Ethics with Barth: God, Metaphysics and Morals

Rezensionen / Stimmen

'In this engaging work, Rose makes the bold proposal that Barth's ethics is best read in line with Catholic concerns: to live morally and well is to live in conformity with human nature as that is determined by God's dealings with us. Taking its cue from some of the best Catholic scholarship on Barth, this book is simply among the most important treatments of Barth's ethics to date, and should therefore be of interest to all students of this enormously influential twentieth-century theologian.' Kathryn Tanner, Yale Divinity School, USA 'Does grace overcome nature or perfect it? The consequences of neither answer to this ancient question have been satisfactory. It is a fundamental move of Barth's theology, and one endemically overlooked, to say why this is so: the question presumes a nature antecedent to grace, whereas in fact the grace of Christ is the antecedent of nature. In no field of Barth-interpretation has missing that move been more disastrous than in the attempt to make sense of his ethics. Matthew Rose's brilliant book remedies this situation, in principle and in meticulous detail.' Robert W. Jenson, Princeton, USA 'Rose's book is an interesting thought experiment. He points to surprising features such as the eudaimonism in CD II/2 and III/4. Furthermore, he seeks a basis for communal moral discernment, which should not be dismissed too easily. Rose is helpful in that he combines in one book the dogmatic interpretation of Barth by von Balthasar and the ethical interpretation by Biggar, both of which Rose identifies as his main inspirations.' Journal of Theological Studies 'Rose's Ethics with Barth: God, Metaphysics and Morals is an attractive text for two particular groups of readers. First, for those interested in Christian ethics generally, and those interested in natural law or eudaemonist approaches to ethics specifically, it offers a stimulating account of how God relates to the moral coherence of the world and the fulfillment of human nature.