Temptation Transformed

Rezensionen / Stimmen

"A brisk and entertaining investigation into the cultural history of Adam and Eve's comestible catastrophe . . . [with a] sly sense of humor that peeks through refreshingly cant-free prose. Temptation Transformed is easy to follow for any curious amateur who enjoys getting to the bottom of a puzzle. By the end, Mr. Yadin-Israel at least has exonerated the apple; the serpent might present a more difficult task." * Wall Street Journal * "[A] scrumptiously scholarly morsel of a book . . . In addition to being a philological detective story, Temptation Transformed is a kind of miniature coffee-table book, employing forty-two images of Fall of Man art to chart the transformation from grape and fig (and a few other fruits) to apple . . . Yadin-Israel is a master of philological and iconographic detective work, and the joy of this beautiful little book is in following his reasoning as he thinks through words (in a daunting number of languages) and images." * Jewish Review of Books * "[A] delightfully readable study . . . tracing the apple iconography from its roots in 12th-century France. In fewer than 100 pages, with ample illustrations, Yadin-Israel builds a compelling argument around the convergence of textual evidence, semantic shifts, and the visual arts in medieval Europe." * The Christian Century * "Temptation Transformed is a serious study of a biblical topic, which should appeal primarily to biblical scholars." * Washington Jewish Week * "So what at first seemed like a simple question - where did that apple come from? - becomes a complicated story of changes across time and space as Jewish families adjust to the Christian world around them, and Jews and Christians alike adjust to changes in language, theology, and geography." * Jewish Standard * "An accessible, well-argued, well-researched book and a testament to the power of interdisciplinary work to clarify age-old conundrums . . . A must-read for those interested in the mechanisms by which religious ideas and iconography develop . . . [and] for those interested in the history of Jewish and Christian biblical interpretation, especially of Genesis 3. . . [and] a gift to art lovers everywhere." * Reading Religion * A Best Medieval Book of 2023 * Medievalists.net * "A fascinating scholarly narrative that reads like a mystery novel . . . Temptation Transformed invites readers on a journey through the annals of history, challenging preconceived notions, and revealing the intricate story behind the genesis of a pervasive cultural belief." * Jerusalem Post * "Meticulously researched and engagingly written, this study yields more fascinating discoveries per page than anything I have read in years." * Religious Studies Review * "Assessing both textual and iconographic references to the forbidden fruit over time, Yadin-Israel challenges the pervasive malum hypothesis, which posits that the forbidden fruit came to be identified with the apple due to the double meaning of the Latin word malum, which signifies both 'apple' and 'evil.'" * Journal of Religion * "A concise study of how the tale and representation of the original sin became associated with fruits, and more precisely, subsequently with the Apple . . . A true merit of Yadin-Israel's study is its bridging of the realms of visual and linguistic means of representation in the medieval and early modern period following an investigation of their pre-histories in the ancient Judaic and Christian textual traditions. Assembling a cornucopia of case studies, Yadin-Israel is not serving up what could easily result in a fruit-salad-style collection of bits and pieces across media (e.g., murals, book illumination, drawings, prints, sculpture, and more, all richly represented throughout the book and in the glossy colour plates section of the book), but rather integrates the relatively short mention of these artworks into iconographic and iconological contexts that better justify the brevity of attention given to each individual work of art." * Journal of Religious History * "If Genesis speaks only of the forbidden 'fruit,' how and when did that fruit become an apple? To answer, Yadin-Israel leads us from Genesis to the Song of Songs, through an iconographic survey worthy of Erwin Panofsky, into medieval languages, and even a brief history of apples in ancient and modern horticulture. This visual and literary masterpiece will serve as a methodological guide for future research, but its ultimate subject is nothing less than the pictorial representation of human sinfulness and the hope for redemption." -- James Kugel, author of 'The Bible as It Was' "A fascinating cornucopia of insights from language, literature, and art history, Temptation Transformed offers the tantalizing fruit of rigorous textual and iconographic research into the identification of the forbidden fruit. Yadin-Israel provides compelling evidence for a new understanding of the development of the apple tradition in medieval France. I will use his historical insights every time I teach Genesis." -- John H. Walton, author of 'The Lost World of Adam and Eve' "Temptation Transformed traces the rise of the forbidden fruit across centuries-from ancient Hebrew manuscripts to wall paintings and more. This is an engaging and beautiful book." -- Miri Rubin, author of 'Mother of God: A History of the Virgin Mary' "Anyone interested in how cultural and linguistic changes can influence our interpretations of the biblical text will find Temptation Transformed to be of great interest." * The Reporter * "Not in text or in iconography, but rather in art history and French semantics, does one find the appearance, attraction, and role that the apple plays in the fall of humanity." * Catholic Biblical Quaterly *