Media Control

Reviews / Votes

Media Control is a rare, critical look at the power of news at a time of increased surveillance and policing. It's a must read for journalists, citizens and scholars who are concerned about the future of a free society-and their role in it. * Thom Hartmann, Progressive Commentator and New York Times Best-Selling Author of The Crash of 2016: The Plot to Destroy America and What We Can Do to Stop It * In a reflexive account of media control, Robert Gutsche revives the news-as-propaganda model of journalism. He argues that news of fear today justifies government surveillance and militaristic force, reifies power structures that privilege the rich and well positioned, and establishes stark and helpful good-evil demarcations in society. Whether or not you agree with his assessments, Gutsche's work is a radical statement about the complicit role the press has in promoting fear, violence, and social control. Media Control offers an alternative perspective about the role of journalism reminiscent of Noam Chomsky, and represents a conversation piece that would be useful in journalism classes and among those interested in assessing media, journalism education and their function in a democratic society. * Sue Robinson, Associate Professor of Journalism and Mass Communication, University of Wisconsin-Madison, USA * This brave and groundbreaking book in critical journalism throws a devastating blow to the myth about the media and police neutrality. Far from it, Robert Gutsche posits, these two centers of power share the same objective: social control of local communities. Local 'news' about crime, the argument goes, create the local community in its own image; in such capacity, 'news' about crime acts as a symbolic police force patrolling the very space it has created and owns, as its own beat. To the extent that Gutsche takes a cue from Chomsky's and Greenwald's scrutiny of the global media, and shifts the critical focus onto local media and its coverage of a crime, Media Control is a must read for every student studying journalism. * Dusan I. Bjelic, Professor of Criminology, University of Southern Maine, USA * Although not explicitly stated by the founding fathers, but clearly explicated here, is that ultimately what the media has today (and perhaps has always had) is power; specifically, the power to inform, the power to persuade, and the power to help steer the opinions of vast swaths of the population on topics ranging from perceptions of war to their perception of politicians. In this clearly elucidated book, Robert Gutsche helps readers understand how the media wield power. It is a must-read for scholars, laypeople, and anyone who is just interested in knowing about the workings of the media, the construction of news, and ultimately what effect the media does, and does not have, on people's perception of reality. * Lanier Frush Holt, Assistant Professor of Communication, The Ohio State University, USA * As the battle to control information in a digital world intensifies, this book places front and center the media's ability to shape meaning in our everyday lives and its relationship to the 'Power Elite.' Through notions of propaganda, controversy, conspiracy and place-making, this book won't just rattle some journalism cages that seek to preserve classical notions of news media and power - it will shatter them. The book also addresses a paucity of scholarly work on the local press by examining issues of media control closest to home. This is a timely and valuable contribution to the field. A must read. * Kristy Hess, Senior Lecturer in Journalism, Deakin University, Australia * In contrast to books on modern media that examine control of media by financial elites and corporations, Gutsche's important study provides a rare look at how media collaborate with power elites in order to maintain social control. ... He builds his study on theory developed by cultural studies scholars Stuart Hall and James Carey and critical studies media scholar Robert McChesney. ... His analyses of the local media are helpful as a starting point for understanding the role of newspapers and radio and television stations sprinkled throughout the US. Summing Up: Recommended. Lower-division undergraduates through faculty and professionals; general readers. * CHOICE * Gutsche succeeds in what he set out to do. He contributes critical, nuanced, accessible analysis of the press as an act of power. The book succeeds for three reasons. First, Gutsche effectively married theory to analysis. No one will accuse him of academic laziness. Second, his use of recent events such as the Sandy Hook massacre capitalizes on reader memory. Finally, Gutsche's passion bleeds from each page. If it is true that all research is autobiographical, then may we all be so willing to look within ourselves for what needs to be studied next. * Journal of Communication Inquiry *