If This Is a Woman

Reviews / Votes

"Years after the events, the subject of gender and family during the Holocaust began to be researched and written about by scholars, and this volume is a welcome addition to the topic." - Michlean Lowy Amir, AJL News and Reviews "The publication If This is A Woman, edited by an international early career stage researchers' group, is not only an insightful contribution to history and memory studies, it also makes a necessary political statement in times where gender studies and the social position of women are experiencing backlashes across the world. The high level of self-reflection is a very characteristic feature of this volume and may be a symptom of the new generation of researchers reflecting on their own work and how they even are influenced by power imbalances in academia ... All contributions have been thoroughly researched and edited. ... The strength of this book... is that it provides new research on sources that are not available in English. The volume also demonstrates that historical research on gender and war is addressing very pressing issues." - Elisa-Maria Hiemer, H Soz Kult "What sets this volume apart from the other Holocaust scholarship are the introductions to new paths of research that use gender as a subject and a lens, and the fact that it features scholars whose work is otherwise unknown to English-language audiences... [T]he real success of the book is that it teases out exciting new horizons for Holocaust research, giving readers insight into questions previously unasked and looking at sources in innovative and exciting ways, such as Vastenhout's examination of the Jewish councils and Zabransky's analysis of the connections between religion and sexuality." - Morgan Morales, H-Judaic "[T]his newest volume offers a unique focus on Eastern Europe and features approaches to gendered experiences of the Holocaust that are far more theoretically and methodologically rigorous. ... Almost all the chapters in the volume utilize the micro-historical method to inform their theoretical engagement with gendered experiences of the Holocaust. As such, If This Is a Woman is a veritable repository of micro-historical research, which further magnifies its value as a methodological exemplar for future Holocaust research. ... As a result, the book is not simply valuable to those scholars looking for chapters relevant to their own specific localities of interest, but also to scholars searching for examples of theoretical rigor at the micro-scale." - Catharine Aretakis, Utrecht University, European Journal of Jewish Studies "The volume is... a welcome and useful reminder of the necessity and value of a gender-sensitive approach to the study of the Holocaust. Nearly 40 years after the spat about Joan Ringelheim's article discussing a feminist approach, it is time to take stock of scholarly achievements in the by now identifiable field, and If This Is a Woman does a great job doing so. ... [T]he book is coherent; it offers a focused investigation of various dimensions of the Holocaust and World War II. ... Critically exploring the experience of females, gender relations, representation and politics, as well as sexuality and sexual violence under the Nazi regime... will offer a toolbox for the struggle against the conservative and authoritarian regimes in Hungary, Poland, Slovakia, and elsewhere. Refreshing is the reminder that feminist perspectives must not only shape our methodologies, but ought to also encourage us to intervene in institutionalized exclusionary academic practices by creating spaces of constructive critique benefiting junior and female scholars. Lastly, the volume puts forth the work of scholars from, and studies of the Holocaust in the region and thus adds an important perspective on gender ideologies as well as victim experiences under German occupation and in camps and ghettos. ... All chapters are concise and well argued... Several chapters provide not only well-researched and argued studies of individual aspects, they also chart paths for future research." - Anika Walke, Zeitschrift fuer Ostmitteleuropa-Forschung "If This Is a Woman, a collection of well-documented scholarly essays, brings us new insights on women and gender during the Holocaust. Originating in Slovakia, the birthplace of Holocaust heroes Gisi Fleischmann and Haviva Reick, this book is an important contribution to giving women their place in Holocaust history. With the focus on East-Central Europe and some essays the result of research in Russian, Polish, Slovakian, or Ukrainian archives, the book gives English language readers access to important new information on women and gender." - Rochelle G. Saidel, PhD, Founder and Executive Director, Remember the Women Institute, New York City