Sacrifice and Rebirth

Reviews / Votes

"Perhaps fittingly for its subject matter, this collection, made up of diverse approaches and viewpoints, comes together to create a cohesive whole that should be required reading for students of the First World War and the interwar period. More than that, however, the contributors have offered us a remarkable insight into practices of memorialization and commemoration in the context of a multifarious legacy... In bringing light to this, the authors, and especially the editors Cornwall and Newman, are not just to be congratulated but also thanked." * European History Quarterly



"...a welcome addition to the literature on the memory politics of the Great War. It offers an important contribution to a growing scholarship on interpretations of the war in Central and Eastern Europe, an area that has largely been neglected...The geographical spread of the chapters highlights important continuities that went beyond the Habsburg Empire. The volume's innovative aspect is further assisted by the themes and topics that are covered within the chapters." * European Review of History



"Cornwall and Newman have produced an important work on postwar memories. This volume serves as a solid ?rst step into deeper works on the individual experiences and constructed memories of the successor states and their populations." * Austrian History Yearbook



"...a crucial addition to the growing field of post-Habsburg studies...While other scholars and politicians shaped the broad memory of the Habsburg Empire, the veterans, commemorative committees, and memorial organizations in Sacrifice and Rebirth defined the fresher and deeper wounds of war. This book is highly recommended." * Journal of Austrian Studies



"Both the editors and Berghahn books are to be congratulated on having produced an exceptional collection of essays for three reasons in particular. First, these essays address common questions in a highly coherent fashion. Secondly, despite their common focus, the essays offer a range of creative and sometimes new approaches to a difficult set of questions that are only now beginning to be addressed by historians. Third, this collection offers an excellent attempt to go beyond the imperial fragmentation of 1918 that created several often mutually antagonistic historiographies, and to relativize the meaning of 1918 for the region. Thus the volume helps the reader to understand several critical and influential continuities that survived the official end of empire." * Central Europe



"By following the many ways in which the Great War was framed and interpreted all over the former Habsburg Monarchy, this collection provides a fantastic foundation for fresh and thought-provoking comparisons throughout Central and Eastern Europe and the Balkans, and makes a strong argument for overcoming the hitherto prevailing focus on single successor states." * H-Soz-Kult



"This volume of fascinating chapters will be welcomed by scholars and students of East Central Europe as well as by those interested in the legacy and memory of the Great War. Far too little scholarly work has engaged questions about war veterans, public grappling with the meaning of wartime sacrifice, and the memorialization of the dead in the new states that arose from the ashes of the Habsburg Monarchy." * Daniel Unowsky, University of Memphis



"This is a strong collection that fills an important gap. Though memory and memorials of the Great War have become a fashionable subject... the Habsburg lands have been largely neglected hitherto." * Robert Evans, University of Oxford