The Broken Years

Reviews / Votes

'A heart-breaking study of forgotten fighters for Russia in the early twentieth century and a tribute to the vibrant activism of medical experts, social organizers, state officials, and wounded veterans. Their efforts created rights for the disabled, even as soldiers' sacrifices in world war one dropped out of Soviet sight.' Jane Burbank, New York University 'Meticulously researched, eloquent and moving, Alexandre Sumpf's important book brings disabled veterans, their sufferings, their emerging rights, previously overlooked or misunderstood, back to their proper place, at the heart of Russia's war experience in the early twentieth century.' Bruno Cabanes, The Ohio State University 'Sumpf shows how Russia's disabled veterans of the Great War found a voice, culminating in the Revolution, but were ignored by the Bolsheviks. He puts their experience of war and disability into its international context while exploring the relationship between Russia's Great War and Revolution. A moving and important study.' John Horne, Trinity College Dublin 'The Broken Years brilliantly excavates the lost voices of Russia's disabled veterans, long suppressed by both Tsarist and Bolshevik policymakers. Sumpf persuasively argues that disabled veterans of the First World War fought to amplify their voices as citizens through organizations such as the Union of Maimed Soldiers, but that the early Soviet state discriminated against them, crushed their movement, and relegated them to poverty.' Karen Petrone, University of Kentucky 'Sumpf's study brings together a large body of material from Russian archives that would be inaccessible to most scholars due to language barriers as well as politics. This is one of the great contributions of his work ... This book is also valuable as part of a comparative study on how nations interact with wounded soldiers.' John Casey, H-Disability 'The monograph will ... hold considerable value for students of European history interested in the comparative experiences of war, disability, and veterans' reintegration into postwar life. ... Highly recommended.' S. G. Jug, Choice 'The Broken Years is an important book and a fascinating read for scholars of revolutionary Russia. Sumpf convincingly demonstrates that disabled veterans were a distinctive social group whose common struggle for recognition of their sacrifice offers fresh insight into the political and social history of revolutionary Russia. Sumpf's meticulous efforts to move Russia's disabled veterans to their rightful place in the broader international history of war and its aftermath will undoubtedly inspire future studies.' Siobhan Hearne, H/Soz/Kult 'Alexandre Sumpf's outstanding study of disabled veterans in the Russian Empire across three early twentieth century wars offers a fresh look at the soldier in Russian and Soviet history. ... The Broken Years is a masterful achievement and should find wide readership among those interested in military history, late Tsarist social history, and disability history. It will serve as a definitive study for years to come while also providing avenues for further research on veteran assistance, disability, and the push-pull between dominant and marginalized populations in Russia.' Erica L. Fraser, The Russian Review 'Sumpf has written a meticulous and moving study of disabled veterans that makes important interventions in a woefully understudied area ... This book is therefore long overdue. Its great contribution is to make clear that disabled veterans were central to a whole host of major developments in the revolutionary period, from ideas of rights and charity to the rise of modern medicine, the welfare state and civil society.' Thomas C. Stevens, Revolutionary Russia 'The book ... is based on a dizzying array of sources. ... The writing, informed by a melancholy appropriate to the topic, is beautiful and often evocative. ... this path-breaking study ... is highly recommended for every serious student of Russian and Soviet history as well as the history of veterans and of disability more globally.' Mark Edele, Slavonic and East European Review