Access to Power

Reviews / Votes

Access to Power is a conceptually sophisticated analysis of how different kinds of consumers at the national, city and individual levels negotiate with Pakistan's long-faltering energy sector. Based on a wide range of interviews, it offers rare insights into the changing interstices of state and society in Pakistan." -Ayesha Jalal, Mary Richardson Professor of History and Director, Center for South Asian and Indian Ocean Studies, Tufts University Building on the emerging field of critical infrastructure studies, but embedding these concerns within longstanding discussions of state formation, this fascinating book shows us why the Pakistani state's presence is unevenly distributed within and across urban and national territory. Among Naqvi's most provocative findings is his claim that state failures to stem predation in the electricity sector are directly influenced by social formations that provide their own networks of production and consumption, both licit and illicit, thus relegating the formal administrative institutions of the state to a secondary role, particularly at the scale of the city. Electricity demands emanating from cities are central to the scalar dynamics of national governance even as they undermine state capacity locally." -Diane E. Davis, Charles Dyer Norton Professor of Regional Planning and Urbanism, Graduate School of Design, Harvard University An interesting discussion of an important topic. Naqvi takes access to electricity as a lens on state-building in Pakistan. His extensive research, including years of fieldwork, takes us inside Pakistani state bureaucracies and cautions against equating formal rights with substantive access." -Monica Prasad, Professor of Sociology, Northwestern University Access to Power unpacks the riddle of why so many efforts to reform the electricity sector in Pakistan have failed and why electricity remains such an unequally distributed service. Moving beyond the good governance literature, Naqvi locates power and politics at the center of his inquiry and through a nested analysis that moves from the national to the local methodically exposes the distributional conflicts and strategic actions that shape uneven state capacity. If many have called for disaggregating the state, Naqvi actually delivers. This is sociology at its best and a must read for anyone interested in understanding development as a contested process." -Patrick Heller, Professor of Sociology and International Affairs, Brown University Access to Power by Ijlal Naqvi is a fascinating book, focusing primarily on the tremendous electricity shortage in Pakistan as a glaring example of a deficient governmental structure, a situation common in South Asian states. * Priyanka Guha Roy, Project Muse *