Outsourcing US Intelligence

Reviews / Votes

The book's strengths are in its willingness to sort through the utter minutiae of both existing and failed legislation. For this, Van Puyvelde should be lauded for doing truly onerous labor. Van Puyvelde painstakingly demonstrates that Congress is not only sensitive to concerns about intelligence outsourcing, but that there are numerous examples of legislation, passed and failed, that reveal a continual evolution of the relationship between contractors and the government. Van Puyvelde makes clear that while the relationship is not perfect, it is far from out of the norm and is increasingly regulated in the state's interests.[...] Ultimately what Van Puyvelde manages to do is to write broadly into an academic lacuna that links intelligence outsourcing with accountability. Van Puyvelde's book works most effectively as a primer for graduate students seeking an introduction to intelligence and a nuanced counterargument against bombastic claims about intelligence out of control through the private marketplace. -- Nina A. Kollars, Naval War College * H-net, January 2020 * The book's strengths are in its willingness to sort through the utter minutiae of both existing and failed legislation. For this, Van Puyvelde should be lauded for doing truly onerous labor. Van Puyvelde painstakingly demonstrates that Congress is not only sensitive to concerns about intelligence outsourcing, but that there are numerous examples of legislation, passed and failed, that reveal a continual evolution of the relationship between contractors and the government. Van Puyvelde makes clear that while the relationship is not perfect, it is far from out of the norm and is increasingly regulated in the state's interests.[...] Ultimately what Van Puyvelde manages to do is to write broadly into an academic lacuna that links intelligence outsourcing with accountability. Van Puyvelde's book works most effectively as a primer for graduate students seeking an introduction to intelligence and a nuanced counterargument against bombastic claims about intelligence out of control through the private marketplace. -- Nina A. Kollars, Naval War College * H-net, January 2020 * The role of outside contractors in government intelligence activities has been controversial. In the face of impediments to research, this book provides a wealth of insight into the challenges of accountability when democracies outsource their intelligence responsibilities. * Loch Johnson, University of Georgia * This is an important and timely book because it broadens Intelligence Studies' traditional concentration on state intelligence agencies and their oversight (or lack thereof) by examining the position of private contractors in US intelligence governance. There was little concern until post-9/11 scandals erupted around the abuse of detainees at Abu Ghraib in Iraq and raised the question of whether government officials can uphold the public interest in national security when intelligence is outsourced. Conceptually, the author draws on the principal-agent model to develop his analytical framework of the accountability process. [...] This is an important book establishing the groundwork for future research and scholarship in this critical public-private area of Intelligence Studies. -- Peter Gill, University of Leicester * The International Journal of Intelligence, Security, and Public Affairs, 2019 * Privatization can be for the public good, even in the realm of national security. That is the hypothesis that this accomplished and profoundly significant volume sets out to test, and the author's insights are crystal clear. -- Rhodri Jeffreys-Jones, author of We Know All About You: The Story of Surveillance in Britain and America