Bodies Out of Control

Reviews / Votes

<<In 'Bodies out of Control', Matthew Weinstein provides a vivid analysis of how disease, cancer, anthrax, and medical research are represented as both the subject and object of science in the classroom, community and transnational discourse. Weinstein challenges the reader to consider why such sociopolitical issues are so often erased from the discourse of school science. In doing so, his book reveals how critical engagement with the text of science and its concomitant ways of knowing and being, such as that of the guinea pigs and the anthrax workers, deprivilege the authority of text and teacher. Exposing and understanding just these sorts of contradictions between the world of school science and the world of corporate-community-personal science deepen the field's understanding of what we seek for when we claim 'scientific literacy for all'. Weinstein builds a strong case for why we should be concerned with science multiliteracy for all, pushing back against the monolithic narrative that frames school science.>> (Angela Calabrese Barton, Professor of Teacher Education, Michigan State University)
<<'Bodies Our of Control' is a witty and intriguing invitation to a conversation of hope for a new science education of students and the public through a re-reading and even re-writing of the familiar text of science as an objective discourse of facts intent on advancing the public good. Through carefully selected case-texts of nested topics on the body that range from how disease is portrayed in school textbooks to resistance to objectification by human participants in science experiments, this book reveals how science is entangled in colonial, national, financial, and racist interests. Discovering what is represented and absent in the texts of science in schools, media, and science publications, Weinstein successfully models the pedagogy he advocates by colliding such received texts of science with re-readings from experience, zines, and the deep questioning of social-cultural studies of science. 'Bodies Out of Control' is a brilliant and welcome text of civic engagement important for realizing a science education pedagogy that critically explores the complexity and humanness of the body of texts received in schools and in the media as science.>> (David Blades, Professor of Science Education and Curriculum Studies, University of Victoria, Canada)