Captivity

Reviews / Votes

"Monumental.... The level of detail is stunning; Mr. Spiro seems to know absolutely everything about the first-century Mediterranean world and revels in Herodotean digressions.... Mr. Spiro's encyclopedic tendencies do not hobble "Captivity," which never loses steam. In Tim Wilkinson's forceful translation, we are transported to a world of political corruption and messianic hopes. Uri, whose maturation gives the story its psychological heft, exemplifies the enigmas and tensions of Diaspora Jewry across history. Readers will find particularly strong resonance in the scenes of the Alexandria riots of A.D. 38, pointedly depicted as the first pogrom in history. "Horrors are on the way," Uri predicts. "Alexandria is a model: it will become fashionable wherever a significant Jewish minority is living, be it in Africa or Asia, anywhere, it is going to be expedited in just the same way."... Mr. Spiro has been a celebrated figure in Hungarian letters since the 1970s, but the remarkable "Captivity" (from 2005) is the first of his novels to be translated into English. You can read it as a parable of the Jewish condition amid the modern empires of Europe, or you can simply lose yourself in the ancient setting it so comprehensively describes."

-Sam Sacks, The Wall Street Journal, Best Books of 2015 "With the novel Captivity, Spiro proves that he is well-versed in both historical and human knowledge. It appears that in our times, it is playfulness that is expected of literary works, rather than the portrayal of realistic questions and conflicts. As if the two, playfulness and seriousness were inconsistent with each other! On the contrary (at least for me) playfulness begins with seriousness. Literature is a serious game. So is Spiro's novel.?"

-Imre Kertesz, Nobel Prize-winning author of Fatelessness "'BEN HUR,' BUT BIGGER AND BETTER. Hungarian writer Gyoergy Spiro's newly translated novel Captivity powerfully sets the perils of modern Jewry in Early Christian Rome.... Captivity [is] a sprawling (more than 800 pages), picturesque, old-fashioned historical novel about the Roman Empire, in the showy tradition of Ben Hur and I, Claudius. In fact, both Jesus and Claudius, the main characters of those books, make cameo appearances in Captivity, as do other boldface names of the 1st century CE, including Caligula, Pontius Pilate, and Philo of Alexandria. What sets Captivity apart is that it makes the rare attempt to view all these historical phenomena-from the rise of Christianity to the flamboyant vices of the emperors-through a distinctively Jewish lens.... Where Spiro excels is dramatizing the world through which Uri moves-its political institutions and social arrangements, its sights and smells. In just the first section of the book, set in Rome, we are treated to gladiatorial combat, a client's morning visit to his patron, and a brutal public execution. These archetypal scenes of Roman life shock us into realizing the ways in which the ancient world differed from our own-the extreme brutality, the fixed and undisguised hierarchy, the omnipresent corruption.... a complex and thoughtful portrait of what Judaism meant in ancient Rome.... Captivity draws you in with its pageant of the classical world, but by the end it also turns out to be a profound meditation on what Judaism meant, and means."

-Adam Kirsch, Tablet "This remarkable novel, recently translated from the Hungarian, is as close as we are likely to get to a real feel for how it was to live in the first century CE.... Spiro's artistic agility shines in his recreation of the world through which Uri moves.... Spiro has absorbed an awesome amount of information to create his ancient tableaux. He demonstrates a mastery of everything from the silk trade to the workings of ancient economies.... The strength of the book is in its unheroic, unillusioned depiction of ancient life.... if you are curious about the ancient world, if you wish to get a 'finger-feel' for what it was like to live there, and to think about the forces that shaped the rise of Christianity, Captivity is well worth your time. Here is a faithful, fantastically informed, and extravagantly detailed picture of one of the most turbulent and consequential moments in human history."

-Rabbi David Wolpe, Los Angeles Review of Books "Uri, the hero of Spiro's enormous novel, is a Jewish Candide, although the scope of his exploits suggests more of a naive Don Quixote type.... Deliberate, evocative and richly detailed. Spiro's elaborate style reflects Uri's acute observation, with the hint of a wink at the reader.... Spiro, a Hungarian man of letters, juxtaposes the prosaic and the significant with aplomb and offers a cheeky, unique view of history through the eyes of his modest everyman. A thoroughly impressive literary feat."

