European countries, including the Netherlands, are increasingly more willing to return looted art to their former colonies. In doing so, however, they are confronted with hard choices. In The Empty Showcase Syndrome, Jos van Beurden explores three of the toughest questions that countries and governments face. First, former colonial powers often hesitate to relinquish control over the provenance research into the looted items to their former colonies. Secondly, most private owners keep quiet about their collections, while these collections should also be included in the restitution debates. Finally, many former colonies struggle with the question of where exactly the returned collections should go: to their national museums or to the old royal houses or indigenous communities from which these collections were stolen. In this book, Jos van Beurden uses many examples from the Netherlands, which has recently returned stolen art to Indonesia and Sri Lanka.
Rezensionen / Stimmen
"In his book, Van Beurden analyzes in clear language and with many concrete examples where change halts but also where breakthrough is possible."
- Katrijn D'hamers, FARO-bibliotheek, March, 2024
Sprache
Verlagsort
Zielgruppe
Produkt-Hinweis
Broschur/Paperback
Klebebindung
Illustrationen
16 farbige Abbildungen
16 Illustrations, color
Maße
Höhe: 218 mm
Breite: 137 mm
Dicke: 13 mm
Gewicht
ISBN-13
978-90-485-6407-1 (9789048564071)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Klassifikation
Dr. Jos van Beurden is a senior researcher colonial cultural collections and restitution (Free University, Amsterdam). His most recent publications are: Treasures in Trusted Hands - Negotiating the Future of Colonial Cultural Objects (Leiden 2017) (nominated for the NWO Boekman Dissertation Price), and The Return of Cultural and Historical Treasures - The Case of the Netherlands (Amsterdam 2012).
For his merits in the cultural heritage field, Van Beurden was appointed Officer in the Order of Orange Nassau. Jos van Beurden is founder of the news-clipping service RM* (restitution matters).
To the reader
1 Three Encounters, Three Questions
A visitor from Sri Lanka - A quick sale in Amsterdam - Conversation in Jakarta
2 Museums: From Looking Away to Changing
The Dubois fossil collection - Collections on loan - Working together
3 The Dutch Government: A U-turn at Last
Frugal in giving back - Gradual shift - The first results - 'They should never have been in the Netherlands'
4 Ethical Compass: Three Principles
Beware of exaggeration - Looting as a form of colonial violence - The three concepts: Trust, equality, and justice
5 No Research About Us Without Us
Inequality in provenance research - Surprising approach in the 1990s - Working towards equality now - Paradigm shift - Bumps in the road
6 Come Out, Private Collector and Art Trader!
Growing insight - Unable to return - Art dealers, private collectors, and the media - Interlude: Is it about 'human remains' or 'ancestral remains'? - What is the Dutch government doing?
7 Ex-Colonies: to whom do the returned objects go?
An installation that touches - Who decides what is claimed? - Friction over a weapon and a gemstone - Papuan and Moluccan skulls - Indigenous group claims 'baby in strong water' - Weakness in Dutch policy?
8 Giving Back: The New Normal?
Slow steps of European countries - What does the European- Nigerian Benin dialogue yield? - How are other former colonies doing? - Will restitution become the new normal?
Notes
Acknowledgements
Sources consulted
Index
