
The Effective Application of EU State Aid Procedures
Description
Alles über E-Books | Antworten auf Fragen rund um E-Books, Kopierschutz und Dateiformate finden Sie in unserem Info- & Hilfebereich.
rapidly in the present context of EU decentralization. Although the EU rules
governing state aid are widely discussed, there has been until now a dearth of
practice-oriented material on the actual implementation of these rules at the
national level. This important contribution to the ongoing debate on the
reform of the state aid system addresses for the first time the full scale of
procedural questions arising in the implementation of EU state aid law. It
covers all issues, ranging from the intention to grant an aid via judicial
protection for competitors right through to recovery of aid and judicial
protection of the beneficiary. The book presents the documentation on state
aid which was made available to the participants of the 22nd World Congress of
the Fédération Internationale de Droit Européenne (FIDE) at Cyprus in November
2006. Detailed reports by well-known practitioners or professors of law
discuss and analyze the implementation of EU State aid law in 17 EU Member
States, as well as Norway, Switzerland, and Croatia. The national reports,
based on a standard questionnaire, are preceded by an analytical general
report, comparing and assessing results of the analysis of Member States' law
in the light of Community law, and an EU report on state aid procedures.
Issues addressed include the following:
transparency obligations;
ensuring compliance with the notification obligation;
ensuring the compatibility of aid and the application of block exemptions;
recovery of aid;
limitation of judicial review; and
the position of state aid debt in bankruptcy proceedings.
No serious academic contribution to the present debate on the reform of state
aid law can afford to ignore this book. As a unique and thorough overview of
state-of-the-art knowledge on national law and practice on EU State aid
matters, this compendium will be of inestimable value to practitioners
involved in representing interests of beneficiaries and competitors before
national authorities or national courts, or before the European Commission or
European Courts. The analyses will also be welcomed by authorities granting
state aid, including public enterprises.
More details
Other editions
Additional editions

Content
- Cover
- Half Title Page
- Title Page
- Copyright Page
- Table of Contents
- Introduction
- Chapter 1 Questionnaire for National Rapporteurs set by Paul F. Nemitz, Head of Legal Affairs at DG Fisheries and Maritime Affairs of the European Commission
- INTRODUCTION
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- V. QUESTIONS TO THE FIDE 2006 EU RAPPORTEUR ON STATE AID
- Chapter 2 22. FIDE Congress, 1-4 November 2006, Cyprus
- A. INTRODUCTION: STRENGTHENING THE JUDICIAL DIALOGUE BETWEEN MEMBER STATE COURTS
- B. DISCUSSION OF THE ANSWERS TO THE QUESTIONNAIRE
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITHTHE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. THE EXECUTION OF RECOVERY DECISIONS
- C. CONCLUSION
- Chapter 3 Community Report
- I. INTRODUCTION
- II. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF NATIONAL STATE AID LAW - TRANSPARENCY OBLIGATIONS
- III. MECHANISM TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- A. INTRODUCTION: THE IMPORTANCE OF ARTICLE 88(3) EC FOR THE FUNCTIONING OF STATE AID CONTROL
- B. THE MAIN REASONS FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITH ARTICLE 88(3) EC
- C. IMPROVING COMPLIANCE WITH ARTICLE 88(3) EC - OBLIGATIONS AND BOUNDARIES UNDER EC LAW
- IV. MECHANISM TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- A. INTRODUCTION: THE COMMISSION'S EXAMINATION OF INDIVIDUAL STATE AID CASES AND THE APPLICATION OF BLOCK EXEMPTION REGULATIONS
- B. SECURING THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID WITH THE COMMON MARKET AND BLOCK EXEMPTION REGULATIONS - OBLIGATION AND BOUNDARIES UNDER EC LAW
- V. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND THE POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY PROCEEDINGS
- A. INTRODUCTION: THE EXECUTION OF THE COMMISSION'S RECOVERY DECISIONS IN PRACTICE
- B. THE IMMEDIATE AND EFFECTIVE RECOVERY OF ILLEGAL STATE AID UNDER EU LAW
- C. THE LIMITATION OF JUDICIAL REVIEW
- D. THE RECOVERY OF ILLEGAL STATE AID INTO THE COMMUNITY BUDGET
- E. THE RIGHT OF COMPETITORS TO ENFORCE RECOVERY DECISIONS VIS-À-VIS NATIONAL AUTHORITIES FROM AN EU LAW PERSPECTIVE
- F. THE RECOVERY OF ILLEGAL STATE AID FROM THE BENEFICIARY IN BANKRUPTCY PROCEEDINGS UNDER EU LAW
- Chapter 4 Austria
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- Chapter 5 Belgium
