Polyphony in Medieval Paris

Rezensionen / Stimmen

'Catherine A. Bradley's superb new book takes us back to the world of medieval Paris where musicians and poets were experimenting with the ways in which plainsong, polyphony, rithmus and the conventions of liturgical and paraliturgical celebration could be combined, differentiated and subverted. She does this by returning to the venerable question of the birth of the motet, and cognate genres. On the way, she brilliantly reminds us of the importance of the female voice in some unlikely places and, in a virtuosic side glance at the relationship between organum and clausula, comes close to uncovering an entirely new subgenre. Magisterial in every regard.' Mark Everist, University of Southampton 'Polyphony in Medieval Paris brings a much-needed analytical perspective to thirteenth-century polyphony. With exceptional acumen, Bradley challenges prevailing narratives about how this repertory emerged and offers fresh insights into the priorities and choices of its composers. Through the new analytical approaches she develops, she also deepens our understanding of issues as diverse as intertextuality and gender.' Rebecca Maloy, University of Colorado, Boulder 'Bradley's book unsettles received views of the thirteenth-century motet and impresses by its powerful combined methodology of incisive musical analysis, and consideration of the material and notational trace. She animates the skilled and serious playfulness of nameless medieval composer-singers, authoritatively exemplifying the broad range of precise and technically advanced skills necessary to engage these fascinating and compositionally complex pieces of music ... Of particular note is Bradley's combination of detailed philological inquiry with creative musical imagination. Her hermeneutic lens challenges traditional understandings of the evolution of the motet genre, finding a surprising degree of bi-directional fluidity. This reframing has significant value for broader considerations of compositional process, musical borrowing, and intertextuality in and beyond medieval Paris.' Official citation for 2019 Early Music Prize, American Musicological Society Awards Committee '... this remarkable study ... constitutes an undeniably important contribution to the revival of musicological thought on the motet of Ars Antiqua ... the reader will be rewarded by the beautiful immersion it offers in the workshop polyphonic writing of the thirteenth century, and the spectacle offered by the richness and virtuosity of its composition processes.' Gael Saint-Cricq, translated from Revue de musicology