Historical Dynamics
Why States Rise and Fall
1st Edition
Published on 9. July 2018
264 pages
978-1-4008-8931-0 (ISBN)
Description
Many historical processes are dynamic. Populations grow and decline. Empires expand and collapse. Religions spread and wither. Natural scientists have made great strides in understanding dynamical processes in the physical and biological worlds using a synthetic approach that combines mathematical modeling with statistical analyses. Taking up the problem of territorial dynamics--why some polities at certain times expand and at other times contract--this book shows that a similar research program can advance our understanding of dynamical processes in history.
Peter Turchin develops hypotheses from a wide range of social, political, economic, and demographic factors: geopolitics, factors affecting collective solidarity, dynamics of ethnic assimilation/religious conversion, and the interaction between population dynamics and sociopolitical stability. He then translates these into a spectrum of mathematical models, investigates the dynamics predicted by the models, and contrasts model predictions with empirical patterns. Turchin's highly instructive empirical tests demonstrate that certain models predict empirical patterns with a very high degree of accuracy. For instance, one model accounts for the recurrent waves of state breakdown in medieval and early modern Europe. And historical data confirm that ethno-nationalist solidarity produces an aggressively expansive state under certain conditions (such as in locations where imperial frontiers coincide with religious divides). The strength of Turchin's results suggests that the synthetic approach he advocates can significantly improve our understanding of historical dynamics.
Peter Turchin develops hypotheses from a wide range of social, political, economic, and demographic factors: geopolitics, factors affecting collective solidarity, dynamics of ethnic assimilation/religious conversion, and the interaction between population dynamics and sociopolitical stability. He then translates these into a spectrum of mathematical models, investigates the dynamics predicted by the models, and contrasts model predictions with empirical patterns. Turchin's highly instructive empirical tests demonstrate that certain models predict empirical patterns with a very high degree of accuracy. For instance, one model accounts for the recurrent waves of state breakdown in medieval and early modern Europe. And historical data confirm that ethno-nationalist solidarity produces an aggressively expansive state under certain conditions (such as in locations where imperial frontiers coincide with religious divides). The strength of Turchin's results suggests that the synthetic approach he advocates can significantly improve our understanding of historical dynamics.
More details
Other editions
Additional editions
Book
10/2003
Princeton University Press
€66.30
Article not available at the moment
Person
Peter Turchin is Professor of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at the University of Connecticut. He is the author of Quantitative Analysis of Movement and Complex Population Dynamics (Princeton).
Content
List of Figures viii
List of Tables x
Preface xi
Chapter 1. Statement of the Problem 1
1.1 Why Do We Need a Mathematical Theory in History? 1
1.2 Historical Dynamics as a Research Program 3
1.2.1 Delimiting the Set of Questions 4
1.2.2 AFocus on Agrarian Polities 4
1.2.3 The Hierarchical Modeling Approach 5
1.2.4 Mathematical Framework 5
1.3 Summary 7
Chapter 2. Geopolitics 9
2.1 APrimer of Dynamics 9
2.1.1 Boundless Growth 9
2.1.2 Equilibrial Dynamics 11
2.1.3 Boom/Bust Dynamics and Sustained Oscillations 12
2.1.4 Implications for Historical Dynamics 14
2.2 The Collins Theory of Geopolitics 16
2.2.1 Modeling Size and Distance Effects 16