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF BELGIUM'S STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- A. COMPETENT COURTS FOR ENFORCING THE PROCEDURES CONCERNING THE DIRECT EFFECT OF ARTICLE 88 (3) EC
- B. PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COUNCIL OF STATE
- C. PROCEEDINGS BEFORE CIVIL COURTS
- D. PROCEDURE BEFORE THE COURT OF ARBITRATION (CONSTITUTIONAL COURT)
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- A. CHAPTER IV: RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- B. ADOPTION OF LEGISLATION IN ORDER TO ENSURE THE RECOVERY OF AID - THE MARIBEL CASE
- C. POSSIBILITIES FOR THE BENEFICIARY TO OBTAIN JUDICIAL REVIEW OF RECOVERY ACTION BY THE MEMBER STATE
- D. EXECUTION OF COMMISSION DECISIONS WHERE THE COMMISSION DECISION IS SUBJECT TO JUDICIAL REVIEW BY THE COMMUNITY COURTS
- E. POSSIBILITIES FOR COMPETITORS TO OBTAIN A JUDICIAL ORDER ENFORCING THE RECOVERY DECISION OF THE COMMISSION AGAINST THE MEMBER STATE
- F. RULES FOR THE RECOVERY OF AMOUNTS OWED TO THE STATE IN CASE OF BANKRUPTCY OF AN ECONOMIC OPERATOR
- Chapter 6 Croatia
- INTRODUCTION
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF CROATIA'S STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- Chapter 7 Cyprus
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- A. TRANSPARENCY OF THE AID GRANTING SYSTEM
- B. CHOICE BETWEEN DIFFERENT LEGAL FORMS FOR THE GRANTING OF AID
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- A. COMPLIANCE WITH THE RULES ON CUMULATION OF AID
- B. THIRD PARTY INTERESTS AND OVERALL CONTROL BY THE COURTS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- A. RECOVERY OF AID AND BANKRUPTCY RULES
- Chapter 8 Denmark
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- A. INTRODUCTION
- B. THE PRINCIPLE OF LEGALITY AND THE BUDGETARY RULES
- C. DIFFERENT STATE AID SCHEMES
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- A. THE ROLE OF THE DANISH COMPETITION AUTHORITY
- B. JUDICIAL REVIEW OF THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- C. THE COMBUS CASE
- D. INCENTIVES TO AVOID THE GRANTING OF ILLEGAL AID
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- A. DANISH STATE AID LAW
- B. JUDICIAL REVIEW
- C. DE MINIMIS AID AND CUMULATION OF AID
- D. COMPATIBILITY OF STATE AID AT THE NATIONAL LEVEL
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- A. THE ROLE OF THE NATIONAL COURTS
- B. RECOVERY OF STATE AID FROM UNDERTAKINGS UNDERGOING BANKRUPTCY PROCEEDINGS
- C. RECOVERY OF EU STATE AID - THE TV2 CASE
- D. RECOVERY OF STATE AID AT THE NATIONAL LEVEL
- Chapter 9 Finland
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISM TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF SATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- Chapter 10 France
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- A. THE COMPETENT COURTS
- B. THE DIFFERENT ACTIONS
- C. PARTICULAR CASE: LIABILITY ACTIONS
- D. THE OBSTACLES FOR INTERESTED PARTIES TO OBTAIN ENFORCEMENT OF THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION BY NATIONAL COURTS
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- A. RECOVERY BY THE STATE
- B. RECOVERY BY LOCAL AUTHORITIES
- C. JUDICIAL REVIEW OF RECOVERY ACTION BY BENEFICIARY
- D. THE ACTION OF COMPETITORS IN OBTAINING A JUDICIAL ORDER TO ENFORCE COMMISSION RECOVERY DECISION AGAINST MEMBER STATES
- E. INSOLVENCY PROCEEDINGS
- F. ASSESSMENT OF THE EXECUTION OF COMMISSION DECISIONS IN FRANCE
- G. IDENTIFICATION OF BEST PRACTICES AND REMEDIES FOR IMMEDIATE AND EFFECTIVE RECOVERY
- Chapter 11 Germany
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF GERMANY'S STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- V. CONCLUSION
- Chapter 12 Greece
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES AND STRUCTURES OF 'GREEK STATE AID LAW' AND CONTROL SYSTEM
- A. INTRODUCTION
- B. GENERAL OUTLINE OF THE MAIN STRUCTURES OF GREEK STATE AID LAW
- C. A REPRESENTATIVE EXAMPLE OF A GREEK GENERAL AID SCHEME: THE LAW ON 'PRIVATE INVESTMENT INCENTIVES FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND REGIONAL CONVERGENCE'
- II. NOTIFICATION ISSUES AND MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE PROCEDURAL REQUIREMENTS OF THE EC STATE AID CONTROL SYSTEM
- A. THE GREEK STATE AID NOTIFICATION SYSTEM
- B. COMPLIANCE MECHANISMS
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF GREEK COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN GREEK BANKRUPTCY LAW
- A. LEGAL CONSEQUENCES OF THE ILLEGALITY OF STATE AID MEASURES AND IMPLICATIONS FOR THE GREEK LEGAL SYSTEM
- B. IMPLEMENTATION OF RECOVERY DECISIONS: TENSIONS BETWEEN THE GREEK LEGAL SYSTEM AND THE EC LAW REQUIREMENTS?
