When Cooperation Fails
The International Law and Politics of Genetically Modified Foods
Published on 21. May 2009
Book
Hardback
456 pages
978-0-19-923728-9 (ISBN)
Description
The transatlantic dispute over genetically modified organisms (GMOs) has brought into conflict the United States and the European Union, two long-time allies and economically interdependent democracies with a long record of successful cooperation. Yet the dispute - pitting a largely acceptant US against an EU deeply suspicious of GMOs - has developed into one of the most bitter and intractable transatlantic and global conflicts, resisting efforts at negotiated resolution and resulting in a bitterly contested legal battle before the World Trade Organization.
Professors Pollack and Shaffer investigate the obstacles to reconciling regulatory differences among nations through international cooperation, using the lens of the GMO dispute. The book addresses the dynamic interactions of domestic law and politics, transnational networks, international regimes, and global markets, through a theoretically grounded and empirically comprehensive analysis of the governance of GM foods and crops. They demonstrate that the deeply politicized, entrenched and path-dependent nature of the regulation of GMOs in the US and the EU has fundamentally shaped negotiations and decision-making at the international level, limiting the prospects for deliberation and providing incentives for both sides to engage in hard bargaining and to "shop" for favorable international forums. They then assess the impacts, and the limits, of international pressures on domestic US and European law, politics and business practice, which have remained strikingly resistant to change.
International cooperation in areas like GMO regulation, the authors conclude, must overcome multiple obstacles, legal and political, domestic and international. Any effective response to this persistent dispute, they argue, must recognize both the obstacles to successful cooperation, and the options that remain for each side when cooperation fails.
Professors Pollack and Shaffer investigate the obstacles to reconciling regulatory differences among nations through international cooperation, using the lens of the GMO dispute. The book addresses the dynamic interactions of domestic law and politics, transnational networks, international regimes, and global markets, through a theoretically grounded and empirically comprehensive analysis of the governance of GM foods and crops. They demonstrate that the deeply politicized, entrenched and path-dependent nature of the regulation of GMOs in the US and the EU has fundamentally shaped negotiations and decision-making at the international level, limiting the prospects for deliberation and providing incentives for both sides to engage in hard bargaining and to "shop" for favorable international forums. They then assess the impacts, and the limits, of international pressures on domestic US and European law, politics and business practice, which have remained strikingly resistant to change.
International cooperation in areas like GMO regulation, the authors conclude, must overcome multiple obstacles, legal and political, domestic and international. Any effective response to this persistent dispute, they argue, must recognize both the obstacles to successful cooperation, and the options that remain for each side when cooperation fails.
Reviews / Votes
an illuminating and methodologically diverse book...not only a rich interdisciplinary dissection of one of the most intractable trade disputes but also a compelling account of the most spectacular regulatory failure of transatlantic cooperation * Alberto Alemanno, Common Market Law Review * There is no doubt that this book constitutes a watershed in the literature about the science-politics interface in the international context, and especially in trans-Atlantic cooperation (or lack thereof). The excellent, original, and highly inspiring treatment of this issue, in both theoretical and empirical terms across political and legal disciplines, brings to the fore the deep interdependency in the bilateral, multilateral, and transnational dimensions of the US-EU relations. The five lessons that the authors draw in the concluding chapter open new venues for further research on this matter. But above all, this book is the fruit of a highly successful, tenacious, and systematic research endeavour that provides new insights into this fascinating topic. * Susana Borras, Science and Public Policy * The contribution of the work lies in its careful, comprehensive, and ultimately convincing presentation of the arguments...Pollack and Shaffer clearly state that the US and EU regulatory frameworks have been produced in such different ways that they will be resilient to change, even in the face of international pressures, such as WTO rulings. The text contains many facts, a good description, and its scope of research is wide. This book will reward the reader - and cannot be ignored by anyone interested in GMO conflict. * Javier Guillem Carrau ommon Market Law Review * An engaging and thorough study of a seemingly intractable international trade dispute...Pollack and Shaffer evaluate the potential outcomes of WTO panel approaches beyond that actually adopted in the US-EU dispute using several methodologies. Their comparative institutional analysis offers new and important insights into the consequences of what might superficially seem to be a typical question of exegesis and international treaties. The book ably reveals the potentially weighty political and institutional consequences of choosing one