The Gestural Origin of Language

Rezensionen / Stimmen

"The gestural theory of language origins was once considered mere speculation by philosophers. In the hands of Armstrong and Wilcox, however, this theory gains greater force and clarity. After reading their articulate and accessible book, I find the conclusion inescapable: language could not have begun otherwise." --H-Dirksen L. Bauman, Professor, Department of American Sign Language and Deaf Studies, Gallaudet University
"Syntax is still the Holy Grail of language-origins research, and it's exciting to read a detailed and plausible explanation of its evolution as grounded in social processes of action, perception, and change over time-- and most definitely not in innatism! This book, in sum, is a beautifully realized synthesis of theory and data; it will advance our understanding of language origins, and of the intricacy and rightness of the view that ALL language is ultimately
gestural." --Barbara J. King, Class of 2007 Professor of Anthropology, College of William and Mary, and author of The Dynamic Dance
"This volume is a stunning example of the insights that scientists with close working familiarity of Deaf people and their natural languages bring to the study of how language evolved and how children develop language skills. Armstrong and Wilcox succeed brilliantly in their efforts to present a 'genuine explanation' in these perennial debates." --Stuart Shanker, Distinguished Research Professor of Philosophy and Psychology, York University, and President,
Council of Early Child Development
"David Armstrong and Sherman Wilcox are well known to a wide community of linguists as imaginative and determined proponents of a claim that the visually mediated languages of the deaf--sign languages, in other words--offer critical clues to the hidden origins of human symbolic communication. In The Gestural Origin of Language they update this increasingly compelling thesis in terms that are not merely rhetorical. Given the relevant advances in
linguistics plus a host of convergent insights from anthropology, neuroscience, genetics, developmental and animal psychology, we have a new game. From now on, linguists hoping to explain human language will simply
have to learn how to chew on, and digest, more than one kind of apple." --Frank R. Wilson, M.D., author of The Hand: How Its Use Shapes the Brain, Language, and Human Culture
"An important book. The authors, who have added solidity to the gestural theory of how language first evolved, are part of a sea change in the way we view language and indeed ourselves."--American Scientist
"Once I read Armstrong and Wilcox's compelling account, it was easy to have a 'How could language emerge any other way?' epiphany...I urge anyone interested in language or any other aspect of human behavior for that matter, to read the rich argument provided in the book and come to their own conclusions."--Ruth Church, in Human Development
"There are many aspects to Armstrong and Wilcox's book that deserve attention...a comprehensive review of the data suggesting that sign language is in most ways equal to spoken language."--PsycCritiques
"The gestural theory of language origins was once considered mere speculation by philosophers. In the hands of Armstrong and Wilcox, however, this theory gains greater force and clarity. After reading their articulate and accessible book, I find the conclusion inescapable: language could not have begun otherwise." --H-Dirksen L. Bauman, Professor, Department of American Sign Language and Deaf Studies, Gallaudet University
"Syntax is still the Holy Grail of language-origins research, and it's exciting to read a detailed and plausible explanation of its evolution as grounded in social processes of action, perception, and change over time-- and most definitely not in innatism! This book, in sum, is a beautifully realized synthesis of theory and data; it will advance our understanding of language origins, and of the intricacy and rightness of the view that ALL language is ultimately
gestural." --Barbara J. King, Class of 2007 Professor of Anthropology, College of William and Mary, and author of The Dynamic Dance
"This volume is a stunning example of the insights that scientists with close working familiarity of Deaf people and their natural languages bring to the study of how language evolved and how children develop language skills. Armstrong and Wilcox succeed brilliantly in their efforts to present a 'genuine explanation' in these perennial debates." --Stuart Shanker, Distinguished Research Professor of Philosophy and Psychology, York University, and President,
Council of Early Child Development
"David Armstrong and Sherman Wilcox are well known to a wide community of linguists as imaginative and determined proponents of a claim that the visually mediated languages of the deaf - sign languages, in other words - offer critical clues to the hidden origins of human symbolic communication. In The Gestural Origin of Language they update this increasingly compelling thesis in terms that are not merely rhetorical. Given the relevant advances in
linguistics plus a host of convergent insights from anthropology, neuroscience, genetics, developmental and animal psychology, we have a new game. From now on, linguists hoping to explain human language will
simply have to learn how to chew on, and digest, more than one kind of apple." --Frank R. Wilson, M.D., author of The Hand: How Its Use Shapes the Brain, Language, and Human Culture
"An important book. The authors, who have added solidity to the gestural theory of how language first evolved, are part of a sea change in the way we view language and indeed ourselves."--American Scientist
"Once I read Armstrong and Wilcox's compelling account, it was easy to have a 'How could language emerge any other way?' epiphany...I urge anyone interested in language or any other aspect of human behavior for that matter, to read the rich argument provided in the book and come to their own conclusions."--Ruth Church, in Human Development
"There are many aspects to Armstrong and Wilcox's book that deserve attention...A comprehensive review of the data suggesting that sign language is in most ways equal to spoken language."--PsycCritiques
"Culling evidence from studies in paleontology, primatology, neurology, signed languages, and writing, the authors presented the gradual evolution of languages."--Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education