Urbanization and Religion in Ancient Central Mexico

Rezensionen / Stimmen

Researchers and students will find a solid book with carefully presented empirical case studies and an innovative theoretical perspective on key intellectual problems, such as urbanism, the formation of settlements and cities, and the organizational potential and unique materiality of cultural belief systems. The writing is precise and unpretentious. The photographs, illustrations, graphs, and maps are informative and well designed. Urbanization and Religion is also not an incredibly long book and, with Carballo's clear prose, will make an excellent assigned book for both undergraduate and graduate classes. * Christopher T. Morehart, Arizona State University, American Anthropologist * In a study that is as concise as it is illuminating, David Carballo takes us through a tour of Central Mexico urbanism in the late Formative Period (roughly from ca. 600 BCE to 100 CE), building on extensive scholarship as well as his own archaeological research. The analysis hinges on the connections between ancient urbanization and religion, brought to life through the methodological choice of combining archaeology with religious studies. * Caterina Pizzigoni, Global Urban History * David Carballo has bootstrapped fresh theoretical constructs with an innovative approach to prehispanic central Mexican religious traditions. He delves skilfully into extant literatures to offer new diachronic perspectives on the emergence and diversity of a key urban tradition. Through this integration, new perspectives regarding the monumental city of Teotihuacan, and its similarities with and differences from predecessors and contemporaries, are revealed. The overarching approach (and findings) provoke new investigatory questions for prehispanic Mesoamerican studies and beyond...through the application of a novel frame that interweaves the general and specific, while also establishing conceptual bridges across the social and historical sciences, the author has advanced a means to interpret the deep past, which, if broadly applied, could help provide a firmer foundation to assess key questions relevant to the present and the future. * Gary M. Feinman, Cambridge Archaeological Journal * An outstanding archaeological synthesis and an interpretive innovation like none other in recent years. Rather than playing it safe by keeping materiality and religion at arms' length, he illuminates through painstaking research and insightful analysis how the 'cultural logic guiding human action' of Mesoamerican urbanization is permeated by religious practices and ideas. Carballo gives new life to knowledge of Mexico's ancient cities. * David Carrasco, Harvard University * This is an excellent synthesis of the earliest cycles of urbanization in central Mexico, showing religion always entangled with politics. Later polities changed in some ways, but much endured into Aztec times. It fills a major gap in our understanding of the history of a key region in Mesoamerica. * George L. Cowgill, Arizona State University *