The Waterless Sea

Reviews / Votes

Through the words of generations of desert travellers, Pinney paints the shimmering heat, the dazzling sand and the strange visions hanging in the sky. He reproduces fascinating postcards, engravings and photos of floating ships and castles, palm trees and palaces that "possess every possible stability", including one alleged photograph of a skyscraper city emerging from the Muir Glacier in Alaska. For ice, too, makes mirages, as light refracts through the different temperatures and densities of air . . . Mr Pinney concludes with Plato's thought that nothing made or seen on this Earth can be more than a poor representation of the beautiful Ideal. Might a mirage be that elusive original? * The Economist * Christopher Pinney has emerged with perhaps the finest homage to evanescence yet written . . . Ultimately The Waterless Sea reveals its author to be as spiritually refracted as the - elusive and translucent occlusion he seeks to own; the richness of his sensibility is every bit as compelling as his subject. As Pinney shows, the mirage is primarily a phenomenon of spiritual resonance, ungovernable and in that, unimaginably potent. Fuelled by the tangible in its creation of the fantastic, the mirage exists to turn the human eye inward. * The Australian * Anyone who has driven down a hot asphalt country road will have seen in the distance what appears to be a pool of standing water that remains perpetually out of reach. In The Waterless Sea, anthropologist Pinney delves into the many accounts of fantastic mirages that have been reported over the centuries. No mere optical illusions, he says, mirages are real and are produced by atmospheric optics. Their interpretations, however, have been shaped by culture, politics, religion, and science. Their illusory qualities drive Pinney's philosophical discussion, which touches on a number of topics, such as their use as metaphor and moral lesson. Historical photos, prints, lithographs, and paintings illustrate Pinney's erudite narrative. * Physics Today * The illusory seas observed in sere deserts are not the only form of mirage, notes Christopher Pinney in this alluring tour of the phenomenon in science and culture. Created by light refracting as it moves through atmospheric regions with differing temperatures, mirages can also appear as imposing and mysterious "castles in the air". Pinney ranges from the old Japanese belief that these "phantom paradises" were exhaled by clam monsters, to an 1898 Nature report detailing mirage effects on flagstone pavements. A paean to a sublime apparition, "real, but not true". * Nature * It is better for a book to have too much in it than too little, and nobody could say that Christopher Pinney sells his readers short. His cultural overview of mirage hurtles around the globe, around history, around political systems, and around religious faiths, in a hailstorm of quotation and citation, reference and reverie.There are many pleasures in the breathless progress. Terms and metaphors for different types of mirage in different places are a delight in themselves . . . It is beautifully produced, almost every page displaying a fascinating picture to illuminate the text; the text itself is beautiful too, evocative and often valuably informative. * Folklore * [A] highbrow meditation . . . Pinney examines mirages as cause of frustration and disappointment, as religious metaphor for falsehood or a society on the brink, and as depiction of mythological places . . . Readers curious about the natural world will find this rumination of interest. * Publishers Weekly * Pinney's fascinating new book . . . traces the illusions of mirages through many eras and cultures and environments . . . Throughout history, from China to Persia to India . . . he's a shrewd reader of the patterns underlying all such visions. * Christian Science Monitor * This is both a study of the mirage as a subject of scholarship and a profound meditation on its paradoxical form as a true illusion ... Pinney explores the way in which the fata morgana has been deployed since the 19th century to think about the existential, aesthetic and political choices, as much as contradictions, between the evidence of the eyes and that of the mind ...this is a global account of its vacillating form as a site of reflection. Itself written as if in the style of a mirage, this is a beautifully conceived work that philosophises the visible. * Faisal Devji, University of Oxford * Pinney's erudite and highly readable account of the mirage is a scintillating journey through more than just an ephemeral intangibility. It is a substantial history of the sublime as it is refracted on the surface of what remains enchanted, mysterious and strange. What appears on the horizon, or just above it, thanks to Pinney's delightful reflections, are a number of unique perspectives on a diverse range of topics, such as colonialism and empire, science and religion, democracy and despotism - and even photography. And just as we historically and collectively confront ourselves in the mirage, what results in this beautiful book are a number of subjective experiences that are, paradoxically, also collective. * Omar W. Nasim. University of Regensburg * Pinney explores the enchanting enigma of fata morgana or mirages, visions of cities in the sky or stately mansions floating on fantastic oceans in deserts and polar wastes . . . Pinney provides an extraordinary tour of the union of refraction and the imagination. * Jonathan Lamb, Vanderbilt University *