Out of Order

Rezensionen / Stimmen

Mary CorcoranaEUR (TM)s Out of Order: the Political Imprisonment of Women in Northern Ireland 1972-1998, provides a significant and valuable contribution to the currently limited academic analyses on womenaEUR (TM)s political imprisonment in Northern Ireland. There remains a dearth of research on this minoritized population of women despite the fact that a wealth of research on the political imprisonment of men in Northern Ireland has been conducted (McEvoy, 2001; McKeown, 2001). In fact, while protests by men prisoners in the H-Block during the 1970aEUR (TM)s and 1980aEUR (TM)s are well documented, CorcoranaEUR (TM)s analysis presents the first detailed documentation of protests by women prisoneraEUR (TM)s in Armagh Prison and in the Mourne House Unit of Maghaberry Prison during the period of time well known as aEUR?the troublesaEUR (TM). Corcoran traces a history of the present, by charting the evolution of the punishment of female political prisoners in Northern Ireland over a 26-year period. To do this, she structures her account according to the three key stages of prison administration and penal regimes that she identified as operating in Armagh Prison during this time frame: reactive containment (1969-76), criminalization (1976-1981), and normalization (1982-1998). During the criminalization period, the women resisted the removal of their political status in prison by engaging in a aEUR?dirty protestaEUR (TM) (refusing to bathe, smearing their cells with feces and menstrual blood). In addition, and despite the Provisional IRA orders against it, the women participated in a nearly year long hunger strike, both to resist and demonstrate their agency as political prisoners and to show their solidarity with and support of their male counterparts in H-Block. Unique to this analysis, is that the author exposes how the womenaEUR (TM)s acts were demonstrative not only of their resistance to the removal of their political status, but also to the gendered mistreatment they experienced as women prisoners.During the later years of the normalization phase of prison administration, women political prisoners in Armagh Prison adopted a neo-liberalistic approach to resistance, by employing formal legal litigation against the administration due to discrimination they experienced with respect to their prison conditions, rights, and the campaigned use of strip-searching. Despite engaging with the reigning entrepreneurial and neo-liberal governing strategy that continues to dominate the correctional landscape, resisting the structure and control of the prison through legal means was negatively reconstructed by prison officials as a mere tactic used to cause disruption in the prison. Women political prisoners were reconstructed in mangerialistic terms, not as self-governing agents or unsatisfied clients of a correctional service, but as aEURoeopportunistic litigants and political agitatorsaEUR? whose legal demands were no more than selfish requests for a minority population of violent women prisoners (p.207). In this text, the author provides a well-balanced and nuanced analysis of the strategies employed by the women in their struggles to resist, demonstrate agency, as well as their relationships with prison authorities and staff. By highlighting the dual purpose and nature of the womenaEUR (TM)s acts of resistance, and drawing heavily on the theoretical propositions of feminist criminologists Kelly Hannah-Moffat, Pat Carlen, and Mary Bosworth, Corcoran demonstrates that the womenaEUR (TM)s narratives of resistance alternate between their roles as penal subjects and resisting agents, as dangerous women and women in danger, as survivors, and ultimately as agents attempting to secure collective prison transformation (p.222). While CorcoranaEUR (TM)s analysis significantly adds to the broader theoretical framework of governance literature, her text may not be accessible to the very women she is writing about. Out of Order is dense with theory, to the benefit of academic penologists, yet at times the voices of the women who fought so hard to be heard are missing. Despite this, CorcoranaEUR (TM)s text provides a sensitive and thoughtful discussion of the impact of gender on the resistance and status of political prisoners during aEUR?the troublesaEUR (TM). JENNIFER M. KILTY - Simon Fraser University References: McEvoy, K. (2001). Paramilitary imprisonment in Northern Ireland: Resistance, management, and release. Oxford: Oxford University Press. McKeown, L. (2001). Out of time: Irish Republican prisoners, Long Kesh, 1972-2000. Belfast: Beyond the Pale Press.