Communal Luxury

Reviews / Votes

No work specifies more fully Marx's claim that, the greatest achievement of the Paris Commune was its 'actual working existence.' * Jacobin * In recent years, the Paris Commune has again moved to the center of political thinking. Kristin Ross's new book now, virtually for the first time, gives us an account of the intellectual antecedents of the Commune as well as its contemporary impact. This is an indispensable text for all current left theory! -- Fredric Jameson Although this is a book of ideas, it is neither dry nor overburdened by scholarly references. Ross's vision of the Commune extends beyond the 72 days, and beyond the space of Paris (and indeed of France), to encompass its echoes throughout the rest of the 19th century . For Ross, the story of the Commune is not a tragedy, because it is not finished. * Financial Times * Ross is the perfect guide for such a journey: few critics are more attuned to how words and images can travel . [She] has an acute eye for this juxtaposition of the pastoral and the political, how the vines of nature can overtake the monuments of empire, how revolutionary events can interrupt the silence of the countryside. -- Corey Robin * Salon * Communal Luxury is a rich and complex book. It is an inspired rereading of the Paris Commune. It is a critique of historical accounts that ignore the ways in which the practices of insurrectionary movements generate their own theory. It is a call to historians to attend to the alternatives offered at decisive moments of political and economic consolidation. It is, as well, Ross's own manifesto about how we might think our futures differently. This is a history with enormous relevance for our contemporary political moment. -- Joan W. Scott, Institute For Advanced Study, Princeton Kristin Ross argues that the spirit of the Commune is alive today among . the Indignados in Spain and inside the Occupy movement. Ross discusses the 'political imaginary' that fuelled and outlived the Commune. -- Philippe Marliere * London Review of Books * A timely, elegant and rather useful cartography of the Paris Commune . This small book is a sort of parable, about another time and place, but not really about the past as past. It is more about the possibility of other kinds of action in time, as indeed are most parables. -- McKenzie Wark One of the most important political books of the year...The ingenuity and collective good sense of the communards will challenge any reader who struggles to reconcile egalitarian politics with concerns over state violence and power. -- Jonathan Sturgeon * Flavorwire * Ross brilliantly remaps the political topoi of the Commune in a narrative that is short but densely interwoven, a pattern of lively and vibrant connections not unlike the floral design by Morris on the book's cover. What the attentive reader gains is the ability to feel the surge of ideas and movement of people that transformed a situation of insurmountable crisis into a moment for revolutionary change * caa.reviews * A timely and fecund work that should stimulate anarchist thought and action on the relevance of the Commune to the contemporary politics of occupation, resistance, and prefiguration. * Anarchist Studies * Ross evokes the exhilaration of art freed from the museum and being lived as something 'vital and indispensable to the community' * Marx & Philosophy * At its most literal, the ideal of communal luxury could just mean public art but the demand the slogan evokes is more expansive and far-reaching, namely, the demand that beauty flourish in social spaces and therefore the later avant-garde expectation of the full integration of art into everyday life exemplified in Constructivism. Ross evokes the exhilaration of art freed from the museum and being lived as something 'vital and indispensable to the community.' -- Jeremy Spencer * Marx & Philosophy Society *