Never Again
Germans and Genocide after the Holocaust
Published on 2. May 2023
Book
Hardback
416 pages
978-0-674-27522-5 (ISBN)
Description
Laura Shannon Prize in Contemporary European Studies Shortlist
Germans remember the Nazi past so that it may never happen again. But how has the abstract vow to remember translated into concrete action to prevent new genocides abroad?
As reports of mass killings in Bosnia spread in the middle of 1995, Germans faced a dilemma. Should the Federal Republic deploy its military to the Balkans to prevent a genocide, or would departing from postwar Germany's pacifist tradition open the door to renewed militarism? In short, when Germans said "never again," did they mean "never again Auschwitz" or "never again war"?
Looking beyond solemn statements and well-meant monuments, Andrew I. Port examines how the Nazi past shaped German responses to the genocides in Cambodia, Bosnia, and Rwanda-and further, how these foreign atrocities recast Germans' understanding of their own horrific history. In the late 1970s, the reign of the Khmer Rouge received relatively little attention from a firmly antiwar public that was just "discovering" the Holocaust. By the 1990s, the genocide of the Jews was squarely at the center of German identity, a tectonic shift that inspired greater involvement in Bosnia and, to a lesser extent, Rwanda. Germany's increased willingness to use force in defense of others reflected the enthusiastic embrace of human rights by public officials and ordinary citizens. At the same time, conservatives welcomed the opportunity for a more active international role involving military might-to the chagrin of pacifists and progressives at home.
Making the lessons, limits, and liabilities of politics driven by memories of a troubled history harrowingly clear, Never Again is a story with deep resonance for any country confronting a dark past.
Germans remember the Nazi past so that it may never happen again. But how has the abstract vow to remember translated into concrete action to prevent new genocides abroad?
As reports of mass killings in Bosnia spread in the middle of 1995, Germans faced a dilemma. Should the Federal Republic deploy its military to the Balkans to prevent a genocide, or would departing from postwar Germany's pacifist tradition open the door to renewed militarism? In short, when Germans said "never again," did they mean "never again Auschwitz" or "never again war"?
Looking beyond solemn statements and well-meant monuments, Andrew I. Port examines how the Nazi past shaped German responses to the genocides in Cambodia, Bosnia, and Rwanda-and further, how these foreign atrocities recast Germans' understanding of their own horrific history. In the late 1970s, the reign of the Khmer Rouge received relatively little attention from a firmly antiwar public that was just "discovering" the Holocaust. By the 1990s, the genocide of the Jews was squarely at the center of German identity, a tectonic shift that inspired greater involvement in Bosnia and, to a lesser extent, Rwanda. Germany's increased willingness to use force in defense of others reflected the enthusiastic embrace of human rights by public officials and ordinary citizens. At the same time, conservatives welcomed the opportunity for a more active international role involving military might-to the chagrin of pacifists and progressives at home.
Making the lessons, limits, and liabilities of politics driven by memories of a troubled history harrowingly clear, Never Again is a story with deep resonance for any country confronting a dark past.
Reviews / Votes
[An] excellent study...shows in great detail the diverse ways the rhetoric of remembrance and invocations of the legacy of the Third Reich were mobilized to advocate for or against various possible political responses...a valuable contribution. -- Devin Pendas * German Studies Review * Ambitious, original and richly evidenced...Port offers an innovative contribution in the atrophied terrain of 'memory studies.' Never Again implies that Walter Benjamin's 'Angel of History' is, at last, turning away from sentimental memorials and sentimental solemnity-and looking forward. -- Christopher Hale * History Today * Never Again thoroughly examines the German response to three genocides that took place elsewhere in the world after the Second World War-in Cambodia, Bosnia and Rwanda-and considers, in particular, the role that the Nazi past and the Holocaust played in debates about them. -- Hans Kundnani * Times Literary Supplement * A wonderfully diverse summary narrative of the influence of the Nazi past on Germany's engagement with contemporary genocide and mass atrocity...The strength of the book is to show just how complicated and often contradictory responses to atrocity could be in Germany, being informed by the experiences of the Holocaust, World War II, and the ongoing process of facing the past. -- Stefan Ihrig * H-Diplo * In his astute analysis, based on a great deal of carefully documented evidence, [Port] is able to illuminate again and again the historical background and link it to the experiences Germans had with the Nazi era -and their memory of it. -- Klaus-Peter Friedrich * Neue Politische Literatur * Port's meticulously researched book is a well-written account of Germans struggling to do the right thing-whether on the political or personal level-against