The Construction of Fatherhood

Rezensionen / Stimmen

'To my taste, this book is an exemplary piece of scholarship. It provides a nuanced critical analysis of case law of the European Court of Human Rights, focused on its construction of fatherhood. In doing so, the book simultaneously offers theoretical depth and the solid grounding in realities that is characteristic of excellent socio-legal scholarship. A valuable addition to human rights law, family law, and law and gender studies.' Eva Brems, Universiteit Gent 'In this wonderful volume Alice Margaria engages the fascinating social and legal evolution of concepts of fatherhood that challenge gender categories, masculinities, partnership, family and the meaning of parenthood amidst profound change in the lived realities of men and children.' Nancy E. Dowd, David H. Levin Chair in Family Law, University of Florida 'Starting from a well-designed theoretical framework, Alice Margaria has meticulously drawn a crystal-clear overview of the construction of fatherhood by the ECtHR following social change. She then carefully unfolds her critical insights to demonstrate how the ECtHR could, and really should, move beyond conventional fatherhood in a consistent way. The multi-faceted analyses in this book offer both in-depth understanding of the ECtHR's case-law, and insight in its power to produce - and not only to reproduce - the law. The result is an indispensable roadmap for current and future socio-legal scholarship on fatherhood.' Frederik Swennen, Universiteit Antwerpen 'This book is a welcome contribution to a very topical area. Margaria's analysis and critique of the ECtHR jurisprudence is thorough and engaging: it focuses on different situations that can affect fathers and sheds light on the opportunities and obstacles that they encounter when seeking to be carers. Ultimately, this book reflects on the role that 'moral decisions' play in our society and, as such, offers a remarkable framework to analyse the situations of fathers.' Eugenia Caracciolo di Torella, University of Leicester 'Alice Margaria offers a masterfully nuanced reading and analysis of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights regarding parenthood, particularly how the Court positions itself when it comes to (re)defining fatherhood. This book is nothing short of a jewel - the author knows how to allow a highly complex, dynamic and technical theme to unfold gradually and naturally. In doing so, she has produced a 'tour de force' that is both highly enlightening and genuinely exciting to read. At the same time, she makes it clear that the adventure of legally (re)defining fatherhood and all that it implies is only just beginning. This book is a must read for anyone interested in new forms of parenting and how they engage with and fit into the law - a process that is not without its own very unique set of challenges and complications.' Marie-Claire Foblets, Managing Director Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology 'This is a well-constructed book, which offers a thoughtful and novel argument about the construction of fatherhood at the ECtHR [European Court of Human Rights], grounded in a detailed consideration of the jurisprudence of the Court itself. The exploration of the dual influences of the Court's interpretive strictures and underlying moral values regarding the nature of fatherhood is particularly insightful. Indeed, the book is a welcome addition to the literature on the legal understanding of fatherhood and the role of the father.' Alan Brown, International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 'Alice Margaria has written a truly valuable contribution to human rights law, family law, and law and gender literature. This book offers a deeper understanding of the ECtHR and its doctrines besides a rich discussion on fatherhood in its evolving forms. Moreover, this book is an enjoyable read, the arguments and analysis unfolding with apparent ease and a clear progression.' Matilda Merenmies, European Journal of Legal Studies 'Margaria remains conscious, though, of the limits of what the cases can show her and ... she resists misshaping her data to make it tidy ... Striking in its methodological and theoretical ambition, Margaria's The Construction of Fatherhood will advance reflection and debate on critical questions in family law and judicial methodology.' Robert Leckey, Social and Legal Studies 'Not only socio-legal scholars will truly benefit from reading this excellent study. (Legal) gender studies scholars will also discover many valuable insights here, especially with regard to the phenomenon of legal ambivalence.' Petra Sussner, European Convention on Human Rights Law Review 2