The Struggle of Parts

Reviews / Votes

Thanks to Haig and Bondi, I now see why this work might have intrigued Darwin and how it provides valuable insight into late nineteenth-century ideas about evolution and development. They make clear what Roux was doing, why, and how it mattered then - and still does today. The excellent translation and thoughtful editing make the ideas not only accessible but also more coherent than they may have been to many contemporary readers...This is a notable achievement that we can applaud. -- Jane Maienschein * Current Biology * This careful, elegant, scholarly translation of Roux's The Struggle of Parts is fascinating. Roux's insufficiently appreciated insights were more than one hundred years ahead of their time and are especially worth reading for anyone interested in the history of fundamental ideas in evolutionary biology, functional adaptation, levels of selection, and what we today call phenotypic plasticity and epigenetics. -- Daniel E. Lieberman, author of <i>Exercised: Why Something We Never Evolved to Do Is Healthy and Rewarding</i> This translation is an important and scholarly contribution to the history and philosophy of biology. The excellent introduction and afterword introduce the rich scientific context in which Roux developed his broad concept of selection as differential persistence and point to the relevance of his ideas to current, and still debated, ideas in evolutionary biology. -- Eva Jablonka, Professor Emerita in History and Philosophy of Science, Tel Aviv University This translation is to be greatly welcomed. Roux was a pioneer in experimental embryology who sought to do what Kant held to be impossible: to explain the purposiveness of organisms with the aid of mechanical principles. These efforts also inspired Nietzsche in his thinking about life and wrestling with Darwinian ideas. The edition is superb and can be recommended to anyone with an interest in the study of life. -- Keith Ansell-Pearson, Honorary President, Friedrich Nietzsche Society David Haig and Richard Bondi have done a great service to a number of fields. By translating Roux's The Struggle of Parts, they have made widely available crucial ideas by a profound thinker. Roux's discussion of how cooperation, competition, and mutual control underlie the formation of a coherent body and mind has major implications for evolutionary and developmental biology, cognitive science, bioengineering, and even artificial intelligence. -- Michael Levin, Professor of Biology, Tufts University