Violence and Order on the Chengdu Plain

Reviews / Votes

"Di Wang's rich volume on the Sichuan Paoge offers a major contribution to the history of Chinese secret societies. Based in part on the fascinating thesis of a sociology student at Yenching University, the study brilliantly illuminates the complex linkages between rural society and culture, the limits of local government, and Western-inspired intellectual efforts to arrive at a new understanding of peasant life."-David Ownby, author of Brotherhoods and Secret Societies in Early and Mid-Qing China "Violence and Order on the Chengdu Plain is the first monograph in English that is solely dedicated to the study of paoge, one of the most influential secret societies in the upper- and middle-Yangzi regions in pre-1949 China. An elegant microhistory, this work weaves an intimate study with larger social and political contexts involving rebellions, revolutions, foreign invasion, state penetration, and peasant resistance that characterized twentieth-century China."-Huaiyin Li, University of Texas at Austin "Without doubt, Di Wang's new book represents an excellent example of a microhistory writing in the field of modern Chinese history."-Shaofan An, Frontiers of History in China "Every once in a blue moon, this reviewer finishes a book and thinks: 'Now this is the kind of book I aspire to write.' Di Wang's Violence and Order on the Chengdu Plain is one of those rare books....Full of pathos and interwoven with complex narratives, Violence and Order is rich in anthropological and sociological data collected in the 1930s and 1940s, and complete with entertaining and humanizing historical anecdotes."-Kelly Hammond, China Review International "Violence and Order on the Chengdu Plain is an illuminating study of how secret societies operated in early twentieth-century Sichuan and how they have been understood....[The book] adds to the recent flourishing of studies of Sichuan in the Republican period."-Henrietta Harrison, Journal of Asian Studies "Violence and Order on the Chengdu Plain is a far-reaching contribution to scholarship on secret societies, local governance, popular culture, and rural society in the first half of China's twentieth century that deserves to be widely read, by both specialists and nonspecialists alike."-Benno R. Weiner, Twentieth-Century China "Wang has made an impressive contribution to our understanding of Chinese secret societies, specifically the Paoge....this book is highly readable and is a welcome addition to the historiography of modern China."-Hongyan Xiang, Pacific Affairs "Violence and Order on the Chengdu Plain: The Story of a Secret Brotherhood in Rural China, 1939-1949 is a thought-provoking and insightful book that will be of interest to anyone interested in Chinese history, as well as those interested in the dynamics of power and violence in general. Di Wang's narrative and attention to Shen Baoyuan and Lei Mingyuan, who lived in two completely different worlds and had wildly different socioeconomic and education backgrounds in 1945, make this book an engaging and informative read, and his nuanced approach to the topic of violence provides important insights into the complexities of human experiences, family crisis, and devastated women's fate in rural China. It is a valuable contribution to the field of history of Chinese family and rural society."-Wei Chin Wong, Asian Journal of Criminology