2.2.2 Positional Effects 20
2.2.3 Conflict-legitimacy Dynamics 23
2.3 Conclusion: Geopolitics as a First-order Process 25
2.4 Summary 27
Chapter 3. Collective Solidarity 29
3.1 Groups in Sociology 29
3.1.1 Groups as Analytical Units 29
3.1.2 Evolution of Solidaristic Behaviors 31
3.1.3 Ethnic Groups and Ethnicity 33
3.1.4 The Social Scale 34
3.1.5 Ethnies 36
3.2 Collective Solidarity and Historical Dynamics 36
3.2.1 Ibn Khaldun's Theory 38
3.2.2 Gumilev's Theory 40
3.2.3 The Modern Context 42
3.3 Summary 47
Chapter 4. The Metaethnic Frontier Theory 50
4.1 Frontiers as Incubators of Group Solidarity 50
4.1.1 Factors Causing Solidarity Increase 51
4.1.2 Imperial Boundaries and Metaethnic Fault Lines 53
4.1.3 Scaling-up Structures 57
4.1.4 Placing the Metaethnic Frontier Theory in Context 59
4.2 Mathematical Theory 63
4.2.1 A Simple Analytical Model 64
4.2.2 A Spatially Explicit Simulation 68
4.3 Summary 75
Chapter 5. An Empirical Test of the Metaethnic Frontier Theory 78
5.1 Setting Up the Test 78
5.1.1 Quantifying Frontiers 79
5.1.2 Polity Size 81
5.2 Results 83
5.2.1 Europe:0 -1000 c.e.83
5.2.2 Europe:1000 -1900 c.e.86
5.3 Positional Advantage? 89
5.4 Conclusion: The Making of Europe 91
5.5 Summary 92
Chapter 6. Ethnokinetics 94
6.1 Allegiance Dynamics of Incorporated Populations 94
6.2 Theory 95
6.2.1 Nonspatial Models of Assimilation 95
6.2.2 Spatially Explicit Models 99
6.3 Empirical Tests 104
6.3.1 Conversion to Islam 105
6.3.2 The Rise of Christianity 111
6.3.3 The Growth of the Mormon Church 112
6.4 Conclusion: Data Support the Autocatalytic Model 113
6.5 Summary 116
Chapter 7. The Demographic-Structural Theory 118
7.1 Population Dynamics and State Breakdown 118
7.2 Mathematical Theory 121
7.2.1 The Basic Demographic-Fiscal Model 121
7.2.2 Adding Class Structure 127
7.2.3 Models for Elite Cycles 131
7.2.4 Models for the Chinese Dynastic Cycle 137
7.2.5 Summing up Theoretical Insights 138
7.3 Empirical Applications 140
7.3.1 Periodic Breakdowns of Early Modern States 140
7.3.2 The Great Wave 143
7.3.3 After the Black Death 145
7.4 Summary 148
Chapter 8. Secular Cycles in Population Numbers 150
8.1 Introduction 150
8.2 "Scale" and "Order" in Human Population Dynamics 150
8.3 Long-Term Empirical Patterns 155
8.3.1 Reconstructions of Historical Populations 155
8.3.2 Archaeological Data 161
8.4 Population Dynamics and Political Instability 164
8.5 Summary 167
Chapter 9. Case Studies 170
9.1 France 170
9.1.1 The Frontier Origins 170
9.1.2 Secular Waves 176
9.1.3 Summary 184
9.2 Russia 184
9.2.1 The Frontier Origins 184
9.2.2 Secular Waves 191
9.2.3 Summary 196
Chapter 10. Conclusion 197
10.1 Overview of Main Developments 197
10.1.1 Asabiya and Metaethnic Frontiers 197
10.1.2 Ethnic Assimilation 198
10.1.3 Demographic-Structural Theory 199
10.1.4 Geopolitics 199
10.2 Combining Different Mechanisms into an Integrated Whole 200
10.3 Broadening the Focus of Investigation 203
10.4 Toward Theoretical Cliodynamics? 204
Appendix A. Mathematical Appendix 205
A.1 Translating the Hanneman Model into Differential Equations 205
A.2 The Spatial Simulation of the Frontier Hypothesis 206
A.3 Demographic-Structural Models with Class Structure 208
A.4 Models for Elite Cycles 212
Appendix B. Data Summaries for the Test of the Metaethnic Frontier Theory 214
B.1 Brief Descriptions of "Cultural Regions" 214
B.2 Quantification of Frontiers 215
B.3 Quantification of Polity Sizes: The First Millennium c.e. 224
B.4 Quantification of Polity Sizes: The Second Millennium c.e. 225
Bibliography 226
Index 243
List of Tables x
Preface xi
Chapter 1. Statement of the Problem 1
1.1 Why Do We Need a Mathematical Theory in History? 1
1.2 Historical Dynamics as a Research Program 3
1.2.1 Delimiting the Set of Questions 4
1.2.2 AFocus on Agrarian Polities 4
1.2.3 The Hierarchical Modeling Approach 5
1.2.4 Mathematical Framework 5
