Defeat and Division

Reviews / Votes

'A clear-eyed, ambitious and myth-busting account that places the Fall of France in 1940 and De Gaulle's Free French in a wider scenario that sees Vichy France and its colonial empire as a serious military player down to 1942. A tour de force by a historian who is a master of his craft.' Robert Gildea, author of Fighters in the Shadows: A New History of the French Resistance 'This superb and ambitious book will fill a very substantial gap (and puzzling) in the massive literature on the history of the Second World War. Douglas Porch has mastered an impressively diverse literature on the military, imperial, diplomatic, cultural and social history of France at war. This material is synthesised and combined with extensive work in the French archives to produce an important and original reinterpretation of France's wartime experience that will serve as a standard work for years to come.' Peter Jackson, author of Beyond the Balance of Power: France and the Politics of National Security in the Era of the First World War 'Comprehensive and encyclopaedic in its coverage, Defeat and Division is destined to become an invaluable resource for understanding the war in Europe. Porch has given us new lenses through which to see and understand the French war.' Michael Neiberg, author of When France Fell: Vichy and the Fate of the Anglo-American Alliance 'Douglas Porch has produced an important and much-needed new look at the darkest period in French history. Defeat and Division is a deeply researched, robustly argued and entertainingly written history of a France destroyed by the weaknesses of its own leadership. This is a book that anyone interested in the Second World War or modern French history should read.' Phillips O'Brien, author of How the War was Won: Air-Sea Power and Allied Victory in World War II 'This expansive study ... considers the experiences of POWs and resistors, concepts of masculinity, and the actions of French forces in North Africa during the Anglo-American operation to liberate France through the Armee d'Afrique. Recommended.' M. L. Scott, Choice 'In an age where academic social media relentlessly advertises novelty, Douglas Porch's 'Defeat and Division: France at War 1939-1942' reminds us of the ultimate purpose of a lifetime of scholarly achievement. It is to reach the point that one can write a book like this... His judgment is amply demonstrated in this powerful work, which is now the benchmark against which a future generation of centennial studies of France and World War II will be measured in the late 2030s and early 2040s.' Andrew Orr, H-War 'In an age where academic social media relentlessly advertises novelty, [this book] reminds us of the ultimate purpose of a lifetime of scholarly achievement. It is to reach the point that one can write a book like this. Porch's work reflects his deep knowledge and long familiarity with the history, culture, and historiography of the French military under the Third Republic.' Andrew Orr, H-Net Reviews