The Critic in the Modern World

Rezensionen / Stimmen

The Critic in the Modern World is an exceptionally intelligent and well-written study, showing how some of the greatest English-language critics have engaged with literature and the world. Like the critics he writes about, Ley is addressing not the specialist but the generally educated reader, and anyone who cares about the tradition of criticism will find him a rewarding and enlightening guide. Ley (Univ. of Western Sydney; editor, Sydney Review of Books) sets out to trace the history of the public literary critic by examining the work of six influential and representative men: Samuel Johnson, William Hazlitt, Matthew Arnold, T.S. Eliot, Lionel Trilling, and James Wood. Combining analysis of the critics' ideas with relevant pieces of their biographies and cultural and historical context, these essays explore the practice and influence of the public judge (as opposed to the academic one). Each piece can stand alone, but the work reads best chronologically as Ley compares and contrasts the ideas of each critic to his predecessors....Thoughtful and well written, Ley's study covers nearly 300 years of literary history. He deftly moves the reader from Johnson's neoclassical stance through romanticism, modernism, and the present-day secular position of Wood. * Library Journal * Just when you think critics must be among the most tedious people on the planet, along comes a book such as James Ley's The Critic in the Modern World to gently remind you this is not the case. [...] Ley has done something remarkable with this little book. Without over-relying on the biographical, he shows how much is at stake in the posture of critic. He has taken six well-known figures and revealed how, in their own way, pat-rician, slovenly, reserved or pugnacious, they created the platform that is so broad and free now, we can almost take it for granted. * The Australian * "The Critic in the Modern World is a lucid, exciting, finely tuned, and elegant work of literary criticism that you won't want to put down. At some points you want to argue with the author, at others you are quietly trying to keep up, at others again simply admiring. To paraphrase Ley's salute to James Wood, this is a fine achievement and one that is a product of this twenty-first-century literary moment. * Australian Book Review * An entertaining study ... Mr. Ley's mission, it turns out, is to systematize the spontaneous opinion-brokering of which most criticism consists... his attempt to authenticate the position played by the critic in modern life consists in subjugating six of the past quarter-millennium's best-known literary critics to a series of interrogations as to what they stand for, what view they take of books and, if only by implication, what view they take of life itself. * Wall Street Journal *