-Publishers Weekly, Starred Review "A visceral new form of epic history. Here mountains of trivia form vivid landscapes and academic minutiae open windows into the soul of a forgotten age. It is a work of fiction, though, and it is hilarious.... Spiro's serious accomplishment is to challenge the chilling observation, popularly attributed to Stalin, that "one death is a tragedy and one million deaths a statistic" by breathing life into the neglected statistics of a magnificent-and terrifying, brutal-age.... An intently philosophical book.... Captivity expresses historical ideas authentically.... As an award-winning author, Spiro displays predictable creativity, but the real power of Captivity is the ability the extensive historical detail lends the reader to inhabit and empathize with ancient life. It is difficult to imagine a more entertaining way to realize so much data, and it is wonderful that Spiro has managed such an accomplishment. His technique is a welcome innovation for historical fiction in general, and perhaps the drollest scholarly introduction to the first century yet."

-Jack Hatchett, Jewish Book Council "Brilliant, picaresque novel of Jewish life in the first century, a bestseller and prizewinner in Spiro's native Hungary.... There are two great impulses at work in Spiro's yarn, the first being a comprehensive sociology of Roman Jewry, the second a grand, seriocomic novel of ideas. Uri, overcoming obstacles and a flaw of birth, makes for a Joseph Campbell-worthy epic hero ... there's a lot packed into these pages, including an engagingly complicated portrait of Roman-Jewish relations in the early empire ('We loathe, absolutely loathe your kind, but not to the extent that we too will perish'), a rambunctious tour of ancient philosophies (including a hilarious semi-Mishnaic defense of prostitution), and no end of plain, good shaggy dog humor. A winning and thoughtful entertainment, somewhere between Lives of the Caesars and The Tin Drum."

-Kirkus Reviews "[One of] the fifty best independent press books of 2015.... There is no shortage of Hungarian masters writing enormous novels - Krasznahorkai and Nadas immediately come to mind - but Spiro's epic road novel stands on its own. A picaresque that doubles as a kind of Jewish history, it's remarkably still a page-turner."

-Jonathon Sturgeon, Flavorwire "Gyoergy Spiro presents a theory in novelistic form about the interwovenness of religion and politics, lays bare the inner workings of power, and gives insight into the art of survival.... This book is an incredible page turner; it reads easily and avidly like the greatest bestsellers while also going as deep as the greatest thinkers of European philosophy."

-Aegon Literary Award 2006 jury recommendation "Thorough, fascinating, and rarely flags.... Captivity is a very long novel (of about 350,000 words), but pacing it as he does Spiro quite easily holds the reader's attention through to the (surprisingly bitter) end.... In this remarkably thorough and detailed novel Spiro also manages to present a great deal of substantive historical and cultural information-adroitly too: it rarely feels like simple information-dumping, as instead he weaves even obscure details about (especially Jewish) life in those times into the narrative in a way that doesn't feel forced.... [Uri is] an impressively convincing character, whose path through these tumultuous times Spiro chronicles thoroughly engagingly. There's lots of knowingness here, yet even in the casual treatment of, for example, Christianity, it's almost never heavy-handed. The historic events are also very well-handled-in particular the frenzies that bubble up and then subside, and how life is at one moment on razor's edge, and then returns (at least for the survivors) to almost everyday banality. Captivity is a superior, well-researched historical novel, but history aside it's also simply a very good story, with a compelling protagonist."

-M.A.Orthofer, The Complete Review "Gyoergy Spiro's extensive research renders Captivity a powerful time machine, but his strategies shape a historiographic metafiction that highlights the links between that world and our own.... Beyond bringing to vivid life a decisive human era, Captivity offers a meditation on man's fate in an absurd world."

-Michele Levy, World Literature Today "Like the authors of so many great novels, Gyoergy Spiro sends his hero, Uri, out into the wide world. Uri is a Roman Jew born into a poor family, and the wide world is an overripe civilization-the Roman Empire. Captivity can be read as an adventure novel, a Bildungsroman, a richly detailed portrait of an era, and a historico-philosophical parable. The long series of adventures-in which it is only a tiny episode that Uri is imprisoned together with Jesus and the two thieves-suggest at once the vanity of human endeavors and a passion for life. A masterpiece."

-Laszlo Marton "Intensively researched.... The book's major strengths are its vast scope and its depictions of the nitty-gritty of daily life.... Spiro weaves a tremendous amount of research into his dense fiction. The payoff is a deep immersion for the reader.... I never wanted to put the book aside.... Spiro is wonderful at depicting the flowing, overlapping nature of religious and other traditions two thousand years ago. To read his book is to gain a deep perspective into human nature and the roots of much of today's Western civilization. Passionate and academic, overflowing with detail, thoroughly engrossing, it's a powerful, important work. Tim Wilkinson, a past PEN/Book of the Month Club Translation Prize winner, has done a great service to modern literature by tackling this behemoth of a novel."

-Jon Sobel, Blogcritics