Fidelity Rebates in Competition Law

This book examines the treatment of fdelity rebates as one of the most controversial topics in EU competition law. The controversy arose from the lack of clarity as to how to distinguish between rebates that constitute a legitimate business practice and those that might have anticompetitive e?ects, as the same type of rebates could be pro-competitive or anticompetitive depending on their e?ects on competition. This book clarifes the appropriate treatment of fdelity rebates under EU competition law by o?ering original insights on the way in which abusive rebates should be identifed, taking into account the wealth of EU case law in this area, the economics' literature and the perspective of US antitrust law. The critical discussion on the case law is centred on the idea as to whether the as efcient competitor (AEC) test is an important part of the assessment of fdelity rebates and in which circumstances it could be used as one tool among others.The analysis treats such issues and topics as the following:

- - What motivated the EU Courts to treat fdelity rebates as illegal 'by object'?

- - Why has this case law drawn so much criticism from academics and other commentators?

- - What can we learn from the economic theories of exclusive dealing and fdelity rebates, and
whether the strict approach of the Courts can be supported by economic empirical studies?

- - What is the meaning attached to the notion of an 'e?ects-based' approach as an expression
of the reform of Article 102?

- - Why is the controversy regarding the treatment of fdelity rebates still a live issue after the Intel
and the Post Danmark II judgments?

- - In which circumstances the price-cost test can be used as a reliable tool to distinguish
between anticompetitive and pro-competitive fdelity rebates?

- - Can we evaluate the e?ect of fdelity rebates without necessarily carrying out a price-cost
test?

- - Can we consider the AEC test as a single unifying test for all types of exclusionary abuses?

- - What can we learn about the application of the AEC test in fdelity rebate cases from the
recent US case law?

A concluding chapter provides an original perspective and also policy recommendations on how the abusive character of fdelity rebates should be assessed including an appropriate legal test that is administrable, creates predictability and legal certainty and minimises the risk of errors and the cost of those mistakes.
This book takes a giant step towards improving the understanding of the legal treatment of fdelity rebates and understanding as to whether the treatment of fdelity rebates could be e?ects-based, without necessarily carrying out an AEC test. It will also contribute signifcantly to the practical work of enforcement agencies, courts and private entities and their advisors. book's parallel study of US and EU competition law.