1.3 Summary 7
Chapter 2. Geopolitics 9
2.1 APrimer of Dynamics 9
2.1.1 Boundless Growth 9
2.1.2 Equilibrial Dynamics 11
2.1.3 Boom/Bust Dynamics and Sustained Oscillations 12
2.1.4 Implications for Historical Dynamics 14
2.2 The Collins Theory of Geopolitics 16
2.2.1 Modeling Size and Distance Effects 16
2.2.2 Positional Effects 20
2.2.3 Conflict-legitimacy Dynamics 23
2.3 Conclusion: Geopolitics as a First-order Process 25
2.4 Summary 27
Chapter 3. Collective Solidarity 29
3.1 Groups in Sociology 29
3.1.1 Groups as Analytical Units 29
3.1.2 Evolution of Solidaristic Behaviors 31
3.1.3 Ethnic Groups and Ethnicity 33
3.1.4 The Social Scale 34
3.1.5 Ethnies 36
3.2 Collective Solidarity and Historical Dynamics 36
3.2.1 Ibn Khaldun's Theory 38
3.2.2 Gumilev's Theory 40
3.2.3 The Modern Context 42
3.3 Summary 47
Chapter 4. The Metaethnic Frontier Theory 50
4.1 Frontiers as Incubators of Group Solidarity 50
4.1.1 Factors Causing Solidarity Increase 51
4.1.2 Imperial Boundaries and Metaethnic Fault Lines 53
4.1.3 Scaling-up Structures 57
4.1.4 Placing the Metaethnic Frontier Theory in Context 59
4.2 Mathematical Theory 63
4.2.1 A Simple Analytical Model 64
4.2.2 A Spatially Explicit Simulation 68
4.3 Summary 75
Chapter 5. An Empirical Test of the Metaethnic Frontier Theory 78
5.1 Setting Up the Test 78
5.1.1 Quantifying Frontiers 79
5.1.2 Polity Size 81
5.2 Results 83
5.2.1 Europe:0 -1000 c.e.83
5.2.2 Europe:1000 -1900 c.e.86
5.3 Positional Advantage? 89
5.4 Conclusion: The Making of Europe 91
5.5 Summary 92
Chapter 6. Ethnokinetics 94
6.1 Allegiance Dynamics of Incorporated Populations 94
6.2 Theory 95
6.2.1 Nonspatial Models of Assimilation 95
6.2.2 Spatially Explicit Models 99
6.3 Empirical Tests 104
6.3.1 Conversion to Islam 105
6.3.2 The Rise of Christianity 111
6.3.3 The Growth of the Mormon Church 112
6.4 Conclusion: Data Support the Autocatalytic Model 113
6.5 Summary 116
Chapter 7. The Demographic-Structural Theory 118
7.1 Population Dynamics and State Breakdown 118
7.2 Mathematical Theory 121
7.2.1 The Basic Demographic-Fiscal Model 121
7.2.2 Adding Class Structure 127
7.2.3 Models for Elite Cycles 131
7.2.4 Models for the Chinese Dynastic Cycle 137
7.2.5 Summing up Theoretical Insights 138
7.3 Empirical Applications 140
7.3.1 Periodic Breakdowns of Early Modern States 140
7.3.2 The Great Wave 143
7.3.3 After the Black Death 145
7.4 Summary 148
Chapter 8. Secular Cycles in Population Numbers 150
8.1 Introduction 150
8.2 "Scale" and "Order" in Human Population Dynamics 150
8.3 Long-Term Empirical Patterns 155
8.3.1 Reconstructions of Historical Populations 155
8.3.2 Archaeological Data 161
8.4 Population Dynamics and Political Instability 164
8.5 Summary 167
Chapter 9. Case Studies 170
9.1 France 170
9.1.1 The Frontier Origins 170
9.1.2 Secular Waves 176
9.1.3 Summary 184
9.2 Russia 184
9.2.1 The Frontier Origins 184
9.2.2 Secular Waves 191
9.2.3 Summary 196
Chapter 10. Conclusion 197
10.1 Overview of Main Developments 197
10.1.1 Asabiya and Metaethnic Frontiers 197
10.1.2 Ethnic Assimilation 198
10.1.3 Demographic-Structural Theory 199
10.1.4 Geopolitics 199
10.2 Combining Different Mechanisms into an Integrated Whole 200
10.3 Broadening the Focus of Investigation 203
10.4 Toward Theoretical Cliodynamics? 204
Appendix A. Mathematical Appendix 205
A.1 Translating the Hanneman Model into Differential Equations 205
A.2 The Spatial Simulation of the Frontier Hypothesis 206
A.3 Demographic-Structural Models with Class Structure 208
A.4 Models for Elite Cycles 212
Appendix B. Data Summaries for the Test of the Metaethnic Frontier Theory 214
B.1 Brief Descriptions of "Cultural Regions" 214
B.2 Quantification of Frontiers 215
B.3 Quantification of Polity Sizes: The First Millennium c.e. 224
B.4 Quantification of Polity Sizes: The Second Millennium c.e. 225
Bibliography 226
Index 243
