No Simple Solutions

Reviews / Votes

All things considered, this is an important book that comprehensively and critically documents Chicago's Plan for Transformation. It is a valuable book for anyone-scholars, practitioners, policymakers, community organizations, and students-interested in these important housing policies. * Journal of Urban Affairs * The book does a great job in presenting cutting edge social research, while tracing the remarkably important role that the author (who has over 30 years of experience studying CHA residents) and her colleagues played in shaping the social service component of Chicago's public housing transformation. . . Because No Simple Solutions represents the first major book on the conditions of HOPE VI relocatees, I recommend it to housing scholars and practitioners on both sides of the Atlantic. * Journal of Housing and the Built Environment * Applied sociologist Popkin presents vivid snapshots portraying the lived experiences of individuals, families, and neighborhoods impacted by public housing policies and revitalization efforts. In 1999, Chicago embarked on an ambitious venture: to rid the city of distressed and deteriorating public housing developments and their accompaniments, including crime, failing schools, crumbling infrastructures, and failed dreams. Popkin builds on her decades of research in Chicago's public housing developments to answer the fundamental question of what the Plan for Transformation meant to Chicago Housing Authority families. In several longitudinal studies, Popkin and her team of researchers conducted surveys and in-depth interviews with hundreds of families and found that transforming the lives of public housing residents requires a more holistic approach that goes far beyond building new housing developments. Documenting the experiences of 'hard to house' families, Popkin demonstrates the need to combine housing assistance with meaningful services targeted at individual and family needs. A must-read for students, practitioners, and researchers interested in housing policy from the ground up.

Summing Up: Essential. Upper-division undergraduates and above. * Choice Reviews * No Simple Solutions by Susan Popkin shows that most displaced residents have benefited, but a significant minority has been hurt. The book does a great job in presenting cutting edge social research, while tracing the remarkably important role that the author (who has over 30 years of experience studying CHA residents) and her colleagues played in shaping the social service component of Chicago's public housing transformation.... I cannot overemphasize the value of this qualitative research.... Unlike other public housing books that end with a 'gloom and doom' scenario, Popkin urges readers to press on and to make incremental improvements.... Because No Simple Solutions represents the first major book on the conditions of HOPE VI relocatees, I recommend it to housing scholars and practitioners on both sides of the Atlantic. * Journal of Housing and the Built Environment * The book is an insightful account... Popkin's No Simple Solutions is an important addition to this literature. It is essential reading for students, scholars, and practitioners interested in the social and human consequences of mismanaged, underfunded, and neglected public housing, and the complicated challenges of addressing them. * Housing Studies * Epic and encyclopedic, this vital book illuminates the human drama induced by Chicago's bold Plan for Transformation. Multiple surveys conducted over more than 15 years' time, plus vivid in-depth interviews that put skin on the numbers, reveal a remarkable, surprising, and ultimately hopeful story. Award-winning author Susan Popkin delivers an essential read for anyone who cares about how our nation attends to the housing needs of the poor. -- Kathryn Edin, Bloomberg Distinguished Professor, Department of Sociology, Johns Hopkins University "Susan Popkin's clear-eyed, succinct, and compassionate book focuses on the children and parents who suffered through the intolerable conditions of Chicago's public housing, and then navigated the complex attempts to transform it. With Popkin's unique perspective gained from following families for more than a decade, No Easy Solutions provides a deeply well informed guide to what is needed next." -- Lawrence J. Vale, Ford Professor of Urban Design and Planning, Massachusetts Institute of Technology "This important new book offers a hopeful but unflinching account of one of America's most ambitious and also misunderstood efforts to transform ghetto poverty in a major city. In this vivid and accessible account, we learn the real impacts on highly disadvantaged parents and their children over time-and what does and does not make a difference in their lives. Sue Popkin is one of our most astute, seasoned, and dedicated observers of vulnerable families in low-income housing. Her new book is required reading." -- Xavier de Souza Briggs, Vice President, Ford Foundation and Professor of Sociology and Planning, Massachusetts Institute of Technology