The Burning Forest

Reviews / Votes

A very important and interesting book which should be widely read. A deeply disturbing analysis of the sacrifice of tribal lives and communities caught between the camouflaged barbarity of the security forces and the violent arrogance of a deflected rebellion. The appeal for reasoned humanity cannot be any stronger - or more eloquent - than this. -- Amartya Sen Nandini Sundar, an extraordinary anthropologist-activist, has mined twenty-five years of experience in the region to write an account of Bastar's civil war that is both gripping and harrowing. She pulls no punches in describing the greed and cynical violence of state agencies, mining companies, politicians and immigrants. Her account of life in the Maoist rebel zones is graphic, full of empathy but by no means uncritical. is is a story that everyone who cares about India must read. -- Partha Chatterjee Every thinking Indian, every citizen who is concerned about the present and future of the Republic, should read The Burning Forest. It is an impeccably researched and finely written work of scholarship, redolent with insight, and displaying enormous courage as well. -- Ramachandra Guha * Hindustan Times * If many places are like Bastar, few books are like The Burning Forest. It resonates with classics on frontiers and dispossession. -- Christian Lund * Journal of Agrarian Change * Sundar's book is an exceptional expose of the scandal of rural governance in India, a chronicle of State excesses, an anthropologist's view about how conflicts perpetuate themselves and an account of how India's democracy is degraded when few are watching. Policymakers ought to take away one the key lesson from it that there really are no military solutions to social conflicts. -- Sushil Aaron * Hindustan Times * Sundar's book is a must-read for those interested in the genesis and the nature of conflict in Bastar * The Hindu * The work needs to be celebrated for its scholarship, for its independence and for its courage. * The Tribune * Will keep you sleepless over several nights. * The Indian Express * Among the most important works on the conflict in southern Chhattisgarh. * India Today * One of the most rounded accounts of the strife in Bastar. * Telegraph * Sundar asks for no glossing over of any kind. A thorough, diligent and finally credible effort. -- Dilip D' Souza * The Caravan * A razor sharp critique of the institutions that make India feel good about itself - its parliamentary democracy, its judiciary, its free press, its vibrant civil society. * The Wire * A balanced and incisive narrative of the ground reality in Chhattisgarh. * Force Magazine * There are so many good reasons to read Ms Sundar's book, even if you disagree with her views. But, there is no way you can read it and not feel harrowed by the war India has unleashed against its own people in Bastar and what it implies for us as a functioning democracy. -- Nitin Sethi * The Business Standard * A timely and pro-adivasi book written with utmost honesty and a deep sense of empathy. * Open Magazine * A compelling account of the real-politik of 'democratic nation building'. -- Harsh Sethi * Seminar * The message of this monumental social science inquiry is loud and clear-citizens have to assert their rights to get justice from the Indian state. -- CP Bhambri * Contributions to Indian Sociology * How does democracy affect the prosecution of civil war? Nandini Sundar explores this question with untold courage and fierce determination in her remarkable extended ethnography of counter-insurgency in Chhattisgarh (India) - a desperate struggle to clear the land for mineral exploitation. Starting from poor adivasi villagers, aided and abetted by Naxalites, Sundar lays out in dispassionate detail the history of escalating violence, spurred on by the atrocities of a state-sponsored vigilante group and special police force. Stung by the lack of interest in the Indian media and parliament, she and two collaborators pursued and finally won a Supreme Court case against the state of Chhattisgarh. But, again, with no obvious effect. By multiplying opportunities to contest state violence, democratic institutions may have moderated but also extended the civil war. A rare and brilliant treatment of a topic few social scientists would dare to touch, let alone examine at such close quarters and for over two decades. -- Michael Burawoy The Burning Forest is vivid, challenging and informative-an exemplar of engaged sociology and anthropology. It is a stellar account of the tension between villagers, insurgents and the multiple levels of state action and inaction, the intricate complications of the legal system and of course, the politics of it all. Nandini Sundar's empathy for the people of the forest and their struggles for a dignified life and livelihood is heart-warming. -- Ari Sitas This meticulous and powerful book not only documents a brutal regime of internal colonialism in the world's largest democracy. It reveals the insidious ways in which consent to state oppression is manufactured and amplified. Everyone interested in the commingled fate of democracy and capitalism in the postcolonial world should read this book. -- Pankaj Mishra, author of <i>Age of Anger</i>