Making Borders in Modern East Asia

Reviews / Votes

'The author deftly presents a convoluted tale of frontier settlement on the Sino-Korean border, where Chinese, Korean, Russian, and Japanese states and activists contended for influence. This skillful multilingual study told from multiple perspectives is a model for new imperial histories of Asia.' Peter C. Perdue, Yale University, Connecticut 'A precise and often beautifully written analysis. Through deep engagement with multiple archives Nianshen Song reveals how competing political and economic forces vied for control over the Tumen River's place in modern East Asia. The study, moreover, urges the need for connection - not division - in the areas of China, Russia, and North Korea that surround this river's course.' Alexis Dudden, University of Connecticut 'This is a truly groundbreaking book in both theoretical and empirical senses. Extensive multi-archival and multilingual research provides original, provocative, yet still accessible perspectives on such complicated issues as border-making, nation-building, and identity-searching in modern East Asia in general and the 'local space' of the Chinese-Korean frontiers in particular. A historical study of the very best.' Chen Jian, New York University. Shanghai and Cornell University, New York 'How did a remote frontier in North East Asia become a source of friction and hostility between China, Korea, and Japan for the first half of the twentieth century? In this fascinating local history, Nianshen Song shows how China and Korea - two adjacent, centralized states with a centuries long history of frontier relations - re-negotiated the modern meanings of place and citizenship under the shadow of an imperialist Japan, eager to use the ambiguities of territorial meanings for its own purposes. Using a multi-lingual, multi-national archive, Song recounts the topsy-turvy changes marking China's conversion from a multi-ethnic empire to a nation-state in which Koreans become newly defined as national minorities. This is transnational history that captures both the excitement and tragedies of early twentieth-century East Asian history while offering a rigorous analysis of the shifting spatial conceptions of nation-states. In Song's adept hands, a small corner of Manchuria reveals itself as at the core of the intellectual, political, economic, and social struggles of East Asia's global modernity.' Andre Schmid, University of Toronto '... this is an extraordinary book, a real tonic to assertions that what is fixed is fixed and what is settled is settled in bordering and nation state construction, the reviewer challenges the reader not to become engrossed in every twist and turn of its extremely articulate pages.' Robert Winstanley-Chesters, European Journal of Korean Studies 'Making Borders in Modern East Asia will become a core text for the study of East Asia at all levels, a frequently cited work for Chinese-Korean relations as well as an essential reference for scholars interested in comparative histories of frontiers and borderlands. It is likely to set precedents for future research about other critical borders formed by waterways and between multiple states.' Loretta E. Kim, Inner Asia 'All in all, Song stresses that 'boundaries for both territories and people are relative rather than absolute, flexible rather than rigid'. His meticulous analysis richly elucidates this 'polyphonic' nature of boundary making.' Masato Hasegawa, Saksaha