Marx's Capital, Capitalism and Limits to the State

Rezensionen / Stimmen

*2024 Winner of the 'Distinguished Achievement Award in Political Economy for the 21st Century' awarded by the World Association for Political Economy*

"[A] major theoretical contribution. In the process of patiently pointing out the problems of current state theory, Das develops both a rigorous defence and a convincing update of the ideas developed by Marx, Engels, and subsequent revolutionary Marxists about the state...Raju Das has done us a favour by taking on these ideas in a serious way and by recovering and reconstituting a Marxist approach to the state. The left urgently needs to take it to heart."

Chris Nineham, Counterfire

"Raju Das has written a magisterial study of Marx's Capital and the Marxist theory of the state. But lest the reader suspect that this is "yet another" reworking of a huge already-existing literature, know that its author has important polemical strings to his bow: The state is not a "place" separated from class, class struggle and capitalist production/reproduction; it is, rather, an intrinsic element of that mix. It is not a neutral site on which different class forces confront one another; but neither can it be reduced to a passive outcome of a spontaneous accumulation process. And Marx's masterwork, Capital, is not, as sometimes thought, largely silent on the state: It contains crucial guides to analysis of the state in all of its manifestations: relation to class, state forms (geographic, bureaucratic), imperialism and the global periphery; the roles and agency of various actors (capitalists, workers, state managers), and much more. While Das is a strong advocate for the centrality of the Marxist classics to clear revolutionary thinking, he is not an unthoughtful one; Marx, Engels, Lenin and legions of contemporary writers all come in for careful, and sometimes critical, evaluation. You may not agree with everything you find here, but it will make you ponder and reflect, and there is no way anyone could miss the relevance of this study to the crises and potentials of today's world."

David Laibman Editor, Science & Society, and Professor Emeritus of Economics at Brooklyn College and the Graduate Center, City University of New York

"Raju Das has written an important and provocative book about the state as the concentrated power and coercive force of capitalist society. He argues with Lenin beyond Lenin about the politics of capitalist wealth and the politics of the poor and miserable. What is done and what can be done? His reconstitution of Marxist state theory provides an imaginative explanation of the role of the state in capitalist society and in a socialist politics of the working class."

Professor Werner Bonefeld, Department of Politics, University of York, UK

"This book is a major contribution to our understanding of the capitalist state. In a series of powerful arguments, Raju J. Das urges us to see the state in terms of its internal relation to capital. This is a challenging and illuminating work that should become essential reading for everyone concerned with Marxist theory and practice.

David McNally, NEH Cullen Chair in History and Business, University of Houston