- Chapter 13 Ireland
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- Chapter 14 Italy
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF ITALIAN STATE AID LAW
- A. THE LEGAL BASIS FOR THE GRANTING OF THE AID
- B. THE POSITION OF BENEFICIARIES IN CASE THE CONDITIONS FOR THE GRANTING OF AID LAID DOWN UNDER NATIONAL RULES ARE COMPLIED WITH
- C. THE TRANSPARENCY OF THE AID. LACK OF ANY OBLIGATION TO MAKE AMOUNTS OF STATE AID TRANSPARENT.
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- A. THE ABSENCE OF A NATIONAL AUTHORITY ENSURING THAT ARTICLE 88 (3) OF THE TREATY AND ART. 14 OF REGULATION 659/1999 ARE COMPLIED WITH
- B. THE PROCEDURES FORESEEN UNDER NATIONAL LAW TO ENSURE THE ENFORCEMENT OF THE NOTIFICATION REQUIREMENT
- C. THE ENFORCEMENT OF THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION AND THE JUDICIAL PROTECTION OF PRIVATE PARTIES BEFORE NATIONAL COURTS IN CASE OF THE GRANTING OF ILLEGAL AID
- D. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS IN ITALY
- E. THE RECOVERY OF ILLEGAL AID UNDER ITALIAN LEGISLATION
- Chapter 15 Latvia
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- Chapter 16 Application of EU State Aid Law in the Netherlands
- I. INTRODUCTION
- II. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF DUTCH LAW WITH REGARD TO STATE AID
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- IV. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- V. RECOVERY OF AID - THE ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND THE POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- VI. CONCLUSION
- Chapter 17 Norway
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- Chapter 18 Poland
- INTRODUCTION
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - THE ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND THE POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- FINAL REMARKS
- Chapter 19 State Aids in Portugal
- I. INTRODUCTION
- II. BASIC PRINCIPLES AND CASES OF PUBLIC SUPPORT IN PORTUGAL
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE EC OBLIGATIONS
- IV. THE APPLICATION OF BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- V. CASE (S) OF RECOVERING UNLAWFUL STATE AID IN PORTUGAL
- Chapter 20 Spain
- INTRODUCTION
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Chapter 21 Sweden
- I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF MEMBER STATES' STATE AID LAW
- II. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- III. MECHANISMS TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- IV. RECOVERY OF AID - ROLE OF NATIONAL COURTS AND POSITION OF STATE AID DEBT IN BANKRUPTCY LAW
- Chapter 22 Switzerland
- I. PRELIMINARY REMARKS
- II. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF SWISS LAW ON SUBSIDIES
- III. MECHANISM TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE NOTIFICATION OBLIGATION
- IV. MECHANISM TO ENSURE THE COMPATIBILITY OF AID AND THE APPLICATION OF THE BLOCK EXEMPTIONS
- V. RECOVERY OF AID
- Chapter 23 United Kingdom
- ANNEX 1: UK AUTHORITIES WITH RESPONSIBILITY FOR STATE AIDS
- CENTRAL GOVERNMENT
- SCOTLAND
- WALES
- NORTHERN IRELAND
- Back Cover
System requirements
File format: PDF
Copy-Protection: Adobe-DRM (Digital Rights Management)
System requirements:
- Computer (Windows; MacOS X; Linux): Install the free reader Adobe Digital Editions prior to download (see eBook Help).
- Tablet/smartphone (Android; iOS): Install the free app Adobe Digital Editions or the app PocketBook before downloading (see eBook Help).
- E-reader: Bookeen, Kobo, Pocketbook, Sony, Tolino and many more (only limited: Kindle).
The file format PDF always displays a book page identically on any hardware. This makes PDF suitable for complex layouts such as those used in textbooks and reference books (images, tables, columns, footnotes). Unfortunately, on the small screens of e-readers or smartphones, PDFs are rather annoying, requiring too much scrolling.
This eBook uses Adobe-DRM, a „hard” copy protection. If the necessary requirements are not met, unfortunately you will not be able to open the eBook. You will therefore need to prepare your reading hardware before downloading.
Please note: We strongly recommend that you authorise using your personal Adobe ID after installation of any reading software.
For more information, see our eBook Help page.