the backdrop of their own history...An important contribution. -- Gisela Dachs * Israel Journal of Foreign Affairs * A valuable and enduring contribution to the scholarship on the German tradition of reckoning with the Nazi past and its implications for foreign policy from the 1970s to 1990s...provides an essential background for understanding the tectonic changes that German political culture and foreign policy have undergone in recent years. -- Jeffrey C. Herf * Historische Zeitschrift * A splendid...brilliant study... [Port] builds a bridge between the emergence of a Holocaust-related culture of remembrance and a history of humanitarianism before and after the fall of the Berlin Wall. His book also addresses the contemporary problem of how society deals with mass violence in distant regions. Not least due to recent global political developments, this requires more than ever a competent classification by the specialist disciplines. -- Annette Weinke * Sueddeutsche Zeitung * A unique and ground-breaking study...Port is to be commended for thorough archival work on these three crises and his ability to tie in and isolate the German moral and political dilemmas on how to properly respond to them. -- A. M. Mayer * Choice * A thrilling accomplishment. Ingeniously conceived and intrepidly executed, Never Again explores how German mastery of the Holocaust past proceeded through reflection on foreign atrocities, first in the postcolonial world and then in Europe itself. This is the most important study of memory, politics, and the ongoing construction of public norms written in a long time. -- Samuel Moyn, author of <i>Humane: How the United States Abandoned Peace and Reinvented War</i> Germans, in the communist East, the democratic West, and the reunified nation, cannot deal with atrocities in other countries without being haunted by their own dark history. How they have negotiated these dangerous political challenges, sometimes successfully, sometimes not, is the subject of Port's fascinating, elegant, subtle, and always fair-minded book. -- Ian Buruma, author of <i>The Collaborators: Three Stories of Deception and Survival in World War II</i> A fascinating, carefully crafted look at how the powerful and dynamic factor of German memory of the Second World War and the Holocaust affected German foreign policy on the genocides in Cambodia, Bosnia, and Rwanda. Port's nuanced and suggestive analysis also contributes in important ways to our understanding of the making of Berlin's zigzag policies on Ukraine today. -- Norman M. Naimark, author of <i>Stalin and the Fate of Europe: The Postwar Struggle for Sovereignty</i> This deeply researched book tells the story of how, by embracing human rights and engaging in humanitarian actions, Germany rejoined 'the community of nations as a peaceful member.' Port illuminates the highly topical question of how Germany's past both shapes and constrains its responses to contemporary bloodshed. -- M. E. Sarotte, author of <i>Not One Inch: America, Russia, and the Making of Post-Cold War Stalemate</i> A highly original work, sensitive both to domestic debates and to far broader transnational and international considerations. By exploring how a concern with their own genocidal past informed German reactions to later genocides, Port illuminates not only the German responses to events elsewhere in the world but also the ways in which, in an increasingly mobile and globalizing society, German society was and is itself changing. -- Mary Fulbrook, author of <i>Reckonings: Legacies of Nazi Persecution and the Quest for Justice</i> A brilliant new perspective on postwar German history. Even with hundreds of books written on attempts to cope with the Nazi past, the political consequences of shifting memory culture have seldom been discussed. In exploring how the Holocaust became an argument in German foreign policy, humanitarian aid, and military interventions, Port offers a wealth of insight-not only on Germany, but also on its global context. -- Frank Boesch, author of <i>Mass Media and Historical Change: Germany in International Perspective, 1400 to the Present</i> Fascinating reading. With Russia's war on Ukraine, Germany faces its biggest crisis yet in its understanding of how the Holocaust and World War II should influence its military policy. Port's timely book shows that this is not the first time Germans grappled with this issue. Examining earlier debates about the proper response to atrocities in Cambodia, Bosnia, and Rwanda, Never Again provides essential historical context for the contemporary dilemma of how to address Russian aggression. -- Hope M. Harrison, author of <i>After the Berlin Wall: Memory and the Making of the New Germany, 1989 to the Present</i>More details
Language
English
Place of publication
Cambridge, Mass
United States
Target group
Professional and scholarly
Illustrations
14 photos
Dimensions
Height: 240 mm
Width: 164 mm
Thickness: 41 mm
Weight
810 gr
ISBN-13
978-0-674-27522-5 (9780674275225)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Person
Andrew I. Port is the author of Conflict and Stability in the German Democratic Republic and the recipient of the DAAD Prize for Distinguished Scholarship in German and European Studies. He is Professor of History at Wayne State University and former editor-in-chief of the flagship journal Central European History.