List of figures and tables
About the editors
About the contributors
Introduction
Part 1: Overview of workplace culture
Chapter 1: Organizational culture and leadership: exploring perceptions and relationships
Abstract:
Introduction
Organizational culture defined
Unit subcultures
Perceptions
Values
Leadership
Everyone leads
Culture-shaping
Conclusion
Chapter 2: Building on our strengths: working towards a preferred workplace culture
Abstract:
Introduction
Literature review
Case studies
Results
Current cultures
Preferred cultures
Discussion
Conclusion
Chapter 3: Organizational culture and administrative change: a case study at a metropolitan academic library
Abstract:
Introduction
Literature review: prior case studies
Background and methodology
Positive cultural aspects
Challenges
Change in the library's administration
Conclusion
Appendix A Culture interview
Appendix B Culture survey and responses
Part 2: Assessment
Chapter 4: Organizational climate assessment and improvement planning
Abstract:
Introduction
Literature review
Strategic planning retreats
Assessment strategy
Climate assessment instrument
Climate assessment retreats
Outcomes
Lessons learned
Conclusion and looking forward
Appendix A Values statement
Appendix B Cook Library Strategic Plan 2010-2016 (Excerpt)
Appendix C Cook Work Life Survey
Appendix D Plan to improve and enhance organizational climate
Part 3: Acclimation for new librarians
Chapter 5: Helping new librarians find success and satisfaction in the academic library
Abstract:
Introduction
Literature review
Best practices for supporting and leveraging new librarians
Conclusion
Part 4: Workforce diversity
Chapter 6: Beyond diversity: moving towards inclusive work environments
Abstract:
Introduction
Literature review
Inclusive work environments
Cultural competencies
Climate surveys
Developing inclusive work environments
An international perspective
Library leadership
Conclusion
Chapter 7: Cultural competencies in authentic leadership
Abstract:
Introduction
Background on the organizational culture of the University of Nebraska-Lincoln Libraries
Leadership literature
Implementing authentic leadership and cultural competencies at University of Nebraska-Lincoln Libraries
Infrastructure
Diversity committee and mission
Workplace climate
Recruitment and retention
Conclusion
Chapter 8: Diversity and sensitivity in the workplace: understanding Asian Pacific American staff
Abstract:
Introduction
Asian Pacific Americans: definition
APA population's profile
APA librarians data: diversity counts
Literature review
APA diverse identities
APA library staff: other relevant issues
Best practices and future research
Conclusion
Part 5: Physical environment
Chapter 9: Challenges of redesigning staff work space
Abstract:
Introduction
Literature review
Space assessments
Planning for space changes
Conclusion
Appendix Workspace needs assessment and renovation checklist
Chapter 10: All integration is local: merging cultures in an academic library
Abstract:
Introduction
Literature review
Case study
Conclusion
Chapter 11: Promoting and enabling civility in the academic library
Abstract:
Introduction
The broader issues of civility and incivility
A commitment to diversity and to civility
Implementing action
Creating a statement
Ongoing efforts
Launching a civility initiative in your library
Conclusion
Appendix University Libraries Civility Statement
Part 6: Staff morale/Interpersonal
Chapter 12: Building staff morale and creating a positive workplace
Abstract:
Introduction
Literature review
Background
Library divisions
Bridging the great divide
Conclusion
Part 7: Interaction between departments
Chapter 13: Interdepartmental communication in academic libraries
Abstract:
Introduction
Underlying barriers to interdepartmental communication
Success at Western Washington University Libraries
Conclusion
Chapter 14: Interaction between departments: strategies for improving interdepartmental collaboration through communication
Abstract:
Introd
Introduction
Librarians and library staff are typically focused on serving the needs of library users, and this can lead them to lose sight of the fact that libraries are also places of work. The library literature is replete with articles about how to improve services, facilities, and systems for library users, but there are relatively few articles about how to improve libraries for library workers. Librarians and library staff should be concerned with having a good environment in which to work, and improving libraries for library workers will doubtless result in better and more productive organizations.
One of the elements that contribute to the quality of a workplace for employees, if not the most important one, is the culture of that workplace. Workplace culture is defined in the Oxford Dictionary of Business and Management as "the values, customs, rituals, attitudes, and norms shared by the members of an organization, which have to be learnt and accepted by new members of the organization. . . "1 A positive/healthy culture, where new ideas are encouraged, and where mistakes are accepted as part of the learning process, can lead to greater success and productivity for the organization. It can also create less employee anxiety and depression, increase employee satisfaction, raise motivation, and lower absenteeism.2
This volume was compiled to review current workplace cultures in academic libraries and ways to improve those cultures. Basic questions this book is concerned with are: "What conditions contribute to an excellent academic library work environment? What helps to make a particular academic library a great place to work?" Unlike other works published in this area, this work is neither a "how-to" guide nor a collection of highly theoretical and speculative essays. Rather, contributions to this collection primarily discuss successful current programs pertaining to workplace culture in academic libraries and place the discussion in a scholarly context, particularly by considering similar programs and/or the history of the topic as reviewed in the library literature. It is hoped that, because this work is from the practitioner's standpoint, each contribution will still have significant practical value by providing useful ideas and suggestions for consideration by other academic libraries. Chapters relate to the physical environment, diversity, retention of quality staff, staff morale, interaction between departments, communication/information sharing, handling of complaints, and management styles conducive to healthy workplaces.
