Women and the Criminal Justice System

Rezensionen / Stimmen

Women and the Criminal Justice System: Gender, Race, and Class is an essential text for teaching about women's issues within the criminal justice system. Split into three primary sections, van Wormer and Bartollas examine how women are treated within the criminal legal system as perpetrators of harm, victims of harm, and as employees within the system. The authors deftly discuss key topics such as the victim-offender overlap, the global nature of violence against women, the adultification of Black girls, and sexual harassment. The authors use case studies and provide examples of recent criminal events, making this book a compelling and accessible read. Students will enjoy learning from the book, and professors will enjoy teaching from it.

Danielle Slakoff, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Criminal Justice, California State University, Sacramento

For most of my career I have been lucky enough to learn from and use this comprehensive and intersectional text by Van Wormer and Bartollas in my criminal and social justice courses. Each new edition of Women and the Criminal Justice System: Gender, Race, and Class has shared important new insights, updates, concepts, and case studies, as well as new perspectives on the workings of courts, policing, and corrections institutions here and abroad. I use this work for many reasons but especially because, semester after semester, students benefit from an holistic, case by case understanding of the powerful roles of gender, race, and class in justice policy, programming, and in officers' own lives. But this latest edition is especially important for the 2021-2022 year and years to come. It creates that necessary context for students to understand current crises and reforms in terms of recent and dramatic new social change movements students are in desperate need of discussing, understanding, and reflecting upon in their own lives before they graduate, often into positions of complex social power in the criminal justice workplace.

This text will be the main tool I use to help students as so many of them learn and train to serve in a justice system undergoing needed gender, race, and class-informed reform. They will be part of a new social justice system that is learning how to adapt to waves of empowered grassroots movements while responding to new forms of technological oversight and political change. These movements and topics in this latest edition include the recent Me Too, Black Lives Matter, LGBTQIA movements as well as the impact of the COVID19 and opioid pandemics on social justice and class inequality in America and abroad. This will give my students important historical and civil rights context to these voices as well as theoretical depth and review so that students can understand the times we are living in and the meanings and values we are creating for the future. It is a rare and useful guide that speaks to students across disciplines, from women's studies to criminal justice to ethnic and gender studies. Especially in the wake of the pandemic and opioid crises, the harm reduction, social health and trauma-informed, and class-sensitive approaches taught here in the context of power and human rights help students create a new way of thinking about social justice. The addition of a focus on concepts in glossary form is especially useful in the classroom.

Women in the Criminal Justice System: Gender, Race, Class is the text all students of criminal and social justice, especially police and corrections officers in training, should be reading and applying to their lives and work with the public.

Elizabeth Stassinos, Ph.D., Professor of Criminal Justice & Ethnic & Gender Studies, Westfield State University

[T]his classic text provides a well-rounded exploration of the experiences and reality of girls and women in the criminal justice system, encompassing offending and incarceration, victimhood, and criminal justice career pathways. The marginalization and oppression of women by gender, class, and race is the central them that runs through and connects all three spheres of the criminal justice system. A system designed by men and for men overlooks the needs and differences women present to the system. Inherent bias and discrimination of girls and women, especially girls and women of color, and those in the lower socio-economic status, means that their treatment and conditions are harsher than those experienced by their male counterparts. Each section of the text includes updated material and relevant statistics that will both surprise and inform the reader. The text gives the student a theoretical foundation for understanding male and female differences and needs.

There are many attributes of this text including an exploration of international circumstances and comparisons to women in North America. On a positive note, the text presents positive advances in gender specific programing for female offenders. The text uses highlights of women in their own words to bring to life the challenges faced by these women as offenders, victims, and practitioners. This text is well-designed and organized to maximize course strategies and learning outcomes.

I have used this text and its subsequent editions for nearly 20 years in my course Women and Crime. As a retired law enforcement officer, I appreciate the attention it gives to women working in the criminal justice system. As a professor, I appreciate the text's organization and readability for my students. Students and former students, both male and female, have told me that they loved my class. I attribute my success as a professor of criminal justice to the availability of texts of this caliber. I recommend this book to my colleagues. With all the textbooks that are available, this is one I return to every time I teach this course.

Deborah A. Parsons, Ph.D., Professor of Criminal Justice, California State University, San Bernardino

Women and the Criminal Justice System: Gender, Race, and Class is a powerful text that provides depth and breadth to the role of gender in the criminal justice system. This insightful and sophisticated view can inform and shape the roles we choose when advocating for change across systems. As professionals, as social workers, and as educators, or in any other relevant and overlapping realm, we can join with those who are calling for change by harnessing the ideas, guidance, and suggestions in this text through supporting, encouraging, and promoting holistic and intentional transformation in the ways in which women and girls take part in the criminal justice system. Ethically we must stand up and call for more just, transparent, and humane practices, regulations, and laws within criminal justice institutions and legislation. This book provides a wealth of information to inform our call for and movement toward substantive and procedural change.

Melissa Hirschi, Ph.D., Professor of Social Work, University of Memphis, in Affilia: Feminist Inquiry in Social Work 1-2, 2023

In driving change, from the "bottom up" the role of the practitioner is fundamental in terms of resisting patriarchal, racist and class-based violence through becoming aware of our own potential for complicity in those processes. What this book usefully does is to provide a detailed critique but also to demonstrate potential solutions for survivors and with a key section on restorative justice. Ultimately of course van Wormer and Bartollas argue, that the problem of crime is emergent from societies in which discrimination thrives, and it is down to practitioners to not just model but to actualize different possibilities for people who are oppressed.

This theme of empowerment for all women in the criminal justice system runs throughout the book and includes international perspectives. This comprehensive book has 5 sections divided into 14 chapters. The sections are: An introduction focusing on theoretical perspectives; Female crime and delinquency; Drug addiction, prison and restoration; The prison environment; Women as victims and survivors; Global victimisation: Women's perspectives (co-written with Dheeshana Jayasundara); Women as professionals; Summary and trends for the future. Usefully every chapter has a glossary of key terms, critical thinking questions and relevant websites for more information. I will be using this book for my students including trainee probation officers and cannot recommend it highly enough.

Aaron Pycroft, Ph.D., University of Portsmouth, UK, in Journal of Social Work 1-2, 2024.