Resisting Extortion

Reviews / Votes

'Resisting Extortion offers an empirically rich analysis of how everyday citizens in Latin America seek to reduce the burdens of crime on their lives through different forms of resistance. Drawing on fascinating case studies in Mexico, El Salvador, and Colombia this book offers important comparative insights into how Latin Americans confront crime amid state inefficacy and corruption. This work opens theoretical pathways and will provide important new avenues of thinking to students and scholars of Latin America as well as policymakers seeking to address some of the greatest challenges affecting the region.' Enrique Desmond Arias, Marxe Chair of Western Hemisphere Affairs, Baruch College, City University of New York 'This is a powerful combination of outstanding theorizing, elegant style, and courage. Eduardo Moncada takes us to a different level in understanding why, when and how civilians use varying strategies civilians to respond to criminal extortion. The ideas in this book are novel and exciting and will change the way we think about civilian responses to criminal groups. Only very few authors can conduct such courageous and extensive ethnographic work in so many countries - Mexico, El Salvador, and Colombia - and translate the findings with erudition, incisive theorizing and analytic rigor. The book is a must read for anyone interested in conflict, public insecurity, criminal rule, collective action, resistance, the surge of violence in Latin America and how these have deeply transformed politics in the region and everyday life for so many people.' Beatriz Magaloni, Professor of Political Science and Director of the Poverty, Violence and Governance Lab, Stanford University 'The scourge of crime and violence afflicts much of Latin America. Yet, victims are not passive. How and why do the responses of victimized communities vary? Through revealing comparative analysis and intensive fieldwork Moncada finds answers in the local context and political economy. This is a major contribution not only to the study of coercion and collective action, but also to the broader analysis of Latin America's distinctive political economy.' Ben Ross Schneider, Ford International Professor of Political Science, Massachusetts Institute of Technology 'This is a powerful, agenda-setting book about societal resistance to criminal extortion in Latin America. Based on impressive multi-method and multi-sited fieldwork, Moncada masterfully identifies and explains different paths of resistance, including everyday forms of resistance, vigilantism, and/or coproduction of order. Victims of extortion respond strategically to subnational conditions, particularly variations in criminal's time horizons; local political economies and corresponding level of collective action; and criminal capture of the police. Resisting Extortion is a pathbreaking book not only because of its theoretical apparatus and rich conceptual innovation but also because of its highly original fieldwork and deep ethnographic sensibility.' Deborah Yashar, Professor of Politics & International Affairs, Princeton University 'Moncada's well-chosen, carefully researched case studies compare the ways in which people have resisted the predations of organized crime in Latin America.' Richard Feinberg, Foreign Affairs 'This work is a welcome contribution to the literature on criminal violence in Latin America and opens a plethora of potential research pathways to build on Moncada's initial findings ... Highly recommended.' E. Acevedo, CHOICE 'Resisting Extortion provides a theoretically innovative and empirically compelling account of the dynamics of resistance to extortion. Scholars of criminal violence, citizen participation, and qualitative methodologists will all find invaluable insights within this carefully structured and argued book. Moncada succeeds in bringing victims back into the study of crime and governance - a significant contribution with potential to reshape future scholarship in each of these areas.' Janice Gallagher, Perspectives on Politics 'Resisting Extortion is a careful, thorough, and extraordinary reexamination of how people create security where the state cannot ensure the rule of law. Moncada's multicountry ethnography of extortion and security networks should be on the reading list of any scholar working with themes of security, violence, organized crime, the rule of law, or qualitative political science.' Calla Hummel, Latin American Politics and Society