When the State Meets the Street

Reviews / Votes

When the State Meets the Street reads as one might imagine a collaboration between Bernard Williams, Richard Sennett, and James Scott could turn out. If there can be such a thing as an instant classic, this book is one. -- David Owen, University of Southampton In this refreshing study, Zacka finds in the commonplace decision-making of street level bureaucrats an implicit but coherent moral structure. When citizens experience the state through street-level encounters, the author shows, they are subject to moral reasoning no less than when elected officials expand or contract social welfare policies, or bring a nation to war. -- Michael Lipsky, author of <i>Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services</i> Beautifully written, tightly argued, and totally original. -- Michael Piore, Massachusetts Institute of Technology In his groundbreaking book When the State Meets the Street: Public Service and Moral Agency, Bernardo Zacka illustrates a new methodological approach for political theory, opens up avenues of normative research on the neglected topic of bureaucracy and bureaucrats and overturns an intellectually dubious, but nonetheless dominant, model of the state...Zacka's discussion is subtle and thoughtful and opens many avenues for political and moral theorists to explore. -- Alex Sager * LSE Review of Books * This book...not only offers a valuable contribution to the street-level bureaucracy literature, but is also an essential read for political theorists interested in a bottom-up account of the state. -- Nadine Raaphorst * Acta Politica * Zacka's application of normative theory to state-level bureaucrats and his efforts at injecting ethnographically informed descriptive evidence into political theory are to be applauded and should represent a vanguard in political theory. -- Timothy Werner * Administrative Science Quarterly * An exemplary and exquisitely written book from which sociologists have much to learn. -- Gretchen Purser * American Journal of Sociology * Drawing from first-hand observations adds an anthropological sensitivity to the book, in the process showing that political philosophers have much to gain from venturing into the real world. The result is an original book that most democratic theorists should read, especially those interested in moral reasoning in everyday life. -- Jan Pieter Beetz * Constellations * Zacka persuasively argues that street-level bureaucrats are, in fact, moral agents 'vested with a considerable margin of discretion.' More importantly, he makes a compelling case for the normative desirability of that discretionary power...The book draws on a broad array of literatures, from other qualitative work on bureaucracies to psychology, sociology, and normative political philosophy, providing Zacka with an astounding and productive array of interlocutors...Zacka's remarkable book opens up many intriguing questions and will hopefully be one of many future studies that combine the virtues of an ethnographic approach and normative political theory. -- Yuna Blajer de la Garza * Contemporary Political Theory * Drawing eclectically from a breathtakingly wide range of sources and disciplinary approaches to the study of politics, policy, and organizations, Zacka develops a robust and analytically rigorous framework for understanding street-level work that builds on, and ultimately surpasses, Lipsky's original treatment in several respects. -- Chad Broughton * Contemporary Sociology * It is wide-ranging in its theoretical breadth, evocative in its traversing of theory and practice, and convincing in its marshalling of argument. Above all, it is stylish. It makes bureaucracy-largely neglected in contemporary political theory as technical, apolitical, mundane-intellectually sexy...Brilliant. -- John Boswell * Critical Policy Studies * When the State Meets the Street offers an innovative take on the conditions of and possibilities for frontline workers' moral agency. Further, the strength of this work is grounded in Zacka's engagement with previous qualitative research on frontline workers, moving seamlessly from vocational rehabilitation agents in the United States to immigration agents in France...An essential read. -- Sule Tomkinson * Governance * A thoughtful book that usefully brings the tools of political theory to bear on questions of public administration. It argues persuasively that democratic theorists need to pay attention not just to the principles and the institutions that shape our laws but also to the street-level bureaucrats who interpret and apply them. -- Clarissa Rile Hayward * Perspectives on Politics * One emerges from this insightful book with a considerable measure of respect for bureaucrats...Studying their experience as well as their behavior, is indeed, 'an experiment in living,' as well as a test of our own values and vision. It is, or should be, humbling. -- Glenn C. Altschuler * Psychology Today * An examination of street level bureaucracy rooted in anthropological fieldwork, but with the philosopher's toolkit dexterously deployed, it announces [Zacka] as a major new voice. -- Paul Sagar * Political Quarterly * Since Michael Lipsky coined the term in 1969, street-level bureaucracy has developed into a scholarly theme of its own. Nevertheless, the normative dimensions of the work done in this segment of government bureaucracy have remained almost entirely in the shadow so far. Filling this lacuna the book is an absolute must-read. -- Peter Hupe * Public Administration * An excellent piece of work that will interest researchers, current and future policy makers, public administrators, and nonprofit leaders as well as students. But more importantly, as part of the need to integrate more political science in the study of public administration, this is a book that is particularly important to political scientists and implementation scholars. -- Nissim Cohen * Public Administration Review * When the State Meets the Street is both a strikingly original work and a penetrating analysis of governmental decision-making. Not only is the book a sophisticated deconstruction of the administrative state, it also encourages liberty-minded readers to expand their intellectual horizons beyond the traditional citizen-government relationship. -- John Ehrett * The University Bookman * From its novel theorizing about the normative underpinnings of discretion to the nuanced discussion of the 'impossible situations' faced by street-level bureaucrats, When the State Meets the Street is essential reading that ought to inform the work of scholars and practitioners alike. -- Yanilda Mari?a Gonza?lez * Social Service Review * A sophisticated and empirically rich theorization of street-level agency and discretion. Through close and evocative appreciation of the conflicts and dilemmas posed by street-level work, it yields numerous valuable insights into everyday practice. -- James Kaufman * Social Policy & Administration * A really rich and rewarding read. It fizzes with stimulating insights and ideas and offers the kind of empathetic portrayal of street-level bureaucracy which participant-observation is particularly good at. -- Simon Halliday * Social & Legal Studies * A bold and interesting contribution...Given the recent 'behavioral turn' in public administration, Zacka's unique efforts to understand individual behavior in relation to social dynamic provides an alternative, serious mezzo-level explanation that should not be overlooked. -- Jodi R. Sandfort * American Review of Public Administration * An unusual work of political theory, invigorating and innovative in terms of its methodology and argumentative thread...Its arguments are the result of a reflection on observed practices and on interpretations and analyses of similar practices in philosophical and social scientific literatures. The perceptiveness and care with which it builds taxonomies for the intra- and interpersonal challenges involved in navigating the normative demands of street-level bureaucracy are an outstanding example of this approach. This perceptiveness and care allow Zacka to address several audiences differently, thus providing orientation for political theorists, for street-level practitioners and their managers, and for citizens dealing with public services. Each of these audiences may come away with changed views. -- Janosch Prinz * Polity *