
The World and God Are not-Two
A Hindu-Christian Conversation
Daniel Soars(Author)
Fordham University Press
Published on 25. April 2023
Book
Hardback
256 pages
978-1-5315-0204-1 (ISBN)
Description
The World and God Are Not-Two is a book about how the God in whom Christians believe ought to be understood. The key conceptual argument that runs throughout is that the distinctive relation between the world and God in Christian theology is best understood as a non-dualistic one. The "two"-"God" and "World" cannot be added up as separate, enumerable realities or contrasted with each other against some common background because God does not belong in any category and creatures are ontologically constituted by their relation to the Creator.
In exploring the unique character of this distinctive relation, Soars turns to Sara Grant's work on the Hindu tradition of Advaita Vedanta and the metaphysics of creation found in Thomas Aquinas. He develops Grant's work and that of the earlier Calcutta School by drawing explicit attention to the Neoplatonic themes in Aquinas that provide some of the most fruitful areas for comparative engagement with Vedanta. To the Christian, the fact that the world exists only as dependent on God means that "world" and "God" must be ontologically distinct because God's existence does not depend on the world. To the Advaitin, this simultaneously means that "World" and "God" cannot be ontologically separate either. The language of non-duality allows us to see that both positions can be held coherently together without entailing any contradiction or disagreement at the level of fundamental ontology. What it means to be "world" does not and cannot exclude what it means to be "God."
In exploring the unique character of this distinctive relation, Soars turns to Sara Grant's work on the Hindu tradition of Advaita Vedanta and the metaphysics of creation found in Thomas Aquinas. He develops Grant's work and that of the earlier Calcutta School by drawing explicit attention to the Neoplatonic themes in Aquinas that provide some of the most fruitful areas for comparative engagement with Vedanta. To the Christian, the fact that the world exists only as dependent on God means that "world" and "God" must be ontologically distinct because God's existence does not depend on the world. To the Advaitin, this simultaneously means that "World" and "God" cannot be ontologically separate either. The language of non-duality allows us to see that both positions can be held coherently together without entailing any contradiction or disagreement at the level of fundamental ontology. What it means to be "world" does not and cannot exclude what it means to be "God."
More details
Series
Edition
New edition
Language
English
Place of publication
New York
United States
Target group
Professional and scholarly
Edition type
New edition
Product notice
Cloth over boards
Dimensions
Height: 229 mm
Width: 152 mm
Thickness: 18 mm
Weight
508 gr
ISBN-13
978-1-5315-0204-1 (9781531502041)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Other editions
Additional editions

E-Book
04/2023
Fordham University Press
€39.49
Available for download
Person
Daniel Soars teaches in the Divinity Department at Eton College and is book reviews editor for the Journal of Hindu-Christian Studies.
Content
List of Abbreviations and Conventions ix
Introduction 1
1 The Distinctive Relation between Creature and Creator in Christian Theology:
Non-dualism from David Burrell, CSC, to Sara Grant, RSCJ 17
2 Roman Catholic Encounters with Advaita Vedanta:
Between Transcendental Illusion and Radical Contingency 40
3 The Relation between the World and God in Sa?kara and Thomas:
Sara Grant's Case for a Form of Christian Non-dualism 69
4 Creation: "Ex Nihilo" or "Ex Deo"? 97
5 How Real Is the World? Being and Nothingness in Sa?kara and Thomas 129
Conclusion 161
Acknowledgments 173
Notes 177
Bibliography 221
Index 231
Introduction 1
1 The Distinctive Relation between Creature and Creator in Christian Theology:
Non-dualism from David Burrell, CSC, to Sara Grant, RSCJ 17
2 Roman Catholic Encounters with Advaita Vedanta:
Between Transcendental Illusion and Radical Contingency 40
3 The Relation between the World and God in Sa?kara and Thomas:
Sara Grant's Case for a Form of Christian Non-dualism 69
4 Creation: "Ex Nihilo" or "Ex Deo"? 97
5 How Real Is the World? Being and Nothingness in Sa?kara and Thomas 129
Conclusion 161
Acknowledgments 173
Notes 177
Bibliography 221
Index 231