside their representation in recent culture, Smith also seeks to draw attention to a very painful aspect of contemporary Irish history. This is an important work that deserves wide reading." -Choice

"Smith's historical research is thorough and detailed . . . an important and stimulating book, and it is in the discussion of cultural representations of Magdalen laundries that Smith is strongest. His literary and cultural studies background is evident as he discusses the range of cultural responses to the laundries, including drama, both stage and film, documentary, art work, and music." -Cultural and Social History

" . . . Smith raises some important issues about the relationship between empiricism, memory, and history. The social and sexual transformation of the country within the last twenty years has ensured that the history of Irish sexuality has become a growth industry, and both Luddy's and Smith's meticulously researched, highly readable and elegantly produced books have been well received." -Irish Review

"Ireland's Magdalen Laundries adds a vital strand to the emerging narratives of the laundries. In addition to carefully documenting available material from State archives, Smith also explores contemporary cultural representations of the laundries, from the film, The Magdalen Sisters, to art projects, such as those by Diane Fenster and Gerard Mannix Flynn, whose Far Cry Productions has brought Smith to Limerick for a lecture on the book." -The Irish Times