Environment Matters

Reviews / Votes

<<Whidden and Shore wrestle with a long-held recognition of the impact of surroundings on the resultant music created. Through the identification of three different Habitats, Outdoors, Indoors, and Electronic, they systematically investigate what this impact may be. Each Habitat is explored through detailed analyses including various Canadian Indigenous musics for the <<Outdoors>>, and a consideration of Western notated [classical] musics emerging initially from European monasteries and churches for the <<Indoors>>. They raise many interesting observations and queries after their consideration of the impact of electronics on music of the past century. In short, a masterful study initiated to some degree by the insights of Canadians, R. Murray Schafer and Daniel J. Levitin.>> (Dr. Elaine Keillor, C.M. Distinguished Research Professor Emerita, Carleton University)











<<Ethnomusicology and the study of music history so often get bogged down in minutiae that it is wonderful to see a pair of scholars from these different but related fields collaborating to develop an overarching vision of the ways in which the natural, built and electronic environments have influenced music-making over many centuries. [...] Just as the size of medieval cathedrals had a massive impact on the evolution of medieval and Renaissance church music, resulting in complex polyphony, so the growing size of concert halls and opera venues in nineteenth-century Europe transformed <<classical>> music, facilitating Wagner's <<Ring>> and Mahler's <<Symphony of a Thousand.>> We've seen a similar thing happen in twentieth-century popular music with the emergence of forms of rock music (e.g. heavy metal) designed for very powerful loudspeaker systems in huge auditoria. [This] work is important because it stimulates us to re-examine the ways different human environments have played diverse roles in influencing the initial creation of new musical forms and modifying their subsequent development. It's a new way of looking at music history, and the possibilities are endless.>> (Dr E. David Gregory, Professor Emeritus, Athabasca University)











<<In this ground-breaking study, Whidden and Shore expand the discussion of <<music>> to include the associations that link music with the outdoors, the indoors, and electronic reproduction. These are the spaces where humans create, perform, and listen to music. Their systematic study has widened and deepened my understanding of musical experience.>> (Lawrence Jones, DMA, Professor Emeritus, School of Music, Brandon University)











<<Environment Matters is a fascinating study of the various habitats that frame music as we know it today. While the sounds of nature are the primary environment, man-made indoor music became our prevalent source of music, before the onset of electronic transmission and creation of sound catapulted our society into the modern world filled with the miracles and problems of applied technology. The book not only provides an analysis of this musical evolution, but also offers a highly interesting outlook on future developments. A must!>> (Matthias Maute, conductor, composer, musician)