Precious Threads and Precarious Lives

Rezensionen / Stimmen

"Kumar provides a highly original perspective on the history of Kashmiri shawls: an often-copied commodity of world fame produced in a conflict-ridden borderland. Telling the story from the maker's perspective he convincingly argues that next to colonial and princely state policies and mercantilist capital the adaptability of the artisans determined the development and survival of this special craft."

Karin Hofmeester, Research Director at the IISH (International Institute of Social History, Amsterdam) and part-time professor of Jewish Culture at Antwerp University.

"The weavers strike of 1931 is often placed as a critical historical marker for a new self-assertion in the Kashmir valley, with resonances that ghost into the present. In this rich and engaging history of the textile industry in Kashmir Amit Kumar tells us how we may have got there. Keeping the artisan at the centre of his enquiry, he looks closely at the smallest unit of the craft, the karkhana, placing it within the wider circuits of the wool and weaving trade in the region, and linking it to global commodity chains. By doing so he opens up fresh ways of looking at Kashmir."

Sanjay Kak, Filmmaker and Writer

"In many ways, the real work on the genesis and consequences of the dispute over the erstwhile Dogra State of Jammu & Kashmir is just beginning. Amit Kumar's Precious Threads, Precarious Lives: Histories of Kashmiri Shawl and Silk Industries of Kashmir 1846-1950 is a contribution of significance in that genre. It challenges accepted arguments ranging from accepted notions of "nationalist struggle" to the idea of a single unified history of India before the British colonial withdrawal from South Asia, while also pointing to mundane but critical methodological problems such as the manipulation of archival material to support statist interpretations."

Siddiq Wahid, Senior Fellow, CPR India and former Vice Chancellor, Islamic University of Science and Technology, Awantipora