Beyond Human Rights

Reviews / Votes

From a review of the German edition: 'There is much to admire in Anne Peters' book, so much that after reading Jenseits der Menschenrechte, it is difficult to imagine what else can be done in this area of the law.' Roland Portmann, Voelkerrechtsblog (voelkerrechtsblog.org) From a review of the German edition: 'Anne Peters' most recent opus Beyond Human Rights: The Legal Status of the Individual in International Law constitutes an outstanding and groundbreaking piece of scholarship that radically re-positions the individual within the grid system of international law and consistently supplements her previous work on global constitutionalism.' Raphael Oidtmann, Voelkerrechtsblog (voelkerrechtsblog.org) From a review of the German edition: 'Anne Peters' most recent book is an equally important and topical contribution to the international law discourse ... It provides both an in-depth analysis of the rights and obligations of the individual under contemporary international law and a great deal of food for thought regarding what to make of this analysis from the point of view of international law doctrine. Both in its effort of stocktaking and of providing a vision where the development is heading, Jenseits der Menschenrechte marks a significant step in the growing scholarship on the legal status of the individual in international law and, thus, truly deserves to be called a milestone book for the discipline. It is to be strongly hoped that it will soon also be available in English.' Andreas Th. Mueller, European Journal of International Law From a review of the German edition: 'This book is both an intelligent and important one. It lucidly and convincingly explains how international law has come to not only tolerate but also consciously acknowledge individual rights.' Steffen Augsberg, translated from Portal fuer Politikwissenschaft (pw-portal.de) From a review of the German edition: 'Individual rights exist in international law; that is the core message of this book and imperative premise of any critical discussion on the widening gap between reality ... and human rights rhetoric. Doubtless, another merit of this book is its warning against a mere formal and discursive human rights recourse (hence the title). This publication is a must-read for anyone who knows German.' Agostino Carrino, translated from Rivista semestrale di scienza costituzionale e teoria del diritto From a review of the German edition: 'This comprehensive, well-researched and diverse book dovetails with Anne Peters' previous eminent publications. Not only does this book empirically examine numerous legal subfields but it also strengthens their philosophical and doctrinal foundations. Thus it makes a contribution both in terms of analysing the status quo and further developing the role of individual rights in international law.' Katrin Fenrich, Journal of International Law of Peace and Armed Conflict From a review of the German edition: 'Peters puts the individual at the core of international law. Such a simple albeit unusual change of perspective legitimizes an individual-centred rather than state-centred understanding of international law. Peters can thus transpose national legal concepts on to international law. If consistently adhered to, such an approach is capable of undermining a number of politically motivated arguments against rights protection.' Christina Globke, translated from Fachbuch Journal From a review of the German edition: 'Anne Peters' magistral publication validates her intuition that constitutionalism is a relevant approach to contemporary international law.' Evelyne Lagrange, Voelkerrechtsblog (voelkerrechtsblog.org) From a review of the German edition: 'Anne Peters' Beyond Human Rights: The Legal Status of the Individual in International Law is an impressive scholarly intervention, which can be read both as a standalone contribution to the debates about the position of the individual in international law, as well as a companion to Peters' previous work on global constitutionalism and the constitutionalization of international law.' Zoran Oklopcic, Voelkerrechtsblog (voelkerrechtsblog.org) From a review of the German edition: 'This book convincingly shows the paradigm shift in international law making the individual and no longer states the main legal subject.' Eduard Christian Schoepfer, translated from Newsletter Menschenrechte From a review of the German edition: 'Peters' conception includes two layers of individual rights embedded within a normative hierarchy: higher-ranking, constitutional-type human rights, and lower-ranking, 'simple' rights of ordinary international law. This opens up a new doctrinal category and a new register of argumentation: UNESCO, to use Peters' example, can still argue that 'sport' is an individual right but does not need to claim that there is a human right to sport. This is desirable because simple rights help avoid the inflation and banalization of human rights.' Michael Riegner, Voelkerrechtsblog (voelkerrechtsblog.org) 'Beyond Human Rights excels through its exceptional research into international and regional courts and bodies, human rights institutions, arbitral tribunals, national law codes, particular cases, and domestic courts.' C. E. Welch, CHOICE