Fair and Effective Representation?

Reviews / Votes

Given the breadth and clear level of scholarship exhibited in the writing of the book, it should be one of the first reading assignments for students studying representation, redistricting, minority politics, voting rights, political behavior, elections,and political thought. In addition, this text should be required reading for every state legislator, member of Congress, employee of the Attorney General's Office, and anyone seeking knowledge of the U.S. political systemmmm The American Review Of Politics The Rush-Engstrom offering is a valuable contribution to the literature on minority voting rights... Public officials, advocacy groups, and citizens alike should read this book as the post-2000 reapportionment process unfolds. It provides resources to evaluate past trends, contemporary procedures, and future possibilities. The Law and Politics Book Review Useful for general collections and undergraduate collections. CHOICE For those interested in, and especially those teaching, current issues in US politics this will be a useful book. The Journal Of Legislative Studies In the United States we elect most of our representatives in winner-take-all elections in which the candidate with the most votes wins. Thus, in legislative elections, a party whose candidates get a bare plurality-less than half of the vote-could end up winning all the seats. In contrast, most other democracies in the world use election methods in which the overall seats shares of each party are guaranteed to be roughly proportional to the aggregate votes that each party's candidates get. Rush and Engstrom debate the merits of winner-take-all and proportional elections in a balanced, reasoned and comprehensive fashion. Those who read this book will have learned a lot about electoral system reform and will be in a position to intelligently judge the major alternatives for themselves. -- Bernard Grofman, University of California, Irvine Given the breadth and clear level of scholarship exhibited in the writing of the book, it should be one of the first reading assignments for students studying representation, redistricting, minority politics, voting rights, political behavior, elections, and political thought. In addition, this text should be required reading for every state legislator, member of Congress, employee of the Attorney General's Office, and anyone seeking knowledge of the U.S. political system The American Review Of Politics