Multicultiphobia
Will be published approx. on 8. May 2010
Book
Hardback
279 pages
978-1-4426-4146-4 (ISBN)
Description
Official multiculturalism, established as Canadian government policy in 1971, has drawn criticism from many scholars and journalists who view it as a potential threat to a strong, unified Canadian society. In this timely and original book, Phil Ryan examines the emergence and influence of these criticisms, which continue to provoke an anxiety he calls "multicultiphobia." Although Ryan argues that multicultiphobic discourse is often marred by important errors of fact and interpretation, a systematic inspection of news coverage and parliamentary debates reveals the persistent influence of these critiques and their underlying concerns.
Rather than simply dismissing multicultiphobia, Ryan acknowledges that critics of multiculturalism have identified issues about which Canadians need to talk. Does multiculturalism discourage adaptation and encourage 'cultural walls' between Canadians? Does it promote an 'anything goes' relativism? Finally, what do we - both as supporters and critics of multiculturalism - wish to make of Canada's ethnic diversity? Multicultiphobia perceptively tackles all of these questions by means of a sophisticated analysis that encourages a deeper understanding of the issues at the heart of multiculturalism.
Rather than simply dismissing multicultiphobia, Ryan acknowledges that critics of multiculturalism have identified issues about which Canadians need to talk. Does multiculturalism discourage adaptation and encourage 'cultural walls' between Canadians? Does it promote an 'anything goes' relativism? Finally, what do we - both as supporters and critics of multiculturalism - wish to make of Canada's ethnic diversity? Multicultiphobia perceptively tackles all of these questions by means of a sophisticated analysis that encourages a deeper understanding of the issues at the heart of multiculturalism.
Reviews / Votes
'Ryan's book will be of interest to a variety of readers, from political scientists and philosophers to policy-makers and the general public.' - Chris Durante (Journal of Religion and Culture, vol 23:2012)More details
Language
English
Place of publication
Toronto
Canada
Target group
College/higher education
Professional and scholarly
Product notice
sewn/stitched
Paper over boards
Dimensions
Height: 229 mm
Width: 152 mm
Thickness: 25 mm
Weight
567 gr
ISBN-13
978-1-4426-4146-4 (9781442641464)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Person
Phil Ryan is an associate professor in the School of Public Policy and Administration at Carleton University.
Content
Table of contents
Introduction
Multiculturalism 4
Culture 10
Plan of this work 22
Why this approach? 27
PART I: Fin-de-siecle critiques of multiculturalism32
Chapter One: Classics of multicultiphobia32
Bibby's Mosaic madness32
Bissoondath's Selling illusions35
Gwyn's Nationalism without walls39
Granatstein's Who killed Canadian history? 45
A Summary of the "Classics"47
Chapter Two: Multicultiphobia: A closer look 52
The primitive ontology of multicultiphobia52
Frozen and monolithic multiculturalism 59
Causality in the classics 65
The lure of the fairy-tale 69
Multicultiphobia and the scourge of political correctness 77
Chapter Three: Multiculturalism in Parliament, 1994-95 82
Bloc Quebecois critiques of multiculturalism 83
Reform Party critiques 85 The Liberal response 97
The quality of the Parliamentary debate 103
Chapter Four: Multiculturalism in the News (1995) 108
Methodology 109 Thematic analysis 111
Conclusion 128
PART II: Multiculturalism after 911 129
Chapter 5: Multiculturalism, immigration, security 129
Stoffman and Canadian immigration policy 130
Collacott and the terrorist threat 134
Conclusion 137
Chapter 6: Parliament 2005-06: The ambiguous triumph of multiculturalism 139
Chapter 7: Multiculturalism in the News (2006) 148
Echoes of the "classics"148
Echoes of 1995 themes152
Paper-by-paper analysis154
Conclusion168
PART III: What do we need to talk about? 169
Chapter 8: Multiculturalism and relativism 169
The problem of relativism170
Relativism 1173
Relativism 2180
Relativism 3184
Conclusion193
Chapter 9: Multiculturalism and society's basic needs 195
Values, or guns and jails? 198
What society do we want?209
What does this society need?210
Conclusion216
Chapter 10: How are we doing? 218
Multiculturalism and the welfare state219
Social cohesion221
Social interaction224
Conclusion232
Chapter 11: Sauce for the goose...? 235
Double standards...?236
... What double standards?237
The solidarity principle241
Religious regulation246
Concluding thought251
PART IV: Update and Conclusion 252
Chapter 12: Immortal Multicultiphobia? 252
Recent multicultiphobia252
The Kenney factor254
A Personal Conclusion263
How do we need to talk?264
What do we want multiculturalism to be?273
Works Cited281
Notes336
Introduction
Multiculturalism 4
Culture 10
Plan of this work 22
Why this approach? 27
PART I: Fin-de-siecle critiques of multiculturalism32
Chapter One: Classics of multicultiphobia32
Bibby's Mosaic madness32
Bissoondath's Selling illusions35
Gwyn's Nationalism without walls39
Granatstein's Who killed Canadian history? 45
A Summary of the "Classics"47
Chapter Two: Multicultiphobia: A closer look 52
The primitive ontology of multicultiphobia52
Frozen and monolithic multiculturalism 59
Causality in the classics 65
The lure of the fairy-tale 69
Multicultiphobia and the scourge of political correctness 77
Chapter Three: Multiculturalism in Parliament, 1994-95 82
Bloc Quebecois critiques of multiculturalism 83
Reform Party critiques 85 The Liberal response 97
The quality of the Parliamentary debate 103
Chapter Four: Multiculturalism in the News (1995) 108
Methodology 109 Thematic analysis 111
Conclusion 128
PART II: Multiculturalism after 911 129
Chapter 5: Multiculturalism, immigration, security 129
Stoffman and Canadian immigration policy 130
Collacott and the terrorist threat 134
Conclusion 137
Chapter 6: Parliament 2005-06: The ambiguous triumph of multiculturalism 139
Chapter 7: Multiculturalism in the News (2006) 148
Echoes of the "classics"148
Echoes of 1995 themes152
Paper-by-paper analysis154
Conclusion168
PART III: What do we need to talk about? 169
Chapter 8: Multiculturalism and relativism 169
The problem of relativism170
Relativism 1173
Relativism 2180
Relativism 3184
Conclusion193
Chapter 9: Multiculturalism and society's basic needs 195
Values, or guns and jails? 198
What society do we want?209
What does this society need?210
Conclusion216
Chapter 10: How are we doing? 218
Multiculturalism and the welfare state219
Social cohesion221
Social interaction224
Conclusion232
Chapter 11: Sauce for the goose...? 235
Double standards...?236
... What double standards?237
The solidarity principle241
Religious regulation246
Concluding thought251
PART IV: Update and Conclusion 252
Chapter 12: Immortal Multicultiphobia? 252
Recent multicultiphobia252
The Kenney factor254
A Personal Conclusion263
How do we need to talk?264
What do we want multiculturalism to be?273
Works Cited281
Notes336