The Great Train Robbery
Expounding the Myths
Published on 14. April 2025
Book
Hardback
224 pages
978-1-3990-3831-7 (ISBN)
Description
This is a fresh examination of the 'intelligence' gathered for the great train robbery.
The suggestion of an Irishman ('The Ulsterman') was simply part of a package created by the robbers in time for their release from prison and to contribute to the subsequent book - everything since has compounded the 'mystery'. Gordon Goody was one robber who 'met' The Ulsterman and speaks highly of The Ulsterman's information, but this information could easily be found elsewhere, and some of it is incorrect.
So who else might have given 'intelligence'? One by one, other 'suspects' are identified and discounted, but with evidence for their defence.
To use the metaphor 'hidden in plain sight', one can identify another 'suspect' with all the attributes The Ulsterman was said to have. If the reader is willing to look at the evidence afresh, it's necessary to consider not what the robbers et al have said, rather what they haven't said.
The robbers were dishonest men who frequently lied - but writers and commentators have followed what they have said. And it hasn't really led anywhere.
To unravel the yarn presented, it wasn't a senior official in either the Post Office or British Rail. It was an 'ordinary thief' with an extraordinary ability to blend into the background, and have fingers in a great many pies.
Let's expound the myth.
The suggestion of an Irishman ('The Ulsterman') was simply part of a package created by the robbers in time for their release from prison and to contribute to the subsequent book - everything since has compounded the 'mystery'. Gordon Goody was one robber who 'met' The Ulsterman and speaks highly of The Ulsterman's information, but this information could easily be found elsewhere, and some of it is incorrect.
So who else might have given 'intelligence'? One by one, other 'suspects' are identified and discounted, but with evidence for their defence.
To use the metaphor 'hidden in plain sight', one can identify another 'suspect' with all the attributes The Ulsterman was said to have. If the reader is willing to look at the evidence afresh, it's necessary to consider not what the robbers et al have said, rather what they haven't said.
The robbers were dishonest men who frequently lied - but writers and commentators have followed what they have said. And it hasn't really led anywhere.
To unravel the yarn presented, it wasn't a senior official in either the Post Office or British Rail. It was an 'ordinary thief' with an extraordinary ability to blend into the background, and have fingers in a great many pies.
Let's expound the myth.
More details
Language
English
Place of publication
Barnsley
United Kingdom
Publishing group
Pen & Sword Books Ltd
Illustrations
32 mono illustrations; 32 Illustrations
Dimensions
Height: 164 mm
Width: 242 mm
Thickness: 24 mm
Weight
432 gr
ISBN-13
978-1-3990-3831-7 (9781399038317)
Copyright in bibliographic data and cover images is held by Nielsen Book Services Limited or by the publishers or by their respective licensors: all rights reserved.
Schweitzer Classification
Person
Jim Morris published _The Great Train Robbery - A New History_ in 2013 for the fiftieth anniversary, and has published other true crime studies. He is a former mental health worker interested in behaviour and with a natural curiosity in folk who buck the system, not necessarily criminals.
Jim is a people watcher. Experts don't exist, there is only expertise and that's shared.
History relies on interpretation and sometimes we interpret the recording of facts, but not the facts.
Jim is a people watcher. Experts don't exist, there is only expertise and that's shared.
History relies on interpretation and sometimes we interpret the recording of facts, but not the facts.