The Beam and the Mote

Acknowledgements Introduction 1. Topic and main aims 2. Structure 3. Significance Chapter 1: Hypocritical blame 1. Introduction 2. When is blame hypocritical? 2.1 The blaming condition 2.2 The incoherence condition 2.3 The no-self-blame condition 2.4 The no-justification condition 2.5 Summary 3. Standing to blame and its denial 4. Other accounts of what it is to dismiss blame on grounds of the hypocrite's lack of standing 5. Conclusion Chapter 2: Complications and defeaters of standing 1. Introduction 2. Private blame 3. Self-blame 4. Third-person blame 5. Degrees of blame and degrees of standing 6. Skepticism about standing to blame 7. Why does hypocrisy undermine standing to blame? 8. Conclusion Chapter 3: What, if anything, makes hypocritical blame morally wrong? 1. Introduction 2. Lack of desert 3. Lack of commitment 4. Wrong attention 5. Transgression of moral authority 6. Failure of reciprocity 7. Moral community 8. Implying falsehoods 9. A clash with moral equality 10. Conclusion Chapter 4: Other ways of not having standing to blame 1. Introduction 2. Tu quoque 3. Complicity 4. None of your business 5. ?You don't know what it's like? 6. ?You don't accept that principle yourself? 7. Conclusion Chapter 5: Praising 1. Introduction 2. What is praising? 3. Standing to praise 4. Hypocritical praise 5. The wrongfulness of hypocritical praise 6. Other forms of standingless praise 7. Standing to prame 8. Conclusion Chapter 6: Forgiving 1. Introduction 2. What is it to forgive? 3. Dismissing forgiveness as standingless 4. Hypocritical forgiving 5. What undermines standing to forgive? 6. The wrongfulness of hypocritical forgiveness 7. Other ways in which forgiving can be standingless 8. Fromtaking 9. Conclusion 10. Appendix: Forgiving and standing to apologize Chapter 7: Morality, normativity, and standing 1. Introduction 2. Encouraging 3. Epistemic blame 4. Consequentialism, deontology, and the interpersonal nature of holding accountable 5. Standing and moral encroachment 6. Conclusion Bibliography Index