Forbidden
A 3,000-Year History of Jews and the Pig
Published on 8. October 2024
Book
Hardback
272 pages
978-1-4798-3149-4 (ISBN)
Description
Winner of the 74th National Jewish Book Award: The Jane and Stuart Weitzman Family Award for Food Writing and Cookbooks
A surprising history of how the pig has influenced Jewish identity
Jews do not eat pig. This (not always true) observation has been made by both Jews and non-Jews for more than three thousand years and is rooted in biblical law. Though the Torah prohibits eating pig meat, it is not singled out more than other food prohibitions. Horses, rabbits, squirrels, and even vultures, while also not kosher, do not inspire the same level of revulsion for Jews as the pig. The pig has become an iconic symbol for people to signal their Jewishness, non-Jewishness, or rebellion from Judaism. There is nothing in the Bible that suggests Jews are meant to embrace this level of pig-phobia.
Starting with the Hebrew Bible, Jordan D. Rosenblum historicizes the emergence of the pig as a key symbol of Jewish identity, from the Roman persecution of ancient rabbis, to the Spanish Inquisition, when so-called Marranos ("Pigs") converted to Catholicism, to Shakespeare's writings, to modern memoirs of those leaving Orthodox Judaism. The pig appears in debates about Jewish emancipation in eighteenth-century England and in vaccine conspiracies; in World War II rallying cries, when many American Jewish soldiers were "eating ham for Uncle Sam;" in conversations about pig sandwiches reportedly consumed by Karl Marx; and in recent deliberations about the kosher status of Impossible Pork.
All told, there is a rich and varied story about the associations of Jews and pigs over time, both emerging from within Judaism and imposed on Jews by others. Expansive yet accessible, Forbidden offers a captivating look into Jewish history and identity through the lens of the pig.
A surprising history of how the pig has influenced Jewish identity
Jews do not eat pig. This (not always true) observation has been made by both Jews and non-Jews for more than three thousand years and is rooted in biblical law. Though the Torah prohibits eating pig meat, it is not singled out more than other food prohibitions. Horses, rabbits, squirrels, and even vultures, while also not kosher, do not inspire the same level of revulsion for Jews as the pig. The pig has become an iconic symbol for people to signal their Jewishness, non-Jewishness, or rebellion from Judaism. There is nothing in the Bible that suggests Jews are meant to embrace this level of pig-phobia.
Starting with the Hebrew Bible, Jordan D. Rosenblum historicizes the emergence of the pig as a key symbol of Jewish identity, from the Roman persecution of ancient rabbis, to the Spanish Inquisition, when so-called Marranos ("Pigs") converted to Catholicism, to Shakespeare's writings, to modern memoirs of those leaving Orthodox Judaism. The pig appears in debates about Jewish emancipation in eighteenth-century England and in vaccine conspiracies; in World War II rallying cries, when many American Jewish soldiers were "eating ham for Uncle Sam;" in conversations about pig sandwiches reportedly consumed by Karl Marx; and in recent deliberations about the kosher status of Impossible Pork.
All told, there is a rich and varied story about the associations of Jews and pigs over time, both emerging from within Judaism and imposed on Jews by others. Expansive yet accessible, Forbidden offers a captivating look into Jewish history and identity through the lens of the pig.
Reviews / Votes
Forbidden is an engaging and surprisingly cheerful study of that odd couple of the religious imagination, the Jew and the pig... The anthropologist in Mr. Rosenblum calls [Jewish-American pork-eaters] a 'balancing of rupture and continuity.' There is, of course, no balancing rupture and continuity. Sometimes, you have to pick a side. And a main. (Wall Street Journal) An enlightening historical expose of the remarkable transformation of the pig from an obscure animal in Jewish dietary laws to the center of what it means to be Jewish. (Foreword Reviews) A rich and highly readable Jewish cultural history of the pig. Based on an impressive array of sources, Rosenblum shows that the pig has been a defining feature of Jewish identity from ancient Israel through today. - Beth Berkowitz, author of Animals and Animality in the Babylonian Talmud Easy to read, spiced with humor and new information. Who knew there was so much history between Jews and pigs? (Jewish Herald-Voice) Using a wealth of sources, Rosenblum invites readers to delve deep into the Jewish cultural significance of the swine over time. (The Jewish Book Council) A historical tour d'horizon of the obsessive focus on Jews and the pig from antiquity to the present... Given [Rosenblum's] past scholarship on Jewish foodways in antiquity, it comes as no surprise that the analyses of classical texts sparkle... Those who eat 'pork for dinner,' those repelled by the very thought, and those somewhere in between will all find food for thought in this illuminating volume. - Jonathan Sarna (Contemporary Jewry) A lively new history. (The Jewish Chronicle) Captivating and contagious ... The depth into which Rosenblum reaches to uncover minute and key details and hidden correlations equally deserves praise. (Association of Jewish Libraries) Wonderfully written ... Rosenblum's book, a model of bringing religion, history, and contemporary experience together, shows how the decisions we make today often live in the shadow of those we have faced for centuries. (The Jewish News of Northern California)More details
Language
English
Place of publication
New York
United States
Target group
College/higher education
Product notice
Trade binding
Illustrations
15 b/w figures
Dimensions
Height: 229 mm
Width: 152 mm
Weight
590 gr
ISBN-13
978-1-4798-3149-4 (9781479831494)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Person
Jordan Rosenblum is Professor of Religious Studies, University of Wisconsin-Madison, where he is also the Belzer Professor of Classical Judaism at the Mosse/Weinstein Center for Jewish Studies. He is the author of many books, including Rabbinic Drinking: What Beverages Teach Us About Rabbinic Literature,
The Jewish Dietary Laws in the Ancient World and Food and Identity in Early Rabbinic Judaism and coeditor of Feasting and Fasting: The History and Ethics of Jewish Food.
The Jewish Dietary Laws in the Ancient World and Food and Identity in Early Rabbinic Judaism and coeditor of Feasting and Fasting: The History and Ethics of Jewish Food.