The essays in the section "Overview of Workplace Culture" begin the book with some "meta" workplace culture issues, such as defining the concept of workplace culture, workplace culture and leadership, the creation of a "preferred" workplace culture, and a case study that took place in a large metropolitan academic library. The chapter on "Assessment" by MacDonald discusses the different tools that academic libraries have used to assess their culture and plan for improvement. Some academic libraries have used professionally-produced tools, such as ClimateQUAL®,3 to define their culture, while other libraries have created or adapted tools of their own.
The book contains a number of chapters related to staff diversity in academic libraries. Topics include making workplaces inclusive towards co-workers from diverse backgrounds; the importance for library leaders to develop cultural competences so they can improve interaction with diverse staff; and developing cultural competencies specifically towards Asian Pacific American co-workers, a fast-rising group in academic libraries. The topic of diversity relates to more than just ethnicity, and, in their chapter, Garnar and McCaffrey analyze the commentary of focus groups of different generations of librarians in regard to their differing visions of 21st-century academic libraries. In the section on "Acclimation for New Librarians," Miller is specifically concerned with new librarians in academic libraries, and she advocates for special attention to be paid to this group. Not only do new librarians need help in being acclimated to their new profession, but their newness to the profession makes them a fertile source of fresh ideas.
The issue of communication is bound to be raised in any thorough discussion of workplace culture. There is a need for communication at all levels; communication, however, is an ongoing effort, and implementing and maintaining good communication requires concerted effort and time. The issue of interdepartmental communication is discussed by Mautino and Lorenzen, and interdepartmental collaboration through communication is addressed by Bordeianu and Lubas. Blessing focuses on the crucial aspect in a workplace culture of good communication flowing from the leadership to the staff, a characteristic of transparent leadership. The topic of workspace redesign projects is covered in two chapters, one by vanDuinkerken and MacDonald, the other by Weisbrod. The vanDuinkerken/MacDonald chapter, on the challenges of library staff workspace redesign, states that administrators frequently tend to make the mistake of announcing the need for a change and then moving directly to implementation, without conducting staff interviews, observing staff work behavior, and engaging in inclusive planning. Tedford, Corbett, and Lock report on the improvements in the workplace culture of their library after an inspirational library director was hired. While this director was concerned with making the library more innovative, she accomplished this by being more open to communication from her staff, listening more closely to staff ideas and making them feel more a part of the decision-making process for new programs at the library.
Fostering civility and managing conflict are two sides of the same coin of interpersonal relationships, one focusing on the positive and the other the negative. Snavely and Hudson's chapter considers a number of ways to encourage civility in an academic library. And, in her chapter, Plocharczyk discusses how best to manage conflict in academic libraries. She argues that conflict does not have to be seen only in a negative light; when handled constructively, it can bring about necessary and positive change.
Tenure for librarians is another weighty issue in academic librarianship, and two chapters deal with this issue directly. While the research in the article by Hepburn noted that most academic librarians hold faculty rank, what that actually meant in terms of tenure or other conditions varied. Hepburn investigates the different types of faculty status to see what effect, if any, the varying statuses had on the culture of libraries, and he reports on a survey he implemented to help to determine these perceptions. Bruxvoort looks at the different ways mentoring, particularly mentoring tenure-track librarians, can be handled and then determines best practices for this.
Change is omnipresent in the 21st-century academic library, with trends including major budget cuts due to the global economic recession, increased purchasing of and access to e-books, and repurposing of space to allow more collaborative work and study spaces. Most academic libraries are currently facing budget cuts, and two articles in this book elaborate on how academic libraries can provide non-monetary awards and morale boosters. Johnson, Stoffan, and Carstens take up the topic of motivating library staff in a time when monetary incentives are not an option. They conclude by recommending practices that "include giving employees the maximum possible control over their physical environment and individual work schedules; providing them with opportunities to grow in their job and learn about other departments in the library; providing them with a possible career path within the library; including staff on library committees; attempting to communicate effectively with all staff; and praising employees' accomplishments whenever appropriate." And, while a discussion of enhancing staff morale could take a number of directions, Jennings and Tvaruzka's treatment of this issue in their chapter focuses on an effort to increase the level of fun that co-workers have in the library while still being mindful of budget constraints.
The major themes of this book, diversity, communication, and leadership, seem to fall under the umbrella of one over-arching idea: respect. Increasing the respect for diversity in all of its manifestations, for co-workers, for the value of staff to the point that communication with them, their ideas, and their motivation and development are major concerns of leadership, these things should be on the agenda if the goal is to improve the workplace cultures of academic libraries. The editors hope that this book will provide substantive suggestions and inspiration for academic librarians to improve the respect between their co-workers and leaders, to result in enhanced workplace cultures that will provide optimal conditions for library workers.
1Oxford Dictionary of Business and Management, 4th ed. (New York: Oxford University Press, 2006).
2"Making Work Fun: An Important Role for Managers," SAM Advanced Management Journal 67, no. 1 (2002): 4-8, 21; Katherine M. Hudson, "Transforming a Conservative Company - One Laugh at a Time," Harvard Business Review 79, no. 7 (2001): 45-53; Mildred Golden Pryor et al., "Workplace Fun and its Correlates: A Conceptual...