On a Knife Edge

Rezensionen / Stimmen

'All future historians of the First World War will have to engage with Holger Afflerbach's important and authoritative book, and his powerful and provocative case that the conflict was more of a 'close run thing' than previously thought.' Jonathan Boff, author of Haig's Enemy: Crown Prince Rupprecht and Germany's War on the Western Front 'A fascinating and provocative account - Afflerbach argues that the First World War could have ended in a draw and that the German leadership committed serious mistakes to lose it.' Annika Mombauer, author of The Origins of the First World War 'Holger Afflerbach provides a comprehensive reassessment of Germany's conduct of the 1914-18 war. Drawing on fresh archival sources and an impressive command of the immense secondary literature, he offers a thought-provoking reappraisal of the entire history of that terrible conflict.' David Stevenson, author of With Our Backs to the Wall: Victory and Defeat in 1918 'Boldly argued and beautifully written, Holger Afflerbach's On a Knife Edge vividly portrays Germany's strategic desperation in 1914-18 and reveals how the Allies' uncompromising pursuit of total victory radicalised the conflict and destroyed all hope of a lasting peace. Thought-provoking and sure to spark controversy - this is one of the most important and exciting new interpretations of the First World War!' Alexander Watson, author of Ring of Steel: Germany and Austria-Hungary at War, 1914-1918 'WWI scholars and enthusiasts will relish this exhaustive deep dive.' Publishers Weekly '... a highly readable account not only of the German side of the war but to some extent a retrospective on the war as a whole, one both enthusiasts and specialists can enjoy and fruitfully debate.' Avi Woolf, The Washington Examiner 'This book is a political study of Germany's war effort, not a campaign narrative, though it tells the 1914-18 story very well ... Afflerbach gathers many strands into a coherent argument, and offers a host of details that are likely to be unfamiliar even to veteran students of the conflict.' Max Hastings, The Sunday Times '... a revisionist spin ... Afflerbach argues that Germany's defeat in 1918 was not inevitable. It could have gone either way on the battlefield, but internal turmoil was to blame for the defeat, leading to a peace not 'based on justice but instead ... too harsh'.' Simon Heffer, Best History Books of the Year, Daily Telegraph 'An impressive, well-researched and readable book which advances an important argument.' Military History Magazine 'The author's knowledge ... is nothing short of stupendous ... Highly recommended.' Klaus Schmider, British Army Review 'This is a fine study in grand strategy, more about the art of political judgement (and misjudgement) than it is about battles and tactics. There are very few quality English language studies of the German military-political scene in the Great War, and none to rival this.' John Spencer, Stand To! The Journal of The Western Front Association '... expertly translated.' Matthew Stibbe, American History Yearbook