seemingly technical legal interpretation of a treaty over another, and of the choice of treaties identified as those relevant to the dispute. * Aaron Fellmeth, Global Law Books * The book shows the limits of diplomacy and international law in areas of deeply entrenched differences of perceptions and attitudes in a regulatory field. It offers many of the elements that need to be taken into account in moving the matter forward in international law in coming years. It is an excellent piece of analytical research and highly recommended to all working in agricultural biotechnology regulation and beyond. * Thomas Cottier, World Trade Review * This book presents an original and an exhaustively researched analysis of one of the difficult and intractable disputes in the transatlantic relationship. It skillfully explores the complex interaction between the national and international dimensions of the GMO dispute in a way that clearly illuminates both the potential and limitations of international regulatory cooperation. Shaffer and Pollack have made a major contribution to our understanding of the legal and political dynamics of regulatory-related trade disputes. * David Vogel, University of California, Berkeley * Mark Pollack and Greg Shaffer's When Cooperation Fails is a masterful analysis of the causes and consequences of the failure of transatlantic cooperation as it relates to agricultural biotechnology In short, while specialists in agricultural biotech and transatlantic relations will find When Cooperation Fails 'must-reading', the book should also be engaged by a wide range of specialists in international law, politics and political economy. * Joseph Jupille, EUSA Review * An excellent piece of analytical research and highly recommended to all working in agricultural biotechnology regulation and beyond * Thomas Cottier, World Trade Review *More details
Language
English
Place of publication
Oxford
United Kingdom
Target group
Professional and scholarly
Dimensions
Height: 240 mm
Width: 161 mm
Thickness: 29 mm
Weight
845 gr
ISBN-13
978-0-19-923728-9 (9780199237289)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Other editions
Additional editions
Mark A. Pollack | Gregory C. Shaffer
When Cooperation Fails
The International Law and Politics of Genetically Modified Foods
Book
05/2009
Oxford University Press
€59.30
Shipment within 15-20 days
Persons
Mark A. Pollack is Associate Professor of Political Science at Temple University, where he teaches classes in international relations and European Union politics. He received his Ph.D. from Harvard University in 1995. He has also taught at the University of Wisconsin-Madison (1995-2004) and was Senior Research Fellow in the transatlantic relations program at the European University Institute in Florence, Italy (2000-2002). His research agenda focuses on the role of international institutions in the regional and global governance, with specific projects examining the delegation of powers to the supranational organizations in the European Union, the creation of new mechanisms for the governance of the transatlantic relationship, the global governance of genetically modified organisms, and the "mainstreaming " of gender issues in international organizations.
Professor Gregory Shaffer is Melvin C. Steen Professor of Law at the University of Minnesota Law School. He was previously Professor of Law at the University of Wisconsin Law School, where he was also Director of the University's European Union Center and Co-Director and Senior Fellow of its Center on World Affairs and the Global Economy, and the inaugural Wing-Tat Lee Chair of International Law at Loyola University Chicago School of Law. Professor Shaffer is a recipient of two US National Science Foundation Law and Social Science grants for his work on the World Trade Organization, a Fulbright Senior Research Scholar for his study of transatlantic regulatory conflict and cooperation, and a Senior Research Fellow at the International Centre on Trade and Sustainable Development for its work on WTO dispute settlement and developing countries.
Professor Gregory Shaffer is Melvin C. Steen Professor of Law at the University of Minnesota Law School. He was previously Professor of Law at the University of Wisconsin Law School, where he was also Director of the University's European Union Center and Co-Director and Senior Fellow of its Center on World Affairs and the Global Economy, and the inaugural Wing-Tat Lee Chair of International Law at Loyola University Chicago School of Law. Professor Shaffer is a recipient of two US National Science Foundation Law and Social Science grants for his work on the World Trade Organization, a Fulbright Senior Research Scholar for his study of transatlantic regulatory conflict and cooperation, and a Senior Research Fellow at the International Centre on Trade and Sustainable Development for its work on WTO dispute settlement and developing countries.
Content
List of Tables ; Acronyms ; Acknowledgements ; 1. Introduction and Overview: Biotechnology, Risk Regulation, and the Failure of Cooperation ; 2. The Domestic Sources of the Conflict: Why the US and EU Biotech Regulatory Regimes Differ ; 3. The Promise and Failure of Transatlantic Regulatory Cooperation through Networks ; 4. Deliberation or Bargaining? Distributive Conflict and the Fragmented International Regime Complex ; 5. WTO Dispute Settlement Meets GMOs: Who Decides? ; 6. US and EU Policies Since 2000: Change, Continuity and (Lack of) Convergence ; 7. Conclusions: The Lessons of Transatlantic Conflict, Developing Countries and the Future of Agricultural Biotechnology ; References ; Index