The Right to be Forgotten

Rezensionen / Stimmen

This is an essential text on an important, new area of law. * The Law Society Gazette * An excellent deep dive into the Right to be Forgotten. I would recommend anyone working in privacy, especially within a technology environment, to read this. -- Stuart Anderson, Managing Director, XpertDPO With this book, Paul Lambert achieved one of the very first, truly profound and up-to-date analyses to the Right to be Forgotten, dedicated not merely to the scope of Article 17 of the GDPR, but also to the path to its evolution, including the widely known 'Google Spain' decision of the European Court of Justice (often seen as a 'Big Bang'), and national law developments, especially in the UK. Since digital memory never forgets and information merging progresses in somewhat alarming ways, manifesting itself in today's threats - blackmailing, stalking, revenge porn, deep fakes, to name but a few - the author points out the strengths and weaknesses of this legal concept. This clearly structured book is therefore highly recommended to all those who would like to develop a deeper understanding of the necessities and different views going beyond Article 17 of the GDPR to approach the significance of a 'digital amnesia' which should by no means be underestimated. -- Christopher Schmidt, Magister of Law Data Privacy Specialist, certified CIPP/E, CIPM, CIPT, CBSA Dr. Paul Lambert's book succeeds in offering an astonishing and prescient examination of the privacy implications and consideration of the right to be forgotten in the digital age. The internet and technologies using personal data are built to remember and never forget, so the right to be forgotten not only explores ethical and legal questions but technical challenges as well. Dr. Lambert leaves no stone unturned in his examination of the right to be forgotten and offers a wide range of information about its ripple effects on privacy in the digital world as we know it. -- Debbie Reynolds, EimerStahl With "Right to be Forgotten - Interpretation and Practice Textbook", Paul Lambert goes well beyond the legal analysis of the right to be forgotten that can be found in the current literature. For the first time the reader gets a comprehensive approach to the problem of data processing and management across long periods of time and how it connects with the will of data subjects that such processing and disclosure be erased and thus forgotten. Dr. Lambert addresses the legal problem starting from a societal approach of great importance reflected on chapters one to three. This is key to understanding how the need to be forgotten came to be an important legal issue of our time and how it influenced the law. The author then proceeds to analyze the legal framework and regime for the right to be forgotten with great detail and special attention to its caselaw origins at the CJEU but without forgetting national case law and the guidance of the Article 29 Working Party. This is done with clear language and practical examples to illustrate analysis. Paul Lambert's "Right to be Forgotten - Interpretation and Practice Textbook" immediately ranks as fundamental work regarding this new and important right and constitutes an important tool for any operator in the privacy and data protection ecosystem. -- Domingos Soares Farinho Professor, University of Lisbon School of Law Privacy and Data Protection Lawyer The internet allows our misdemeanours and mistakes to come back to haunt us. Digital footprints are visible long after the storm has past and human interest has waned. The right to be forgotten balances this out by enabling some people to wipe the digital slate clean. The right is still in its infancy and finding its feet however and Paul Lambert's book provides what every data protection lawyers really need right now, that is a clear and simple exposition of how the right can be contextualised and put within the broader data protection framework. -- Professor Phillip Johnson, Cardiff University My initial reaction to a 500+ page textbook only about The Right to be Forgotten was to wonder what on earth there was to talk about. However, having reviewed Paul Lambert's text and seen what a thorough account he has provided on the subject, this makes more sense. As well as tracking the history of the original Google Spain Case (a case in which Bristows was heavily involved), Lambert also considers the development of the modern commercial internet, including social media in particular, and the growing need for individuals to be able to manage their online presence in certain situations. The advent of 'revenge porn' is a good example of this, which the book covers in a reasonable amount of detail. The impact of GDPR is also looked at closely, as well as the way in which it has developed and modified the RtbF as originally seen in the Google Spain case. Moreover, various national cases that have looked at the RtbF are described and analysed, with the UK's NT 1 and NT2, deserving of a chapter each. The impact of RtbF on the media - a highly contentious area - is also looked, as is the potential impact of Brexit. Overall, this is a solid piece of work that will provide a useful resource for anyone involved in weighing the respective rights of privacy and data protection and freedom of expression and other, competing rights. -- Mark Watts * Bristows Law Firm *