Forging the Golden Urn

Reviews / Votes

[Oidtmann's] work is marked by an exemplary scholarly discipline. . . . What he brings to the table is an extensive insight into the thinking and debates over the Golden Urn's introduction among the Manchu authorities, and most particularly those of the aging Qianlong emperor (1711-99) himself. -- Martin A. Mills * Journal of Asian Studies * An absorbing read for non-specialists. * Asian Review of Books * Sheds a thoroughly new light on Sino-Tibetan relations against the backdrop of Qing colonialism. * Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies * Max Oidtmann's tour de force is in introducing the reader to the mysteries of both Manchu and Tibetan powers. [He] offers a remarkable and finely crafted study. * Inner Asia * Meticulously researched and skillfully argued. * Journal of Chinese History * Oidtmann's eloquent and learned book is thus essential reading for anyone who wants to understand the Qing political order. -- Joseph Lawson * Modern Chinese Literature and Culture * [Forging the Golden Urn] serves as an outstanding model for how to avoid the anachronisms that tend to haunt the historical study of matters mired in contemporary polemics. -- James Gentry, University of Virginia * Journal of Chinese Religions * It is not insignificant that Oidtmann's story brings together the disparate literary and cultural studies of Tibet and Qing China in an accessible and tidy monograph. -- J. Arya Moallem, Harvard University * Religious Studies Review * The most comprehensive examination of the Golden Urn question to-date. -- Massimo Introvigne * Bitter Winter * Not only does Max Oidtmann do an excellent job providing a captivating account of a famed religious implement in an imperial context, he also opens a valuable window on how Tibet existed as part of an empire during that time. * Reading Religion * The relationship between Qing China and Tibetan elites is explored in this fascinating work based on Manchu, Tibetan, and Chinese sources. * Choice * The book is a must-read for anyone interested in Qing-Tibet relations -- Lei Lin, Harvard University * Saksaha * An excellent and much-needed contribution to our knowledge of the politics of the Qing empire in Tibet. . . . A must-read not only for the historian of Tibet, but for anyone who wants to better understand the current Tibet-China conflict. * Chinese Historical Review * Max Oidtmann explores the impact of the golden urn ritual that the Qianlong emperor introduced in the early 1790s in order to-as he claimed-make the recognition of reincarnated lamas legitimate. The impact of this ritual innovation and its introduction into Tibet had profound consequences, not least regarding how it was subsequently interpreted by the Chinese on one side and the Tibetans and their Western supporters on the other. Oidtmann's work steps deftly into this binary historiographical struggle and brilliantly shows that everything was not only far more complicated than either side claims, but also far more interesting. In doing so, Forging the Golden Urn queries the actual nature of Qing rule in Tibet. -- Johan Elverskog, Southern Methodist University Using new source material, Max Oidtmann's Forging the Golden Urn opens a window to a better understanding of the dynamics that resulted in Tibet's increasing incorporation into the Qing empire. Framing these imperial efforts as a legal enterprise first and foremost, Oidtmann provides a fresh approach to examine the Qing's strategy for expanding and justifying its sovereignty. This excellent book-obviously a result of sound and careful research-is a major achievement. -- Peter Schwieger, University of Bonn Oidtmann's book opens up new perspectives on the intricate relationship that existed toward the end of the eighteenth century between Lhasa and the Qing court. The presence of reincarnate lamas is a defining feature of Tibetan Buddhism; Oidtmann brilliantly details its political dimension and the way the Qianlong emperor and his court decided to introduce the golden urn as a means to control the process by which reincarnate lamas were selected. Forging the Golden Urn is a tour de force and should be required reading for anyone interested in the history of Tibet, Qing history, and the history of Inner Asia. -- Leonard van der Kuijp, Harvard University An immensely valuable work in the studies of Qing imperialism in Tibet. * China Review International * A deeply researched account of the politics of reincarnation...all nicely framed by an introduction and conclusion that draw out the larger significance of the politics of the urn in Inner Asia and beyond. * Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies *